Common Mistakes on Photon Energy & Photoelectric Effect Questions
Students lose marks on this exact type of problem in predictable ways. Here are the most frequent errors and how to fix them.
Mistake 1: Forgetting to convert electron-volts to joules
The work function is given as 2.14 eV, but the formula hf0=ϕ requires h in J⋅s and ϕ in joules. Many students plug 2.14 directly into f0=ϕ/h and get a nonsense answer.
How to avoid: Always convert eV to joules using 1 eV=1.6×10−19 J. So ϕ=2.14×1.6×10−19=3.424×10−19 J. Only then divide by h=6.63×10−34 J⋅s.
If you keep ϕ in eV and use h in J·s, your units won't cancel. The threshold frequency will be off by a factor of 1.6×10−19.
Mistake 2: Confusing threshold frequency with threshold wavelength
Part (a) asks for threshold frequency f0, not wavelength. Some students compute λ0=hc/ϕ instead. That's the threshold wavelength — a different quantity.
How to avoid: Read the question carefully. Threshold frequency comes from f0=ϕ/h. Threshold wavelength comes from λ0=hc/ϕ. They are not interchangeable.
Mistake 3: Using the wrong equation for part (b)
For the stopping potential part, students sometimes write eV0=hf alone, forgetting that the work function must be subtracted. The correct relation is:
eV0=hf−ϕ
or equivalently
hf=ϕ+eV0
How to avoid: Remember the photoelectric equation: kinetic energy of the fastest electron equals photon energy minus work function. Stopping potential just measures that maximum kinetic energy: Kmax=eV0.
Mistake 4: Mixing up units of stopping potential
The stopping potential is 0.60 V. When you compute eV0, you get 0.60 eV — that's already in electron-volts. But if you then add it to ϕ (which is also in eV), you must keep everything consistent. Some students convert eV0 to joules but leave ϕ in eV, or vice versa.
How to avoid: Work entirely in eV for the addition step, then convert to joules only when you need to use h or c. Here's the cleanest path:
- Total photon energy in eV: E=ϕ+eV0=2.14+0.60=2.74 eV
- Convert to joules: E=2.74×1.6×10−19=4.384×10−19 J
- Then λ=hc/E
Mistake 5: Using c=3×108 but forgetting to check units
When computing λ=hc/E, if E is in joules and h in J·s, c in m/s gives λ in metres. Students sometimes leave E in eV and get a wavelength off by 10−19.
How to avoid: Write out the units explicitly before calculating. If E is in joules, hc/E gives metres. If you prefer to keep E in eV, use the shortcut: …