Skip to content

Physics · Ch 11 — Waves

Vibrations of Air Column

11.10

Vibrations of Air Column

Musical wind instruments such as the flute, the clarinet, and the nathaswaram all work on the same underlying principle: setting up standing (stationary) longitudinal sound waves inside a confined column of air, using a hollow wooden or metal pipe -- the organ pipe -- as the simplest and most general form such an instrument can take. Organ pipes are classified into two types, depending on whether one end of the tube is closed or both ends are left open, and the two types support very different sets of natural frequencies. In a closed organ pipe (open at one end, closed at the other, as in a clarinet), a sound wave reflecting off the closed end returns 180 degrees out of phase with the incoming wave, so the air right at the closed end cannot move at all -- forcing a node to form there, with a corresponding antinode always forming at the open end where air is free to move. For the simplest (fundamental) mode of vibration, this boundary condition fits exactly one quarter of a wavelength into the tube's length LL, giving L=λ1/4L=\lambda_1/4 and a fundamental frequency f1=v/(4L)f_1=v/(4L); because a node must always sit at the closed end, only the odd-numbered modes can satisfy this same boundary condition as the length is fixed, so a closed pipe supports ONLY odd harmonics, in the ratio f1:f2:f3:…=1:3:5:…f_1:f_2:f_3:\ldots=1:3:5:\ldots, with the frequency of the nn-th harmonic given by fn=(2n−1)f1f_n=(2n-1)f_1. In an open organ pipe (open at both ends, as in a flute), antinodes instead form at both open ends, and for the fundamental mode a node forms exactly at the pipe's midpoint, fitting half a wavelength into the length, L=λ1/2L=\lambda_1/2, giving a fundamental frequency f1=v/(2L)f_1=v/(2L) -- twice as high as a closed pipe of the identical length. Because antinodes are now required at both ends rather than just one, …

Figure 11.36Clarinet is an example of a closed organ pipe

What this figure shows. A photograph or drawing of a clarinet is shown, a long slender wind instrument held vertically with a reed mouthpiece visible at its upper end and a flared bell opening at its lower end, its body dotted with the round finger-holes and metal keys players use to change pitch. The figure identifies the clarinet as a concrete, real-world instance of a closed organ pipe -- despite having finger holes along its side, its basic acoustic behaviour is that of a tube effectively closed at the reed end (where the vibrating reed nearly blocks air motion, forcing a node there) and open at the bell end, which is exactly the closed-pipe boundary condition the text uses to derive the pip …

Figure 11.37No motion of particles which leads to nodes at closed end and antinodes at open end (fundamental mode) (N-node, A-antinode)

What this figure shows. A tube of length L, closed at its lower end and open at its upper end, is drawn in its fundamental (lowest) mode of vibration, with a node (labelled N) marked exactly at the closed lower end and an antinode (labelled A) marked at the open upper end, and the smooth curve of the standing-wave displacement pattern drawn bulging outward from the tube's central axis to show that displacement is zero at the closed end and maximum at the open end. A brace alongside the tube marks its length L as exactly one quarter of the wavelength lambda-one, i.e. L=λ1/4L=\lambda_1/4. The figure is the geometric basis for the closed-pipe fundamental-frequency formula f1=v/(4L)f_1=v/(4L) derived in the surrounding text: because the closed end must always be a node and the open end always an antinode, the shortest standing-wave pattern that can fit this boundary condition spans exactly one quart …

Figure 11.38Second mode of vibration having two nodes and two anti-nodes

What this figure shows. The same closed tube of length L is now drawn in its second allowed mode of vibration, showing a total of two nodes (one still at the closed end, one partway along the tube) and two antinodes (one at the open end, one partway along), with the standing-wave curve now showing two bulging lobes along the tube's length instead of the single lobe of the fundamental mode. A brace marks the tube's length L as three-quarters of the wavelength lambda-two for this mode, L=3λ2/4L=3\lambda_2/4. The figure shows visually why the closed pipe skips straight from the fundamental to a mode three times its frequency (the first overtone, called the third harmonic since f2=3f1f_2=3f_1): the next standing-wave pattern that still satisfies node-at-closed-end, antinode-at-open-end must fit three quarter-wavelengths into the same fixed length L, not two, because a node-antinode bou …

Figure 11.39Third mode of vibration having three nodes and three anti-nodes

What this figure shows. The closed tube of length L is drawn in its third allowed mode of vibration, now showing three nodes and three antinodes distributed along its length, with the standing-wave curve showing three bulging lobes. A brace marks the tube's length L as five quarter-wavelengths of this mode's wavelength lambda-three, 4L=5λ34L=5\lambda_3. The figure continues the pattern established by the previous two figures, confirming that successive allowed closed-pipe modes require 1, 3, 5, ... quarter-wavelengths (always an odd count) to fit the fixed length L, which is exactly why a closed organ pipe's second overtone has a frequency five times the fundamental (the fifth harmonic, f3=5f1f_3=5f_1) and why closed pipes support only …

