Why is a retiring/deceased partner entitled to a share of goodwill of the firm?

Short Answer Questions · Q5

Q. Why is a retiring/deceased partner entitled to a share of goodwill of the firm?

Chhattisgarh CgbseTextbookSubjective· 3mImportance★★★★★

84% · 52/62 Questions

🔒 Locked · start free trial →

You're viewing a preview — the full solution, concept, methods & PYQ mapping are locked.

Start your 14-day free trial to unlock the full solution →

Concept understanding — Partner Retirement Methods

Partner Retirement Methods – A First Look

Think of a partnership like a three-legged race. Three friends tie their legs together and run. Now imagine one friend wants to stop running mid-race. The other two can't just untie and keep going — they have to settle accounts with the leaving friend first. How much does the leaving friend get? Who pays? That's what retirement of a partner is about.

What Does "Retirement of a Partner" Mean?

When a partner leaves the firm (by choice, age, or agreement), the remaining partners continue the business. The retiring partner is entitled to their share of the firm's net worth — not just their original capital, but also their share of accumulated profits, reserves, revaluation gains, and goodwill.

The key idea: the retiring partner's claim = what they brought in + what the firm earned on their behalf – what they've already taken out.

Why Does This Matter?

If you just give the retiring partner their capital back, you're shortchanging them. The firm may have grown, built up reserves, or owned assets that appreciated. Conversely, if the firm has losses, the retiring partner must bear their share. Proper accounting ensures fairness — no one gets cheated, and the remaining partners don't overpay.

The Accounting Treatment – Step by Step

The NCERT Class-12 textbook follows a clear sequence. Let's walk through it.

Step 1: Revalue Assets and Reassess Liabilities

The firm's balance sheet may not reflect current values. So we create a Revaluation Account.

Note

Revaluation Account is a nominal account. It captures gains (credit) and losses (debit) from revaluing assets and liabilities.

Journal entry:

If asset value increases: Debit Asset A/c, Credit Revaluation A/c
If liability increases: Debit Revaluation A/c, Credit Liability A/c

The profit or loss on revaluation is then transferred to all partners' capital accounts in their old profit-sharing ratio.

Step 2: Adjust for Goodwill

The retiring partner is entitled to their share of the firm's goodwill. The remaining partners compensate them because they'll continue to benefit from the firm's reputation.

Treatment (as per NCERT):

Calculate the firm's total goodwill (agreed value).
Retiring partner's share = Total goodwill × Retiring partner's profit share.
The remaining partners debit their capital accounts in their gaining ratio (new ratio – old ratio) and credit the retiring partner's capital account.

Journal entry:

Remaining Partners' Capital A/c (individually)   Dr.
    To Retiring Partner's Capital A/c

Step 3: Transfer Reserves and Accumulated Profits

Any General Reserve, Profit & Loss A/c (credit balance), or accumulated profits belong to all partners. The retiring partner's share is transferred to their capital account.

Journal entry:

General Reserve A/c   Dr.
Profit & Loss A/c     Dr.
    To All Partners' Capital A/c (in old ratio)

Step 4: Settle the Retiring Partner's Account

After all adjustments, the retiring partner's capital account shows the final amount due. This is paid either in cash or transferred to a loan account if the firm can't pay immediately.

Journal entry:

Retiring Partner's Capital A/c   Dr.
    To Bank A/c (or Retiring Partner's Loan A/c)

The Capital Account Format (as per NCERT)

Here's how a retiring partner's capital account looks in the ledger:

Dr.	Retiring Partner's Capital Account	Cr.
Particulars	Amount (₹)	Particulars
To Revaluation A/c (loss)	xxx	By Balance b/d
To Goodwill A/c (if written off)	xxx	By Revaluation A/c (gain)
To Retiring Partner's Loan A/c	xxx	By General Reserve A/c
To Bank A/c (final payment)	xxx	By Profit & Loss A/c
		By Goodwill A/c (remaining partners)
		By Interest on Capital (if any)
Total	xxx	Total

Start your 14-day free trial to unlock the full solution →

A retiring or deceased partner is entitled to a share of the firm's goodwill because goodwill represents the firm's ability to earn super-profits, built over time through the collective efforts of all partners, including the one who is leaving. When a partner retires or dies, the continuing partners will enjoy the future benefits of this goodwill without the outgoing partner's contribution. Therefore, the outgoing partner must be compensated for their sacrificed share of this intangible asset.

The journal entry to record this is a debit to the continuing partners' capital accounts in their gaining ratio (not the old ratio) and a credit to the retiring partner's capital account.

Gaining Ratio = New Ratio - Old Ratio

Watch out

A common mistake is to use the old profit-sharing ratio to adjust goodwill. The adjustment must always be in the gaining ratio of the continuing partners.

