- (i) Distinguish between direct tax and indirect tax with the help of suitable examples. (ii) Explain the 'redistribution of income' objective of the Government Budget. OR
- (i) Suppose the following data is presented for an imaginary economy:
| S.No. | Items | Amount (in ₹ Crore) |
|---|---|---|
| (i) | Tax Receipts | 1,200 |
| (ii) | Revenue Expenditure | 3,700 |
| (iii) | Non-Tax Receipts | 2,000 |
| (iv) | Recovery of Loans | 145 |
| (v) | Capital Expenditure | 500 |
| (vi) | Disinvestment | 120 |
| (vii) | Interest Payments | 1,070 |
Calculate Revenue Deficit and Fiscal Deficit. (ii) Differentiate between public provision and public production.
🔒You're viewing a preview — the full solution, concept, methods & PYQ mapping are locked.
🔒 Start your 14-day free trial to unlock the full solution →Part (a)Concept understanding — Goods And Services Tax
Goods and Services Tax (GST)
Start with what you already know
Walk into any shop — a chemist, a mobile store, a restaurant — and look at your bill. At the bottom, you will see a line: GST @ 5% or GST @ 12% or GST @ 18%. That extra amount is not pocketed by the shopkeeper. It goes to the government. But why is there a separate tax called GST, and not just "sales tax" or "VAT" like before?
The answer lies in a simple problem: before GST, every state had its own tax system. A truck carrying goods from Maharashtra to Karnataka would be stopped at checkposts, pay entry tax, octroi, and state VAT — each time adding cost and delay. GST was designed to make India one unified market.
The precise meaning
Goods and Services Tax (GST) is a comprehensive, multi-stage, destination-based indirect tax levied on every value addition in the supply chain — from manufacture to final consumption.
Let me unpack each part of that definition.
Comprehensive — It replaced a dozen central and state taxes (excise duty, service tax, VAT, octroi, entry tax, luxury tax, etc.) with a single tax.
Multi-stage — A product passes through several stages: raw material → manufacturer → wholesaler → retailer → consumer. GST is collected at every stage where value is added.
Destination-based — The tax revenue goes to the state where the goods are consumed, not where they are produced. If a car is made in Gujarat but sold in Bihar, Bihar gets the GST.
Value addition — This is the key idea. A manufacturer buys steel for ₹100, pays 18% GST (₹18). He uses the steel to make a machine and sells it for ₹200. He collects 18% GST (₹36) from the buyer. But he does not pay ₹36 to the government — he pays only ₹18 (₹36 minus the ₹18 he already paid on steel). This is called Input Tax Credit (ITC).
Input Tax Credit is the heart of GST. It prevents "tax on tax" (cascading). Under the old system, a manufacturer paid tax on his inputs, then paid tax again on the full selling price — effectively taxing the tax. GST eliminates this.
How GST works: a simple chain
Imagine a wooden chair.
-
Logger sells timber to a furniture maker for ₹1,000. GST @ 18% = ₹180. Logger deposits ₹180 with the government.
-
Furniture maker uses the timber, adds value (labour, design), and sells the chair to a wholesaler for ₹2,000. GST on sale = ₹360. But he claims ITC of ₹180 (the tax he already paid on timber). He deposits only ₹180 (₹360 − ₹180).
-
Wholesaler sells to a retailer for ₹3,000. GST = ₹540. ITC = ₹360. Deposits ₹180.
-
Retailer sells to you, the consumer, for ₹4,000. GST = ₹720. ITC = ₹540. Deposits ₹180.
Total tax collected = ₹180 + ₹180 + ₹180 + ₹180 = ₹720 — exactly 18% of the final price ₹4,000.
Notice: the government collects the same total tax (₹720) whether it collects it in one lump from the retailer or in four small instalments from each stage. The difference is that everyone in the chain is incentivised to maintain proper invoices because they need ITC. This reduces tax evasion.
Why GST matters for the economy
Removed cascading — Earlier, a product bore "tax on tax". A study by the National Institute of Public Finance and Policy estimated that cascading added 25–30% to the final price of many goods. GST removed that.
