Skip to content
Questions · Q1

Q.‘Have you come back?’ said the woman. ‘I thought that no one had come back.’ Does this statement give some clue about the story? If yes, what is it?

CBSENCERTSubjective· 3mImportance★★★★★est
6% · 1/18 Questions
✓ Free question

Yes — the line foreshadows the war's devastation of the narrator's family and exposes Mrs Dorling's guilty hope that no one would return.

Mrs Dorling's words, “Have you come back? I thought that no one had come back,” give an important clue about the story. They tell us that the narrator's family had been caught up in the persecution of the War — the quiet signals of the family's Jewish identity (the Hanukkah candle-holder) confirm this — and that such families were expected to be wiped out, never to return. The narrator is, in fact, the sole survivor.

The statement also reveals Mrs Dorling's character and situation. Far from being glad to see her old acquaintance's daughter alive, she is dismayed. Her reaction shows a guilty conscience: she had taken away all the family's precious possessions under the pretext of keeping them safe, and she had counted on no one coming back to reclaim them. Her cold refusal to recognise the narrator flows directly from this. Thus the line foreshadows both the tragedy of the family and the greed and dishonesty that drive the plot.

✓Final answer

Yes. The remark reveals that the narrator's family was persecuted in the War and was not expected to survive — she is the lone survivor — and it exposes Mrs Dorling's guilt: she had hoped no one would return to claim the belongings she had appropriated, which is why she coldly denies knowing the narrator.

Unlock everything free for 14 days

  • Full step-by-step solutions
  • Concept-first explanations
  • Methods, shortcuts & mistakes
  • PYQ mapping + timed mock tests

Full access for 14 days. No credit card required.