Q.An element Δl=Δxi^ is placed at the origin and carries a large current I=10 A (Fig. 4.8). What is the magnetic field on the y-axis at a distance of 0.5 m. Δx=1 cm.
🔒You're viewing a preview — the full solution, concept, methods & PYQ mapping are locked.
🔒 Start your 14-day free trial to unlock the full solution →Concept understanding — Magnetic Force Balance
Magnetic Force Balance
When a current-carrying wire or coil sits in a magnetic field, it feels a force F=BILsinθ (or, for a point charge, F=qvBsinθ). On its own that force just pushes the conductor - but in many real situations the push is deliberately set up to CANCEL another force, so the whole system sits in equilibrium. That equilibrium condition - magnetic force balanced against weight, against another wire's magnetic force, or against a mechanical counterweight - is what "magnetic force balance" means, and it is also historically how the ampere itself was defined.
The balance condition
Whenever a conductor is in equilibrium under a magnetic force and one other force, the two must be equal and opposite:
BILsinθ=Fother
Solving this equation for whichever quantity is unknown (B, I, L, or the other force) is the entire skill in this class of problem - the only new step, beyond the force law itself, is correctly identifying what the magnetic force is opposing.
Case 1: a wire suspended against gravity
A straight horizontal wire of mass m and length l, carrying current I, can be held up ("floated") in mid-air by a horizontal magnetic field perpendicular to it. The upward magnetic force must equal the downward weight:
BIl=mg⟹B=Ilmg
For example, a 200g, 1.5m wire carrying 2A needs B=(2)(1.5)(0.2)(9.8)≈0.65T to stay suspended.
Case 2: two wires balancing each other
Two long parallel wires carrying currents I1,I2 exert a force per unit length on each other of 2πdμ0I1I2 (attractive if the currents run the same way, repulsive if opposite). If one wire is free to move, this magnetic force can itself balance that wire's weight:
2πhμ0I2L=mg⟹h=2πmgμ0I2L
This is exactly how a "current balance" apparatus works, and historically it is how the ampere was defined: the current that, flowing in two infinite parallel wires one metre apart, produces a force of exactly 2×10−7N per metre of length.
Case 3: balancing on a beam
A current-carrying coil arm hanging from one pan of a beam balance feels an extra force F=NBIl when only that arm sits in an external field. Re-balancing the beam means adding a mass m so that mg=NBIl.
Always check which length enters the formula - for a coil of N turns the force multiplies by N; for a single suspended straight wire it doesn't. …
Why this formula?
Magnetic Force Balance: Why the Key Formulas Hold
The Magnetic Force Balance describes when the magnetic force on a charged particle or current-carrying conductor is exactly balanced by another force (gravity, electric force, or tension). Let's build the reasoning step-by-step.
1. The Core Idea: What Does "Balance" Mean?
A force balance means the net force on an object is zero:
Fnet=0
For magnetic forces we use the Lorentz force law:
- On a moving charge: Fm=q(v×B)
- On a current-carrying wire: Fm=I(L×B)
When this is balanced by another force (say gravity Fg=mg):
Fm+Fother=0
2. Case 1: Charged Particle in Crossed Fields (Velocity Selector)
A charged particle moves perpendicular to both electric field E and magnetic field B.
- Electric force: Fe=qE (along E)
- Magnetic force: Fm=q(v×B) (perpendicular to both v and B)
For straight-line motion (no deflection), the two forces must cancel:
qE=qvB⇒v=BE
Key insight: Only particles with this exact speed pass undeflected — this is how velocity selectors work in mass spectrometers.
3. Case 2: Current-Carrying Wire Balanced by Gravity
A horizontal wire carrying current I sits in a perpendicular magnetic field B, suspended by strings.
The magnetic force on a straight wire is Fm=ILBsinθ; for a wire perpendicular to the field (θ=90∘), Fm=ILB. Setting this equal to the weight Fg=mg for equilibrium:
ILB=mg
Key insight: This balance lets you measure B if I, L, and m are known — the principle behind a current balance experiment.
4. Case 3: Circular Motion of a Charged Particle …
Concept: Biot–Savart law for a current element.
For a short element, dB=4πμ0r2Idl×r^. Here dl=Δxi^=(0.01 m)i^, I=10 A, and the point is on the y-axis at r=0.5 m, so r^=j^ and the angle between dl and r^ is 90∘. …
Using the Biot–Savart law for the current element, B=4πμ0r2IΔx=4×10−8 T, directed out of the page.
Why Biot–Savart (not the long-wire formula)
The segment Δx=1 cm is tiny compared with r=0.5 m, so it acts as a point source of field and we use the Biot–Savart law directly, with its 1/r2 fall-off:
dB=4πμ0r2Idl×r^.
