Q.State whether the following statement is True or False, giving reasons: A firm is compulsorily dissolved when a partner decides to retire.

Partnership Liability Distinction – A First Look

Think of a partnership like a group of friends starting a food stall together. Each friend brings some money, some bring a stove, some bring their time. Now imagine one friend borrows ₹5,000 from her father to buy extra ingredients. That loan is her personal debt — her father can only come after her personal assets, not the stall’s cash or the other friends’ bikes. But if the stall itself takes a loan from a bank for a new fridge, the bank can come after all the friends and all the stall’s assets.

That gut-level difference — whose pocket the debt comes out of — is the core of Partnership Liability Distinction.

The Precise Meaning

In a partnership firm, there are two distinct layers of liability:

1. Firm’s Liability – Debts owed by the partnership as a business. These are paid from the firm’s assets first. If those assets fall short, the partners are jointly and severally liable — meaning creditors can go after any partner’s personal property to recover the full amount.

2. Partner’s Personal Liability – Debts a partner incurs in their individual capacity (e.g., a personal loan, a car loan). These are paid from that partner’s personal assets. The firm’s assets are not available to satisfy such debts.

Why This Matters

This distinction is not just legal theory — it directly affects how you prepare the Partners’ Capital Accounts and the Profit and Loss Appropriation Account.

• When a partner takes a drawing (withdraws cash or goods for personal use), it reduces the firm’s assets and increases the partner’s personal benefit. That drawing is not a firm expense — it’s a reduction of the partner’s capital.
• When a partner gives a loan to the firm, that loan is a firm liability (owed to the partner as a creditor), not a part of capital. It earns interest at an agreed rate (usually 6% p.a. if no agreement exists, per the Partnership Act).
• When the firm pays interest on a partner’s loan, it is a charge against profit (deducted before calculating profit for appropriation), not an appropriation of profit.

Accounting Treatment

1. Partner’s Drawings (Personal use of firm assets)

• Journal Entry:

  Drawings A/c … Dr.

    To Cash/Bank/Goods A/c

  (Being goods/cash withdrawn for personal use)

• At the end of the year, the Drawings account is closed to the Partner’s Capital Account (or Current Account, if the fixed capital method is used).

2. Partner’s Loan to the Firm

• Journal Entry when loan is given:

  Cash/Bank A/c … Dr.

    To Partner’s Loan A/c

  (Being loan given by partner to the firm)

• Interest on Partner’s Loan:

  Interest on Partner’s Loan A/c … Dr.

    To Partner’s Loan A/c

  (Being interest due on partner’s loan)

• This interest is debited to Profit and Loss A/c (as a charge), not to the Profit and Loss Appropriation A/c.

3. Firm’s Liability vs Partner’s Personal Liability in Balance Sheet

• Firm’s liabilities (creditors, bank loans, partner’s loan) appear on the Liabilities side of the Balance Sheet.
• Partner’s personal liabilities are never recorded in the firm’s books.

Format: Partners’ Capital Account (Fixed Capital Method)

Under the Fixed Capital Method, the capital account remains constant (except for additional capital introduced or permanent withdrawal). All other transactions (drawings, interest on capital, salary, share of profit/loss) are recorded in a separate Current Account. …