Q.Find dxdy from the following
i. x3+y3=3axy
ii. exy−axy=a
iii. 3x3−5x2y+2xy2+4y3=0
iv. x1/3+y1/3=a2/3
v. x=ylog(xy)
Puducherry CbseNCERTSubjective· 5mImportance★★★★★
48% · 42/87 Questions
✓ Free question
Concept understanding — Implicit Differentiation
Implicit Differentiation: The Intuition
You already know how to differentiate y=x2+3x — just apply the power rule and get dxdy=2x+3. That's explicit differentiation: y is written directly in terms of x, so the derivative falls out cleanly.
But what if you're given something like x2+y2=25? Here y is not isolated. You could solve for y (getting y=±25−x2) and then differentiate — but that's messy, and you'd have to handle the ± separately. Worse, try solving y3+xy+x3=1 for y. It's impossible by elementary means.
Implicit differentiation is the trick that lets you find dxdywithout isolating y first. The core idea is simple: treat y as an unknown function of x, and differentiate both sides of the equation with respect to x, using the chain rule whenever you hit a y.
The Precise Statement
Given an equation relating x and y (like F(x,y)=0), differentiate every term with respect to x, remembering that y is a function of x. Whenever you differentiate a term containing y, apply the chain rule:
dxd[f(y)]=f′(y)⋅dxdy
Then solve the resulting equation for dxdy.
dxd[yn]=nyn−1⋅dxdy
Worked Example: x2+y2=25
Step 1: Differentiate both sides with respect to x.
dxd(x2)=2x
dxd(y2)=2y⋅dxdy (chain rule: derivative of y2 is 2y, times derivative of y)
dxd(25)=0
So we get:
2x+2y⋅dxdy=0
Step 2: Solve for dxdy.
2y⋅dxdy=−2x
dxdy=−yx
That's it. The derivative is expressed in terms of both x and y — which is natural, because the slope of the circle at a point depends on where you are.
Tip
To find the slope at a specific point, just plug in the coordinates. At (3,4) on the circle, dxdy=−43.
Why It Works
The chain rule is the engine. When you write y2, you're really writing [y(x)]2 — a function of a function. Differentiating it requires the chain rule, and that's exactly what produces the dxdy factor. Every term with y contributes one such factor; terms with only x differentiate normally.
Watch out
Never forget the dxdy factor when differentiating a y-term. The most common mistake is writing dxd(y2)=2y — that's wrong. It's 2y⋅dxdy.
Another Example: y3+xy+x3=1
Differentiate term by term:
dxd(y3)=3y2⋅dxdy
dxd(xy): use product rule — x times y gives 1⋅y+x⋅dxdy=y+xdxdy
dxd(x3)=3x2
dxd(1)=0
Put it together:
3y2dxdy+y+xdxdy+3x2=0
Collect dxdy terms:
(3y2+x)dxdy+y+3x2=0
Solve:
(3y2+x)dxdy=−y−3x2
dxdy=3y2+x−y−3x2
No solving for y needed — just algebra after differentiation.
When to Use Implicit Differentiation
Use it whenever:
y is difficult or impossible to isolate
The equation involves products or compositions of x and y (like xy, exy, sin(xy))
You need the derivative at a specific point without solving for y explicitly
Important
Implicit differentiation always gives dxdy in terms of both x and y. That's not a flaw — it's the natural result when y is not a function of x alone.
Summary
Implicit differentiation is just the chain rule applied to an equation. Differentiate both sides with respect to x, treat y as y(x), collect dxdy terms, and solve. It's a mechanical process — once you practice it, it becomes as automatic as explicit differentiation.
Each relation defines y implicitly in terms of x, so differentiating both sides with respect to x and collecting the dxdy terms on one side gives the slope in each part.
✓Final answer
dxdy=y2−axay−x2
dxdy=−xy
dxdy=5x2−4xy−12y29x2−10xy+2y2
dxdy=−(xy)2/3
dxdy=x[1+log(xy)]x−y
Note
The book's answer key prints part (iv) as −3xy, i.e. −(xy)1/3. This is a misprint: differentiating x1/3+y1/3=a2/3 gives 31x−2/3+31y−2/3dxdy=0, so the exponent is 2/3, giving dxdy=−(xy)2/3 as above.
Differentiating each relation implicitly and collecting dxdy gives the five results boxed below.
Implicit differentiation: differentiate both sides w.r.t. x, treating y as a function of x (so dxdyn=nyn−1dxdy), then solve for dxdy. Product rule dxd(uv)=u′v+uv′.
(i) x3+y3=3axy: differentiate: 3x2+3y2dxdy=3a(y+xdxdy). Divide by 3: x2+y2dxdy=ay+axdxdy. Collect: dxdy(y2−ax)=ay−x2, so dxdy=y2−axay−x2.
(ii) exy−axy=a: differentiate: exy(y+xdxdy)−a(y+xdxdy)=0, i.e. (y+xdxdy)(exy−a)=0. Since exy−a=0 in general, y+xdxdy=0⇒dxdy=−xy.
(iii) 3x3−5x2y+2xy2+4y3=0: differentiate term by term: 9x2−5(2xy+x2dxdy)+2(y2+2xydxdy)+12y2dxdy=0. That is 9x2−10xy−5x2dxdy+2y2+4xydxdy+12y2dxdy=0. Collect dxdy: dxdy(−5x2+4xy+12y2)=−(9x2−10xy+2y2), so dxdy=5x2−4xy−12y29x2−10xy+2y2.
(iv) x1/3+y1/3=a2/3: differentiate: 31x−2/3+31y−2/3dxdy=0, so dxdy=−y−2/3x−2/3=−(xy)2/3.
(v) x=ylog(xy): differentiate: 1=dxdylog(xy)+y⋅dxdlog(xy). Now dxdlog(xy)=xy1(y+xdxdy)=x1+y1dxdy, so 1=dxdylog(xy)+xy+dxdy. Hence dxdy[1+log(xy)]=1−xy=xx−y, giving dxdy=x[1+log(xy)]x−y.
✓Final answer
y2−axay−x2;
−xy;
5x2−4xy−12y29x2−10xy+2y2;
−(xy)2/3;
x[1+log(xy)]x−y.
Note
The book's answer key prints part (iv) as −3xy, i.e. −(xy)1/3. This is a misprint: differentiating x1/3+y1/3=a2/3 gives 31x−2/3+31y−2/3dxdy=0, so the exponent is 2/3, giving dxdy=−(xy)2/3 as above.