Q.If a green plant is kept in dark with proper ventilation, can this plant carry out photosynthesis? Can anything be given as supplement to maintain its growth or survival?
Imagine a solar panel. Sunlight hits it, and out comes electricity. The light reaction in photosynthesis is exactly that — a solar panel built into every green leaf. But instead of electricity, it produces two chemical fuels: ATP (the energy currency of the cell) and NADPH (a reducing agent that carries high-energy electrons). These two molecules are then used in the next phase (the Calvin cycle) to build glucose from carbon dioxide.
The key insight: the light reaction is the only part of photosynthesis that directly uses light. Everything after it runs on the ATP and NADPH it produces.
Where does it happen?
Inside the chloroplast, there are flattened, disc-like sacs called thylakoids. Their membranes are packed with pigment molecules (chlorophyll a, chlorophyll b, carotenoids) and protein complexes. This is the stage. The space inside the thylakoid is the lumen; the fluid outside is the stroma.
What actually happens? (The precise statement)
When a photon of light strikes a chlorophyll molecule, an electron gets excited — it jumps to a higher energy level. That excited electron is then passed through a chain of carriers embedded in the thylakoid membrane, like a bucket brigade. As it moves, its energy is used to pump protons (H+) from the stroma into the thylakoid lumen, building up a concentration gradient. That gradient drives ATP synthesis (via ATP synthase). Meanwhile, the electron eventually ends up reducing NADP+ to NADPH.
But here's the catch: the chlorophyll that lost an electron needs to replace it. That electron comes from water (H2O). Splitting water releases oxygen gas (O2) as a byproduct — that's the oxygen we breathe.
2H2O+2NADP++3ADP+3PilightO2+2NADPH+3ATP
The two photosystems: a closer look
There are two distinct pigment systems, Photosystem II (PSII) and Photosystem I (PSI), named in the order they were discovered, not the order they work. Light hits both.
PSII absorbs light, excites an electron, and passes it to an electron acceptor. The electron hole in PSII is filled by splitting water. This releases O2 and protons into the lumen.
The electron travels down an electron transport chain (cytochrome b6f complex), pumping protons along the way.
The electron reaches PSI, which also absorbs light and re-excites the electron to an even higher energy level.
That high-energy electron is finally used to reduce NADP+ to NADPH.
The proton gradient built up during step 2 drives ATP synthase to make ATP. This entire flow is called non-cyclic photophosphorylation — the most common pathway.
Note
There is also a cyclic pathway where electrons from PSI cycle back to the electron transport chain instead of reducing NADP+. This produces only ATP, no NADPH or oxygen. It happens when the cell needs extra ATP.
No, a green plant kept in the dark cannot carry out photosynthesis, even with proper ventilation.
Photosynthesis requires light to drive the light reactions — the photochemical events (water splitting, electron excitation, ATP and NADPH formation) — which take place on the thylakoid membrane and cannot occur without light.
Without these light reactions, no ATP or NADPH is generated, and the biosynthetic (dark) reactions that depend entirely on them will also stop after continuing only briefly on any reserves.
Ventilation supplies CO2 and removes waste gases, but CO2 availability alone cannot substitute for the light energy that photosynthesis fundamentally requires; the plant remains unable to manufacture its own food (it can no longer function as an autotroph) under these conditions. …
A green plant cannot photosynthesise without light no matter how well ventilated it is, since light is essential for the light reactions; to survive it would need to be given ready-made organic food, as an autotroph cannot manufacture its own food without light.
Green plants are described as autotrophs specifically because they can manufacture their own organic food, through photosynthesis, using light energy. This is what fundamentally distinguishes them from heterotrophs, which must obtain food from an external source. Photosynthesis begins with the light reaction — a genuinely photochemical process in which light striking the pigments of the two photosystems excites electrons, drives their transport, splits water, and ultimately produces ATP and NADPH. None of this can happen without light, since it is the light itself that excites the electrons in the reaction-centre chlorophyll molecules. …
Method 1 — Separate what ventilation supplies from what light supplies
Recall that photosynthesis begins with the light reaction, which is genuinely photochemical — it cannot occur without light exciting electrons at the reaction centres.
Recognise that ventilation only affects CO2/O2 gas exchange, not light availability — good ventilation cannot substitute for the missing light. …