Q.(a) Distinguish between isotopes and isobars, giving one example for each.
🔒You're viewing a preview — the full solution, concept, methods & PYQ mapping are locked.
🔒 Start your 14-day free trial to unlock the full solution →Part (a)Concept understanding — Nuclear Binding Energy and Mass Defect
A nucleus's actual measured mass is always slightly less than the sum of the masses of its separate protons, neutrons and electrons; this shortfall is the mass defect, Δm=[ZmH+(A−Z)mn]−m. By Einstein's relation E=mc2, that 'missing' mass corresponds to energy that was released when the nucleus formed -- the nuclear binding energy, B.E.=Δm(u)×931.4 MeV per u (using nuclear masses in unified mass units u, where 1u = 1.66x10^-27 kg). Dividing by the number of nucleons gives binding energy per nucleon, Bˉ=B.E./A, the real measure of a nuclide's stability. Plotted against mass number, Bˉ peaks sharply at light nuclides that are multiples of helium-4, climbs through medium-mass nuclides, and reaches its overall maximum (~8.79 MeV/nucleon) at iron-56, the single most tightly bound nuclide known, before falling off again for heavy nuclides. Because both fusing light nuclei and splitting heavy nuclei move the products toward that high-Bˉ peak, both processes release energy. …
Part (b)Concept understanding — Nuclear Density Calculation
Nuclear Density: Why All Nuclei Are Almost Equally Dense
Imagine you have a bag of marbles. If you pack them tightly, the density of the bag depends only on the marbles themselves — not on how many you put in. The nucleus behaves the same way. That's the core idea.
The Intuition
An atom's nucleus is made of protons and neutrons (collectively called nucleons). These nucleons are held together by the strong nuclear force, which is extremely short-ranged. Think of it like magnets: each nucleon only "feels" its immediate neighbours. So adding more nucleons doesn't compress the inner ones — it just adds a new layer on the outside.
This means the nucleus grows in volume proportionally to the number of nucleons. Double the number of nucleons, double the volume. And since mass also doubles, the density stays constant.
The Precise Statement
The nuclear radius R is experimentally found to follow:
R=R0A1/3
where:
- A = mass number (total protons + neutrons)
- R0≈1.2×10−15 m (a constant, about 1.2 femtometres)
R=R0A1/3
This is the nuclear radius formula. It's not a guess — it comes from scattering experiments where high-energy electrons or alpha particles bounce off nuclei.
Deriving the Density
The nucleus is roughly spherical, so its volume is:
V=34πR3=34π(R0A1/3)3=34πR03A
Notice: volume is directly proportional to A. The mass of the nucleus is approximately m≈A×(1.67×10−27 kg) (mass of one nucleon). So density:
ρ=volumemass=34πR03AA×mnucleon=34πR03mnucleon
The A cancels out completely. The density is a constant — independent of the nucleus size.
Nuclear density is independent of mass number A. All nuclei have approximately the same density.
The Numerical Value
Plug in the numbers:
- mnucleon≈1.67×10−27 kg
- R0≈1.2×10−15 m
ρ=34π(1.2×10−15)31.67×10−27≈2.3×1017 kg/m3
That's about 230 million tonnes per cubic centimetre. To put it in perspective: a sugar-cube-sized piece of nuclear matter would weigh as much as 230 million cars.
| Object | Density (kg/m³) |
|--------|-----------------|
| Water | 103 |
| Earth (average) | 5.5×103 |
| White dwarf star | 109 |
| Atomic nucleus | 2.3×1017 |
Why This Matters
This constancy of density tells us something profound: the strong nuclear force saturates. Each nucleon only interacts with its nearest neighbours, not with the whole nucleus. If the force were long-range (like gravity), density would increase with size. It doesn't — so the force is short-range. …
Why this formula?