Made India a common market — Before GST, a truck moving from Delhi to Chennai spent 60–70 hours at state borders in paperwork. After GST, interstate checkposts were dismantled. Logistics costs fell.
Increased tax base — Because every business wants ITC, they must file returns and show purchases from registered suppliers. This pulls informal businesses into the tax net.
Simplified compliance — Instead of filing separate returns for excise, service tax, and VAT, a business files one GST return.
The three-tier structure
GST in India is not a single rate. It has three components:
| Component | Levied by | Applies to |
|---|---|---|
| CGST (Central GST) | Central Government | Intra-state sales |
| SGST (State GST) | State Government | Intra-state sales |
| IGST (Integrated GST) | Central Government | Inter-state sales |
For a sale within the same state (say, a shop in Delhi selling to a customer in Delhi), the total GST is split equally: 9% CGST + 9% SGST = 18% total.
For a sale across states (Delhi to Mumbai), only IGST is charged (18%). The central government collects it and later transfers the state's share to Maharashtra (the destination state). …
Part (b)Concept understanding — Fiscal Deficit Definition
Fiscal Deficit: What It Really Means
Think of your household budget. If your monthly expenses exceed your income, you have a shortfall. You cover it by borrowing from someone — a friend, a bank. That shortfall is your personal "deficit."
Now scale that up to the entire country. The government earns money (mostly through taxes) and spends money (on roads, salaries, defence, subsidies). When the government's total spending exceeds its total non-borrowed income, it runs a fiscal deficit. It's the gap the government must fill by borrowing.
The Precise Definition (NCERT Class 12)
The NCERT Macroeconomics textbook defines fiscal deficit as:
Fiscal Deficit = Total Expenditure − Total Receipts excluding borrowings
Let's unpack that. "Total Receipts excluding borrowings" means all the money the government gets without going into debt — mainly tax revenue and non-tax revenue (like fees, dividends from public sector companies, etc.). Borrowings are not counted as "receipts" here because they are the source of finance for the deficit, not income.
So the formula is:
Fiscal Deficit=Total Expenditure−(Revenue Receipts + Non-debt Capital Receipts)
Where:
- Total Expenditure = Revenue Expenditure (day-to-day running costs) + Capital Expenditure (building assets like highways, dams)
- Revenue Receipts = Tax revenue + Non-tax revenue (fees, fines, dividends)
- Non-debt Capital Receipts = Money from selling government assets (disinvestment), loan recoveries — these don't create debt
The fiscal deficit is not the same as "total borrowing." It is the amount that must be borrowed. In practice, the government covers this gap by:
- Borrowing from the market (selling bonds)
- Borrowing from the RBI
- Drawing down cash balances
Why Does It Matter?
A fiscal deficit isn't automatically bad — it depends on why it exists and how it's financed.
When it's good: If the government borrows to build a national highway network, that creates jobs, boosts transport, and generates future tax revenue. The deficit is an investment.
When it's bad: If the deficit is caused by wasteful subsidies or paying salaries without any productive outcome, and the government keeps borrowing year after year, it piles up debt. Future generations must repay it. Large deficits can also fuel inflation if the RBI prints money to finance them.
The fiscal deficit is the single most watched number in the Union Budget. It tells you how much the government is living beyond its means. A high fiscal deficit (say, above 6% of GDP) signals stress; a low one (below 3%) signals fiscal discipline.
A Simple Diagram (in words)
Imagine a vertical bar representing total government expenditure. Below it, a shorter bar represents total receipts (excluding borrowings). The gap between the top of the expenditure bar and the top of the receipts bar is the fiscal deficit. That gap is filled by borrowings.
Total Expenditure: |████████████████████████████████|
| |
| FISCAL DEFICIT |
| (borrowings) |
Total Receipts: |████████████████████████ |
| |
| Revenue + Non-debt Capital |
|________________________________|
``` …
Part (a)
- Direct tax vs Indirect tax. A direct tax is one whose burden (incidence) and payment (impact) fall on the same person — it cannot be shifted to another. It is levied on income or wealth. Examples: income tax, corporate tax. An indirect tax is levied on goods and services, so its impact and incidence fall on different persons — the seller pays it to the government but shifts the burden to the buyer through a higher price. Examples: GST, customs duty.
