Skip to content
NCERT Exemplar · Q1

Q.Two students performed the same experiment separately and each one of them recorded two readings of mass which are given below. Correct reading of mass is 3.0 g. On the basis of given data, mark the correct option out of the following statements. Student A — Readings:

(i) 3.01 g,
(ii) 2.99 g
Student B — Readings:
(i) 3.05 g,
(ii) 2.95 g
(i) Results of both the students are neither accurate nor precise.
(ii) Results of student A are both precise and accurate.
(iii) Results of student B are neither precise nor accurate.
(iv) Results of student B are both precise and accurate.
CBSEMCQ· 1mImportance★★★★★est
51% · 45/89 Questions
✓ Free question

Accuracy refers to how close measurements are to the true value, while precision refers to how close repeated measurements are to each other. Student A's results are both accurate and precise, while Student B's results are accurate but not precise. Therefore, the correct option is (ii).

When evaluating experimental data, two key terms are used: accuracy and precision. Understanding the distinction between them is crucial.

Accuracy describes how close a measured value (or the average of several measured values) is to the true or accepted value. A measurement is accurate if it has a small systematic error.

Precision describes how close repeated measurements are to each other. It reflects the reproducibility of the measurements. A set of measurements is precise if they are tightly clustered, regardless of whether they are close to the true value. Precision is related to random error.

Think of it like target practice:

  • If all your shots are tightly grouped around the bullseye, you are both accurate and precise.
  • If all your shots are tightly grouped but far from the bullseye, you are precise but not accurate.
  • If your shots are scattered all over the target, but their average position is the bullseye, you are accurate but not precise.
  • If your shots are scattered and far from the bullseye, you are neither accurate nor precise.

Let's apply these concepts to the given data.

  1. Identify the True Value

    The problem states that the correct reading of mass is 3.0 g3.0 \text{ g}. This is our true value.

  2. Analyze Student A's Readings

    Student A's readings are 3.01 g3.01 \text{ g} and 2.99 g2.99 \text{ g}.

    • Assess Accuracy for Student A:

      To assess accuracy, we compare the average of the readings to the true value.

      Average for Student A =3.01 g+2.99 g2=6.00 g2=3.00 g= \frac{3.01 \text{ g} + 2.99 \text{ g}}{2} = \frac{6.00 \text{ g}}{2} = 3.00 \text{ g}.

      The average reading (3.00 g3.00 \text{ g}) is exactly equal to the true value (3.0 g3.0 \text{ g}). This indicates that Student A's results are accurate.

    • Assess Precision for Student A:

      To assess precision, we look at how close the individual readings are to each other.

      The readings are 3.01 g3.01 \text{ g} and 2.99 g2.99 \text{ g}. The difference between them is 3.01−2.99=0.02 g3.01 - 2.99 = 0.02 \text{ g}. This is a very small spread, meaning the readings are very close to each other. This indicates that Student A's results are precise.

    • Conclusion for Student A: Student A's results are both accurate and precise.

  3. Analyze Student B's Readings

    Student B's readings are 3.05 g3.05 \text{ g} and 2.95 g2.95 \text{ g}.

    • Assess Accuracy for Student B:

      Average for Student B =3.05 g+2.95 g2=6.00 g2=3.00 g= \frac{3.05 \text{ g} + 2.95 \text{ g}}{2} = \frac{6.00 \text{ g}}{2} = 3.00 \text{ g}.

      The average reading (3.00 g3.00 \text{ g}) is exactly equal to the true value (3.0 g3.0 \text{ g}). This indicates that Student B's results are accurate.

    • Assess Precision for Student B:

      The readings are 3.05 g3.05 \text{ g} and 2.95 g2.95 \text{ g}. The difference between them is 3.05−2.95=0.10 g3.05 - 2.95 = 0.10 \text{ g}. This spread (0.10 g0.10 \text{ g}) is significantly larger than Student A's spread (0.02 g0.02 \text{ g}). The readings are not very close to each other. This indicates that Student B's results are not precise.

    • Conclusion for Student B: Student B's results are accurate but not precise.

  4. Evaluate the Options

    Based on our analysis:

    • Student A: Accurate and Precise
    • Student B: Accurate but Not Precise

    Let's check the given options:

    1. Results of both the students are neither accurate nor precise. (Incorrect, Student A is both, Student B is accurate)
    2. Results of student A are both precise and accurate. (Correct, matches our conclusion for Student A)
    3. Results of student B are neither precise nor accurate. (Incorrect, Student B is accurate)
    4. Results of student B are both precise and accurate. (Incorrect, Student B is not precise)
✓Final answer

Based on the analysis, Student A's results are both precise and accurate, while Student B's results are accurate but not precise. Therefore, the correct option is (ii).

Unlock everything free for 14 days

  • Full step-by-step solutions
  • Concept-first explanations
  • Methods, shortcuts & mistakes
  • PYQ mapping + timed mock tests

Full access for 14 days. No credit card required.