Why Nuclear Density is Constant — The Reasoning
The most striking result about nuclear density is that it is roughly the same for all nuclei, regardless of size. This is not obvious — why wouldn't a larger nucleus be denser? The answer lies in how nuclear force works and how nucleons pack together.
Step 1: The nuclear volume formula
Experiments show that the radius of a nucleus is given by:
R=R0A1/3
where R0≈1.2×10−15 m (1.2 fm) and A is the mass number (total number of protons + neutrons).
The A1/3 dependence is the key. It means volume grows linearly with A, not faster.
Why A1/3? Because nucleons are packed as tightly as possible — like spheres in a close-packed arrangement. If you double the number of nucleons, you need to double the volume, so the radius must increase by 21/3.
Step 2: Volume from the radius
Assuming the nucleus is a sphere:
V=34πR3=34π(R0A1/3)3=34πR03A
Notice: the A1/3 cube gives A directly. So volume is proportional to A.
Step 3: Mass of the nucleus
The mass of the nucleus is approximately:
M≈A⋅mnucleon
where mnucleon≈1.67×10−27 kg (the average mass of a proton or neutron). The small mass defect from binding energy is negligible for this calculation.
Step 4: Density
Nuclear density ρ is mass divided by volume:
ρ=VM=34πR03AA⋅mnucleon=34πR03mnucleon
The A cancels completely. Nuclear density is independent of the nucleus size.
Step 5: The numerical value
Plugging in the numbers:
ρ=34π(1.2×10−15)31.67×10−27≈2.3×1017 kg/m3
ρnuclear≈2.3×1017 kg/m3 …
Part (a)
Isotopes vs isobars.
- Isotopes: same atomic number Z, different mass number A. Example: 612C and 614C.
- Isobars: same A, different Z. Example: 1840Ar and 2040Ca.
Mass defect. The mass of a nucleus is less than the sum of its free nucleons' masses because binding energy is released when they combine; by E=Δmc2 the released energy corresponds to a lost mass Δm (the mass defect). Example: for 24He, Δm≈0.0304 u, i.e. binding energy ≈28.3 MeV. …
Part (a): Isotopes share Z, isobars share A; a nucleus weighs less than its free nucleons by the mass defect Δm, which equals the binding energy (Δm≈0.0304 u for 24He). Part (b): Hg-198 & Au-197 are isotones, C-12 & C-14 isotopes, He-3 & H-3 isobars; R=R0A1/3 makes nuclear density constant, ≈2.3×1017 kg m−3.
Part (a)
Isotopes and isobars
- Isotopes — same atomic number Z, different mass number A (same element, different neutron count). Example: 612C and 614C (6 protons; 6 and 8 neutrons).
- Isobars — same mass number A, different Z. Example: 1840Ar and 2040Ca (40 nucleons each; 18 vs 20 protons).
Why the nuclear mass is less than its constituents
When free protons and neutrons bind into a nucleus, energy — the binding energy — is released. By mass–energy equivalence E=Δmc2, releasing energy means losing mass; the missing mass is the mass defect
Δm=[Zmp+(A−Z)mn]−mnucleus.
Example — helium-4:
- 2mp+2mn=2(1.007276)+2(1.008665)=4.031882 u
- m(24He)=4.001506 u
- Δm=0.030376 u ⇒Eb=0.030376×931.5≈28.3 MeV. …
Showing the 12 most recent of 17 on this concept.
- CBSE 2026Set A1 markMCQQ.The nuclear density is approximately (A) independent of mass number (B) directly proportional to mass number (C) inversely proportional to mass number (D) directly proportional to A^(1/3)
›Reveal solutionSolution
Nuclear radius R = R₀A^(1/3), so volume ∝ A and mass ∝ A, making density independent of A.
The nuclear radius follows the empirical relation R=R0A1/3, where R0≈1.2 fm and A is the mass number.
Volume of the nucleus: V=34πR3=34πR03A, so V∝A.
Mass of the nucleus: M≈A×mnucleon, so M∝A.