- 'Redistribution of income' objective. Through its budget the government tries to reduce inequalities of income and wealth. On the revenue side it taxes the rich more heavily (progressive direct taxes); on the expenditure side it spends on subsidies, free/subsidised services and transfer payments (old-age pensions, scholarships, MGNREGA wages) that raise the real income of the poor. The net effect is a transfer of purchasing power from the well-off to the weaker sections, promoting equity. …
(a) Direct tax (non-shiftable, on income — e.g., income tax) vs indirect tax (shiftable, on goods — e.g., GST); the budget redistributes income via progressive taxes and welfare spending.
(b) Revenue Deficit =₹500 crore, Fiscal Deficit =₹735 crore; public provision = government financing/making a good available, public production = government itself producing it.
Part (a)
(i) Direct Tax vs Indirect Tax
A tax is classified by whether its burden can be shifted.
| Basis | Direct Tax | Indirect Tax |
|---|---|---|
| Incidence & impact | Fall on the same person (cannot be shifted) | Fall on different persons (shifted to the buyer) |
| Levied on | Income and wealth | Goods and services |
| Nature | Generally progressive | Generally proportional/regressive |
| Examples | Income tax, corporate tax | GST, customs duty, excise |
The person who pays a direct tax bears it himself. With an indirect tax, the seller deposits the tax but recovers it from the consumer through a higher price, so the ultimate burden shifts.
(ii) Redistribution of Income Objective
A major aim of the government budget is to reduce inequalities in the distribution of income and wealth so that growth is inclusive. The government works from both sides of the budget:
- Revenue side: progressive direct taxation — higher income groups are taxed at higher rates, reducing their disposable income.
- Expenditure side: the funds so raised are spent on subsidies, public goods, and transfer payments (pensions, scholarships, employment-guarantee wages, subsidised food) that raise the real income of the poor. …
- CA Foundation 2026Set jan-20261 markMCQQ.Which of following taxes has not been replaced by the Goods and Service Tax? (A) VAT (B) Income Tax (C) Excise duty (D) Service Tax
›Reveal solutionSolution
GST is an indirect tax that merged many indirect levies; Income Tax is a direct tax and continues to exist independently.
Reasoning
- GST replaced central and state indirect taxes such as Central Excise Duty (C), Service Tax (D), and VAT (A), among others (CST, entertainment tax, octroi, etc.).
- Income Tax is a direct tax on income, outside the scope of GST, and was never subsumed. …
- JAC Jharkhand Intermediate Class 12 (Commerce) 2026Set ANNUAL1 markMCQQ.Which of the following is known as paper tax?(a) Income tax(b) Corporation tax(c) Wealth tax(d) Customs duty
›Reveal solutionSolution
Wealth tax is the 'paper tax'.
A tax that remains largely on paper and collects very little actual revenue (because of exemptions and evasion) is called a paper tax. In India the wealth tax was such a tax — it yielded negligible revenue relative to the cost o …
- JAC Jharkhand Intermediate Class 12 (Commerce) 2026Set ANNUAL1 markMCQQ.What is the difference between Revenue expenditure and Revenue receipts called?(a) Fiscal deficit(b) Primary deficit(c) Trade deficit(d) Revenue deficit
›Reveal solutionSolution
Revenue expenditure minus revenue receipts = revenue deficit.
Revenue deficit = Revenue expenditure − Revenue receipts. It shows that the government's revenue income falls short of its revenue (routine) expenditure, so it must borrow or use capital receipts to meet current spending. (Fiscal deficit is total expenditure minus total receipts other th …
- JAC Jharkhand Intermediate Class 12 (Commerce) 2026Set ANNUAL1 markMCQQ.Which is included in indirect tax?(a) Income tax(b) Wealth tax(c) Excise duty(d) Gift tax
›Reveal solutionSolution
Excise duty is an indirect tax.
An indirect tax is levied on goods and services and its burden can be shifted from the payer to the final consumer. Excise duty (a tax on the production of goods) is an indirect tax. Income tax, wealth tax and gift tax are **di …
- CA Foundation 2025Set jan-20251 markMCQQ.Which of the following is applied on inter-state movement of goods and services and on imports and exports ? (A) CGST (B) SGST (C) IGST (D) Income tax
›Reveal solutionSolution
IGST (Integrated GST) applies to inter-state supplies and to imports/exports; CGST and SGST apply only within a state.
