Skip to content

Physics · Ch 5 — Magnetism and Matter

The Electrostatic Analog

5.2.4

The Electrostatic Analog

The Electrostatic Analog

The key insight is that the magnetic field of a bar magnet at large distances behaves exactly like the electric field of an electric dipole. This allows us to translate all known results from electrostatics into magnetism by making a simple substitution.

The Replacement Rule:

To go from an electric dipole (dipole moment p⃗\vec{p}) to a magnetic dipole (magnetic moment m⃗\vec{m}), replace:

  • E⃗→B⃗\vec{E} \rightarrow \vec{B}
  • p⃗→m⃗\vec{p} \rightarrow \vec{m}
  • 14πε0→μ04π\frac{1}{4\pi\varepsilon_0} \rightarrow \frac{\mu_0}{4\pi}

This works because the mathematical forms of the field equations are identical.


Field Expressions for a Short Bar Magnet

For a bar magnet of length ll, at distances r≫lr \gg l, the magnet behaves as a point dipole.

1. Equatorial Field (B⃗E\vec{B}_E)

On the perpendicular bisector of the magnet (the equatorial line), the field is:

B⃗E=−μ04πm⃗r3\vec{B}_E = -\frac{\mu_0}{4\pi} \frac{\vec{m}}{r^3}

  • The negative sign indicates the field direction is opposite to the magnetic moment m⃗\vec{m}.
  • This is analogous to the equatorial field of an electric dipole: E⃗E=−14πε0p⃗r3\vec{E}_E = -\frac{1}{4\pi\varepsilon_0} \frac{\vec{p}}{r^3}.

2. Axial Field (B⃗A\vec{B}_A)

On the axis of the magnet (the line through its poles), the field is:

B⃗A=μ04π2m⃗r3\vec{B}_A = \frac{\mu_0}{4\pi} \frac{2\vec{m}}{r^3}

  • The field is parallel to m⃗\vec{m} and twice as strong as the equatorial field at the same distance.
  • This is analogous to the axial field of an electric dipole: E⃗A=14πε02p⃗r3\vec{E}_A = \frac{1}{4\pi\varepsilon_0} \frac{2\vec{p}}{r^3}.
  • This equation is the vector form of Eq. (5.1) from the chapter.

Application: Equilibrium of Two Magnetic Dipoles (Example 5.2)

Consider two identical magnetic dipoles P (fixed at O) and Q (movable). The field of P at any point is given by the axial or equatorial formula above.

  • Stable equilibrium occurs when m⃗Q\vec{m}_Q is parallel to B⃗P\vec{B}_P (minimum energy).
  • Unstable equilibrium occurs when m⃗Q\vec{m}_Q is anti-parallel to B⃗P\vec{B}_P (maximum energy).

For the configurations in Figure 5.4: …

Table 5.1The Dipole Analogy
QuantityElectrostaticsMagnetism
(replacement)1/ε01/\varepsilon_0μ0\mu_0
Dipole momentp\mathbf{p}m\mathbf{m}
Equatorial field for a short dipole−p/4πε0r3-\mathbf{p}/4\pi\varepsilon_0 r^3−μ0m/4πr3-\mu_0\mathbf{m}/4\pi r^3
Axial field for a short dipole2p/4πε0r32\mathbf{p}/4\pi\varepsilon_0 r^3μ02m/4πr3\mu_0 2\mathbf{m}/4\pi r^3
External field: torquep×E\mathbf{p}\times\mathbf{E}m×B\mathbf{m}\times\mathbf{B}