…
- CBSE 2026Set ANNUAL1 markQ.What do you mean by mass defect of a nucleus?
›Reveal solutionSolution
A bound nucleus weighs slightly LESS than the sum of its free, separate nucleons - that missing mass is the mass defect.
If you add up the masses of Z free protons and (A-Z) free neutrons that would make up a nucleus of mass number A, this sum is always slightly GREATER than the actual measured mass of the bound nucleus. This difference is called the mass defect:
delta_m = [Z*m_p + (A-Z)*m_n] - M(nucleus)
…
- CBSE 2026Set ANNUAL1 markMCQQ.For mass defect of 0.4% the binding energy of 1 kilogram material is:(a) 3.6 × 10^14 ergs(b) 3.6 × 10^-14 J(c) 3.6 × 10^-14 ergs(d) 3.6 × 10^14 J
›Reveal solutionSolution
Using Einstein's mass-energy relation E=Δmc2 with Δm=0.4% of 1 kg gives 3.6×1014J.
Mass defect Δm=0.4% of 1kg=0.004kg.
…
- CBSE 2025Set JS1 markMCQQ.The energy is emitted when two nuclei of masses m1 and m2 are fused together to make a nucleus of mass m. In this process: (A) (m1+m2)<m (B) (m1+m2)>m (C) (m1+m2)=m (D) m1m2>m2
›Reveal solutionSolution
Energy is released only if some mass disappears; the product mass m is less than m1+m2, so (m1+m2)>m — option (B).
Concept — mass–energy equivalence. In fusion, two light nuclei combine. If the process releases energy Q, that energy comes from a loss of mass (the mass defect Δm) through Einstein's relation E=Δmc2.
Reasoning.
Δm=(m1+m2)−m>0⇒Q=Δmc2>0. …
- CBSE 2025Set ANNUAL1 markMCQQ.The binding energy of a nucleus is equivalent to(a) mass of proton(b) mass of neutron(c) mass of nucleus(d) mass defect of nucleus
›Reveal solutionSolution
A nucleus's mass is always slightly less than the sum of the masses of its separate nucleons; this missing mass, the mass defect, is exactly equivalent (via E=mc2) to the binding energy released when the nucleus formed.
Mass defect: Δm=[Zmp+(A−Z)mn]−Mnucleus
Binding energy is the energy equivalent of this mass defect:
Eb=Δmc2
…
- CBSE 2025Set ANNUAL1 markMCQQ.The nuclei have their mass numbers in the ratio of 1:3. The ratio of their nuclear densities would be(a) (3)^(1/3) : 1(b) 1:1(c) 1:3(d) 3:1
›Reveal solutionSolution
Because the nuclear radius scales as R = R0 A^(1/3), the nuclear volume scales exactly as A, so density = mass/volume comes out essentially the same constant for every nucleus, regardless of A.
Nuclear radius: R = R0 A^(1/3), where R0 approx 1.2 fm is a constant.
Nuclear volume: V = (4/3) pi R^3 = (4/3) pi R0^3 A
Since nuclear mass is approximately proportional to A (mass number, roughly A times the nucleon mass), density:
rho = mass / volume is proportional to A / A = constant
…
- CBSE 2025Set ANNUAL1 markQ.The density of nuclear matter is independent of the size of the nucleus. (T/F)
›Reveal solutionSolution
This statement is True — nuclear density is essentially the same for all nuclei, independent of the mass number (size) of the nucleus.
The radius of a nucleus with mass number A is given empirically by R=R0A1/3, where R0≈1.2 fm is a constant. The nuclear volume is then V∝R3∝A, and since the nuclear mass is also proportional to A (each nucleon has roughly the same mass), the density …
- CBSE 2025Set ANNUAL1 markMCQQ.A nucleus ZXA has mass represented by M(A,Z). If Mp and Mn denote the mass of proton and neutron respectively and B⋅E, the binding energy in MeV, then(a) B⋅E=M(A,Z)−ZMp−(A−Z)Mn(b) B⋅E=[ZMp+AMn−M(A,Z)]C2(c) B⋅E=[Z⋅Mp+(A−Z)Mn−M(A,Z)]C2(d) B⋅E=[M(A,Z)−ZMp−(A−Z)Mn]C2
›Reveal solutionSolution
Binding energy equals the mass defect (sum of the masses of the free constituent nucleons minus the actual nuclear mass) multiplied by C2; matching this to the options gives option (c).