Journal Entry for Goodwill Adjustment (when no goodwill account is raised):

Date	Particulars	L.F.	Debit (₹)	Credit (₹)
	Continuing Partner 1's Capital A/c Dr.		(Share of gain)

Start your 14-day free trial to unlock the full solution →

A retiring or deceased partner is entitled to a share of the firm’s goodwill because the goodwill was built during their tenure, and the continuing partners will benefit from it after the partner leaves. The retiring partner’s share is compensated by the continuing partners in their gaining ratio.

Why a Retiring/Deceased Partner is Entitled to Goodwill

Goodwill represents the firm’s ability to earn super profits — it is an intangible asset built over time through the efforts, reputation, and client relationships of all partners. When a partner retires or dies, the continuing partners will continue to enjoy the benefits of this goodwill without sharing it with the outgoing partner. Therefore, the outgoing partner must be compensated for their share of the goodwill that they helped create.

The accounting treatment follows the Gaining Ratio principle: the continuing partners who gain the retiring partner’s share of profits must pay for it. The retiring partner’s capital account is credited with their share of goodwill, and the continuing partners’ capital accounts are debited in their gaining ratio.

Watch out

A common mistake is to debit the goodwill account or to treat goodwill compensation as a payment from the firm. In reality, it is a private arrangement between the continuing partners and the retiring partner — the firm’s books only adjust the partners’ capital accounts. The goodwill account itself is not touched unless it is already appearing in the books.

Step-by-Step Solution

Let’s assume a standard scenario (since the question did not provide specific figures, I will use a representative example to illustrate the concept and entries):

Example Data:

Partners: A, B, C sharing profits in ratio 3:2:1.
C retires.
Goodwill of the firm is valued at ₹1,20,000.
No goodwill account appears in the books.

Step 1: Calculate C’s share of goodwill

C’s share = 1/6 of ₹1,20,000 = ₹20,000.

Step 2: Determine gaining ratio of continuing partners

Old ratio: A = 3/6, B = 2/6, C = 1/6.

New ratio after C’s retirement: A and B will share profits in their old ratio (3:2) unless otherwise agreed.

Gaining ratio = New ratio – Old ratio.

A gains: 3/5 – 3/6 = (18 – 15)/30 = 3/30 = 1/10.

B gains: 2/5 – 2/6 = (12 – 10)/30 = 2/30 = 1/15.

Gaining ratio = 1/10 : 1/15 = 3:2.

Step 3: Journal entry to adjust goodwill

Particulars	Debit (₹)	Credit (₹)
A’s Capital A/c Dr.	12,000
B’s Capital A/c Dr.	8,000
To C’s Capital A/c		20,000
(Being C’s share of goodwill adjusted in gaining ratio 3:2)

Working Note:

A’s contribution = ₹20,000 × 3/5 = ₹12,000
B’s contribution = ₹20,000 × 2/5 = ₹8,000

Tip

If the goodwill account already appears in the books at an old value, it must be written off first by debiting all partners’ capital accounts in their old ratio. Then the new goodwill adjustment is done as above.

If Goodwill Already Appears in the Books

Suppose the firm’s books show a goodwill account of ₹60,000 (old value). The steps are:

Write off existing goodwill: Debit all partners’ capital accounts in old ratio and credit goodwill account.
Adjust for new goodwill: Same as above — debit continuing partners in gaining ratio, credit retiring partner.

Journal entries:

Particulars	Debit (₹)	Credit (₹)
A’s Capital A/c Dr. (3/6 of 60,000)	30,000
B’s Capital A/c Dr. (2/6 of 60,000)	20,000
C’s Capital A/c Dr. (1/6 of 60,000)	10,000
To Goodwill A/c		60,000
(Being existing goodwill written off among all partners in old ratio)
A’s Capital A/c Dr.	12,000
B’s Capital A/c Dr.	8,000
To C’s Capital A/c		20,000
(Being C’s share of new goodwill adjusted in gaining ratio)

Treatment in the Retiring Partner’s Capital Account …

Start your 14-day free trial to unlock the full solution →

←Previous question · questions-for-practiceQ4 — Why do firms revalue assets and reassess their liabilities on retireme…→Next question · questions-for-practiceQ1 — Explain the modes of payment to a retiring partner.

Q.Why is a retiring/deceased partner entitled to a share of goodwill of the firm?

Why a Retiring/Deceased Partner is Entitled to Goodwill

Step-by-Step Solution

If Goodwill Already Appears in the Books

Treatment in the Retiring Partner’s Capital Account …

🎓Unlock everything free for 14 days

Unlock everything free for 14 days