Figure 11.40Flute is an example of open organ pipe

What this figure shows. A photograph or drawing of a flute is shown, a long slender wind instrument held horizontally, open at both ends (an embouchure hole near one end where the player blows across the opening, and an open far end), with a row of finger-holes and keys visible along its body. The figure identifies the flute as a concrete, real-world instance of an open organ pipe -- air is free to move at both ends of its tube -- which is exactly the open-pipe boundary condition the text uses to derive the pipe's fundamental frequency (twice that of an equal-length closed pipe) and its a …

Figure 11.41Antinodes are formed at the open end and a node is formed at the middle of the pipe

What this figure shows. A tube of length L, open at both ends, is drawn in its fundamental mode of vibration, with antinodes (labelled A) marked at both the left and right open ends and a single node (labelled N) marked exactly at the midpoint of the tube, and the standing-wave curve drawn bulging outward at both ends and pinching to zero displacement in the middle. A brace marks the tube's length L as exactly half the wavelength lambda-one for this mode, L=λ1/2L=\lambda_1/2. The figure is the geometric basis for the open-pipe fundamental-frequency formula f1=v/(2L)f_1=v/(2L) derived in the surrounding text: because both ends of an open pipe must be antinodes, the shortest standing-wave pattern that can satisfy this double boundary condition spans exactly half a wavelength, with a single node fo …

Figure 11.42Second mode of vibration in open pipes having two nodes and three anti-nodes

What this figure shows. The same open tube of length L is drawn in its second allowed mode, showing three antinodes (at both open ends and one additional antinode in the middle of the tube) and two nodes located symmetrically between them, with the standing-wave curve now showing two full bulging lobes along the tube. A brace marks the tube's length L as exactly one full wavelength of this mode, L=λ2L=\lambda_2. The figure shows why, unlike the closed pipe, the open pipe's very next mode above the fundamental is simply twice the fundamental frequency (the first overtone, called the second harmonic since f2=2f1f_2=2f_1): with antinodes required at both ends, the tube's length can accommodate any integer number of half-wavelengths, so the sequence of allowed lengths increases by simple …

Figure 11.43Third mode of vibration having three nodes and four anti-nodes

What this figure shows. The open tube of length L is drawn in its third allowed mode, showing four antinodes (including both open ends) and three nodes distributed between them, with the standing-wave curve now showing three full bulging lobes along the tube's length. A brace marks the tube's length L as three-halves of the wavelength lambda-three for this mode, L=3λ3/2L=3\lambda_3/2. The figure completes the open-pipe harmonic sequence shown across Figures 11.41-11.43: successive open-pipe modes require 1, 2, 3, ... half-wavelengths (every integer, none skipped) to fit the fixed length L, confirming that an open organ pipe supports every harmonic of its fundamental, in the ratio f1:f2:f3:…=1:2:3:…f_1:f_2:f_3:\ldots=1:2:3:\ldots, unlike th …

Misc Example 11.25Harmonics of a flute and a clarinet sounding the same fundamental note

Worked out. A flute (an open pipe) sounds a fundamental note of 450 Hz, and the task is to find the frequencies of its second, third and fourth harmonics, and then to find the lowest three harmonics of a clarinet (a closed pipe) sounding at the same fundamental 450 Hz. Since an open pipe supports every harmonic in the ratio 1:2:3:4:…1:2:3:4:\ldots, the flute's harmonics are simply integer multiples of 450 Hz: f2=2×450=900 Hzf_2=2\times450=900\ \text{Hz}, f3=3×450=1350 Hzf_3=3\times450=1350\ \text{Hz}, f4=4×450=1800 Hzf_4=4\times450=1800\ \text{Hz}. Since a closed pipe instead supports only odd harmonics in the ratio 1:3:5:7:…1:3:5:7:\ldots, the clarinet's lowest three harmonics use odd multipliers instead of consecutive integers: its second (actual) harmonic present is f2=3×450=1350 Hzf_2=3\times450=1350\ \text{Hz}, its third present harmonic is f3=5×450=2250 Hzf_3=5\times450=2250\ \text{Hz}, and its fourth present harmonic is f4=7×450=3150 Hzf_4=7\times450=3150\ \text{Hz} -- vividly illustrating why a closed pipe's harmon …

Misc Example 11.26Length of an open pipe matching a closed pipe's third harmonic

Worked out. A closed organ pipe of length 30 cm has its third harmonic frequency exactly equal to the fundamental frequency of a separate open organ pipe, and the task is to find the length of that open pipe. The closed pipe's third harmonic (using fn=(2n−1)f1f_n=(2n-1)f_1 with n=2n=2, since the third harmonic is the first overtone) is f=3v/(4l1)f=3v/(4l_1) with l1=30 cml_1=30\ \text{cm}. The open pipe's fundamental is f=v/(2l2)f=v/(2l_2). Setting these equal, 3v/(4l1)=v/(2l2)3v/(4l_1)=v/(2l_2), the common speed v cancels, leaving 3/(4×30)=1/(2l2)3/(4\times30)=1/(2l_2), which rearranges to l2=(2×30)/3=20 cml_2=(2\times30)/3=20\ \text{cm}. The example demonstrates how matching two different pipes' resonant frequencies -- one at a harmonic other than its fundamental -- lets an unknown pipe length be found purely from the ratio of the two pipes' resonance-condition formu …