Mass defect
A nucleus ZXA contains Z protons and (A−Z) neutrons. If these nucleons existed freely (unbound), their total mass would be ZMp+(A−Z)Mn. The actual measured mass of the bound nucleus, M(A,Z), is less than this because some mass is converted into the energy that binds the nucleus together. This mass difference is the mass defect:
Δm=ZMp+(A−Z)Mn−M(A,Z)
Binding energy
By Einstein's mass-energy relation, this "missing" mass corresponds to the binding energy:
B⋅E=ΔmC2=[ZMp+(A−Z)Mn−M(A,Z)]C2
…
- CBSE 2025Set ANNUAL1 markMCQQ.If a star converts all the helium (He) nuclei completely into oxygen (O) nuclei, the energy released per oxygen nucleus is (mass of helium nucleus=4.0026a.m.u, mass of oxygen nucleus= 15.9994 a.m.u)(a) 7.6 MeV(b) 56.12MeV(c) 10.24MeV(d) 23.9MeV
›Reveal solutionSolution
4 He nuclei fuse into 1 O nucleus; the mass defect times 931.5MeV/u gives the energy released per O nucleus.
Since 4×4=16, the fusion of 4 helium (He-4) nuclei into one oxygen (O-16) nucleus is the reaction implied:
424He→ 816O
Mass of 4 He nuclei =4×4.0026=16.0104u. Mass of one O nucleus =15.9994u.
Δm=16.0104−15.9994=0.0110u …
- CBSE 2024Set ANNUAL1 markQ.What do you mean by mass defect of a nucleus?
›Reveal solutionSolution
A nucleus always weighs slightly less than the sum of its separate constituent nucleons; this 'missing' mass is the mass defect, and by E = mc^2 it corresponds to the nuclear binding energy.
For a nucleus ZAX made of Z protons and (A-Z) neutrons, the mass defect is defined as
Δm=[Zmp+(A−Z)mn]−Mnucleus
…
- CBSE 2024Set ANNUAL1 markQ.What is the ratio of nuclear densities of two nuclei having mass number 1:4?
›Reveal solutionSolution
Nuclear density is (almost exactly) the same for all nuclei, regardless of mass number.
Nuclear density is given by ρ=volumemass=34πR3mA, where the nuclear radius scales as R=R0A1/3. Substituting:
ρ=34π(R0A1/3)3mA=34πR03AmA=34πR03m
…
- CBSE 2024Set ANNUAL1 markMCQQ.Two nuclei have mass numbers in the ratio 1:3, the ratio of the nuclear densities are(a) 3:1(b) 1:1(c) 1:9(d) 1:3
›Reveal solutionSolution
Nuclear density ρ=mass/volume∝A/A3⋅3= constant, since the nuclear radius R∝A1/3 makes volume ∝A — so it does not depend on mass number at all.
The empirical nuclear radius formula is R=R0A1/3, where R0≈1.2fm is a constant and A is the mass number. The nuclear volume is
V=34πR3=34πR03A
which is directly proportional to A. The nuclear mass is also (to good approximation) proportional to A, since M≈Au (each nucleon contributes roughly one atomic mass unit).
So the nuclear density is …
🎓Unlock everything free for 14 days
- ✓Full step-by-step solutions
- ✓Concept-first explanations
- ✓Methods, shortcuts & mistakes
- ✓PYQ mapping + timed mock tests
Full access for 14 days. No credit card required.