1. Identify the vectors
The element is at the origin pointing along +x: dl=(0.01 m)i^. The field point is on the y-axis, so r=0.5j^ m and r^=j^. The angle between dl and r^ is 90∘.
2. Direction
i^×j^=k^,
so the field points along +z — out of the page. The magnitude of the cross product is Δxsin90∘=Δx.
3. Magnitude
Using 4πμ0=10−7 T⋅m/A and r=0.5 m: …
Method: Biot–Savart Law
The Biot–Savart law gives the magnetic field due to a small current element:
dB=4πμ0r2Idl×r^
Steps
1. Identify the given quantities
- Current element: dl=Δxi^=0.01i^ m
- Current: I=10 A
- Point of interest: on the y-axis at y=0.5 m
- μ0=4π×10−7 T⋅m/A
2. Determine the position vector and unit vector
From the origin to the point (0,0.5,0):
r=0.5j^ m,r=0.5 m,r^=j^
3. Compute the cross product dl×r^
dl×r^=(0.01i^)×(j^)=0.01k^
4. Apply the Biot–Savart law …
Common Mistakes in Magnetic Field Due to a Current Element (Biot–Savart Law)
Mistake 1: Forgetting the Vector Nature of the Cross Product
The error: Students often plug magnitudes into the Biot–Savart law without considering the direction of Δl×r^.
Why it happens: The formula dB=4πμ0r2Idlsinθ is memorised as a scalar, but θ is the angle between Δl and r^ — not just any angle in the diagram.
How to avoid: Always write the full vector form first:
ΔB=4πμ0r2IΔl×r^
Then compute the cross product explicitly. Here, Δl=Δxi^ and r^ points from the origin to the point on the y-axis, so r^=j^. Since i^×j^=k^, the field is along k^ (out of the page).
Mistake 2: Using the Wrong Distance r
The error: Taking r=0.5 m directly as the distance from the element to the field point.
Why it happens: The problem gives "distance on the y-axis = 0.5 m", which is the y-coordinate. But the current element is at the origin, so the distance from the element to the point (0,0.5) is indeed 0.5 m — this is correct here. However, students often confuse this when the element is not at the origin.
How to avoid: Always identify the position vector from the current element to the field point. Here:
- Element at (0,0,0)
- Field point at (0,0.5,0)
- So r=0.5j^ and r=0.5 m ✓
Mistake 3: Forgetting Unit Conversion for Δx
The error: Using Δx=1 cm as 1 in the formula without converting to metres.
Why it happens: The current is in amperes and distance in metres, but Δx is given in cm. Students overlook the mismatch.
How to avoid: Convert all lengths to metres before plugging in:
Δx=1 cm=0.01 m
The correct magnitude becomes:
∣ΔB∣=4πμ0r2IΔx=10−7×(0.5)210×0.01
Mistake 4: Confusing μ0/4π with μ0
The error: Using μ0=4π×10−7 directly without the 1/4π factor.
Why it happens: Many remember μ0=4π×10−7, but the Biot–Savart law has μ0/4π=10−7.
How to avoid: Memorise the constant as:
4πμ0=10−7 T⋅m/A
This is the number you actually multiply by. Using μ0 alone gives an answer 4π times too large.
--- …
- CBSE 2026Set ANNUAL1 markQ.Write dimensional formula of magnetic permeability.
›Reveal solutionSolution
From B = μ₀nI and force relations, [μ₀] = [M L T⁻² A⁻²].
Magnetic permeability μ₀ can be found from the force per unit length between two parallel current-carrying wires: F/l = μ₀ I₁I₂/(2πd). Rearranging, μ₀ = (F/l)(2πd)/(I₁I₂).
Dimensions:
- Force per unit length F/l has dimensions [M L T⁻²]/[L] = [M T⁻²]. …
- CBSE 2021Set ANNUAL1 markQ.A straight wire of mass 200g and length 1.5m carries a current of 2A. It is suspended in mid air by a uniform horizontal magnetic field B. Find the magnitude of B.
›Reveal solutionSolution
Equilibrium requires the upward magnetic force BIL to equal the weight mg; solving gives B≈0.65T.
A current-carrying straight wire placed in a magnetic field B experiences a force F=IL×B, of magnitude F=BILsinθ, where θ is the angle between the current direction and B. For the wire to remain suspended in mid-air (in equilibrium), this magnetic force must exactly balance the downward gravitational force (weight) on the wire, and it must point vertically upward — this requires B to be horizontal and perpendicular to the wire, so θ=90° and sinθ=1:
BIL=mg
…
🎓Unlock everything free for 14 days
- ✓Full step-by-step solutions
- ✓Concept-first explanations
- ✓Methods, shortcuts & mistakes
- ✓PYQ mapping + timed mock tests
Full access for 14 days. No credit card required.