Step 1 — The GST structure
- CGST + SGST are charged together on an intra-state (within one state) supply.
- IGST is charged on an inter-state supply and on imports and exports (treated as inter-state), and is collected by the Centre, then shared.
Step 2 — Match the stem
The question specifies inter-state movement and imports/exports — that is exactly the scope of IGST. …
- JAC Jharkhand Intermediate Class 12 (Commerce) 2025Set ANNUAL1 markMCQQ.What is balanced budget?(a) Receipt > Expenditure(b) Expenditure > Receipt(c) Receipt < Expenditure(d) Receipt = Expenditure
›Reveal solutionSolution
Balanced budget: receipts = expenditure.
A balanced budget is one in which the government's estimated receipts are equal to its estimated expenditure (Receipts = Expenditure). If receipts exceed expenditure it is a surplus budget, and if expenditure exceeds receipts it is …
- CA Foundation 2024Set sep-20241 markMCQQ.Under which Supreme Court verdict do the Union and State Legislatures have "equal, simultaneous and unique powers" to make laws on Goods and Services Tax (GST) ? (A) June 2020 verdict (B) July 2021 verdict (C) Feb. 2022 verdict (D) May 2022 verdict
›Reveal solutionSolution
The Supreme Court's May 2022 judgment recognised that the Union and States have equal, simultaneous and unique powers to make GST laws.
Step 1 — Recall the context
GST is a concurrent tax: both the Centre (CGST/IGST) and the States (SGST) legislate on it. A key constitutional question was whether GST Council recommendations bind the legislatures.
Step 2 — Identify the verdict …
- JAC Jharkhand Intermediate Class 12 (Commerce) 2024Set ANNUAL1 markMCQQ.In which type of budget is the expenditure of the government more than its income?(a) Balanced budget(b) Deficit budget(c) Surplus budget(d) All of these
›Reveal solutionSolution
Expenditure greater than receipts = deficit budget.
By the relation between receipts and expenditure: a balanced budget has receipts = expenditure; a surplus budget has receipts > expenditure; and a deficit budget has expenditure > receipts. Since …
- JAC Jharkhand Intermediate Class 12 (Commerce) 2024Set ANNUAL1 markMCQQ.Which of the following products has been excluded from GST in India?(a) Tobacco products(b) Stationery(c) Jewellery(d) Petroleum products
›Reveal solutionSolution
Petroleum products are excluded from GST.
The Goods and Services Tax (GST) subsumed most indirect taxes in India, but certain items were kept outside its scope. Petroleum products (crude oil, petrol, diesel, natural gas, ATF) are currently excluded from GST and continue to attract ce …
- JAC Jharkhand Intermediate Class 12 (Commerce) 2023Set ANNUAL1 markMCQQ.Which of the following is an example of indirect tax?(a) Sales tax(b) Excise duty(c) Both(1) and(2)(d) Income tax
›Reveal solutionSolution
Sales tax and excise duty are both indirect taxes.
An indirect tax is levied on goods and services and its burden can be shifted from the person who pays it to another (the consumer). Both sales tax and excise duty are levied on goods and are passed on to consumers, so both are indirect taxes. Income …
- JAC Jharkhand Intermediate Class 12 (Commerce) 2023Set ANNUAL1 markMCQQ.What is the difference between Revenue expenditure and Revenue receipts called?(a) Primary deficit(b) Revenue deficit(c) Fiscal deficit(d) Trade deficit
›Reveal solutionSolution
Revenue expenditure minus revenue receipts = revenue deficit.
Revenue deficit = Revenue expenditure − Revenue receipts. It shows that the government's own revenue is insufficient to meet its routine (revenue) expenditure, forcing it to borrow or draw on capital receipts to meet current needs. (Fi …
🎓Unlock everything free for 14 days
- ✓Full step-by-step solutions
- ✓Concept-first explanations
- ✓Methods, shortcuts & mistakes
- ✓PYQ mapping + timed mock tests
Full access for 14 days. No credit card required.