Skip to content
Short Answer Questions · Q1

Q.State the difference between dissolution of partnership and dissolution of partnership firm.

Sikkim CbseNCERTSubjective· 3mImportance★★★★★
57% · 39/69 Questions
✓ Free question

Dissolution of partnership refers to a change in the existing relationship among partners (e.g., retirement, admission, death) where the firm continues to exist, whereas dissolution of partnership firm means the complete winding up of the business, where the firm ceases to exist.

Concept and Accounting Treatment

The distinction between these two terms is fundamental in partnership accounting, yet it's one of the most commonly confused areas. Let me explain why this matters.

Dissolution of partnership is a narrower concept. It occurs when the partnership agreement between existing partners ends, but the business itself continues. Think of it as a restructuring. For example, when a partner retires, dies, or a new partner is admitted, the old partnership is dissolved and a new one is formed. The firm's assets and liabilities remain intact, and the business carries on without interruption. The accounting treatment here involves revaluing assets and liabilities, adjusting goodwill, and settling the retiring partner's account — but the firm's books continue.

Dissolution of partnership firm, on the other hand, is the complete end. The business stops, all assets are sold, all liabilities are paid off, and the remaining cash is distributed among partners. The firm's legal existence comes to an end. The accounting treatment here involves a Realisation Account (not a Revaluation Account), where all assets are transferred at book value and sold, and all liabilities are paid off. Any profit or loss on realisation is shared among partners.

Watch out

A classic mistake students make is using a Revaluation Account for dissolution of firm. Remember: Revaluation Account is used only when the firm continues (dissolution of partnership). For dissolution of firm, you must use a Realisation Account.

Key Differences

BasisDissolution of PartnershipDissolution of Partnership Firm
MeaningChange in relationship among partners; firm continuesComplete winding up of business; firm ceases to exist
ContinuityBusiness continues with a new partnership agreementBusiness is closed permanently
SettlementOnly the outgoing partner's claim is settledAll partners' claims are settled
Accounts PreparedRevaluation Account, Partners' Capital AccountsRealisation Account, Cash/Bank Account, Partners' Capital Accounts
Court InterventionUsually not requiredMay be ordered by court
Legal FormalityLess formal; can be by mutual agreementMore formal; requires public notice, settlement of all debts
Tip

A simple way to remember: If the business continues after the event, it's dissolution of partnership. If the business stops completely, it's dissolution of partnership firm.

Detailed Explanation

Dissolution of Partnership (Section 39 of Indian Partnership Act, 1932)

This happens when there is a change in the constitution of the firm. The partnership is dissolved between the existing partners, but the firm continues with the remaining partners or with new partners. Examples include:

  • Retirement of a partner
  • Admission of a new partner
  • Death of a partner
  • Insolvency of a partner

The accounting treatment involves:

  1. Revaluation of assets and liabilities (Revaluation Account)
  2. Treatment of goodwill
  3. Adjustment of accumulated profits/losses
  4. Settlement of the outgoing partner's account

Dissolution of Partnership Firm (Section 39 read with Section 40-44)

This is the complete dissolution of the firm itself. The business is wound up, assets are sold, liabilities are paid, and the proceeds are distributed among partners. This can happen:

  • By mutual agreement (Section 40)
  • By notice (in case of partnership at will) (Section 43)
  • Compulsory dissolution (insolvency of all partners, business becoming illegal) (Section 41)
  • By court order (Section 44)

The accounting treatment involves:

  1. Opening a Realisation Account
  2. Transferring all assets (except cash/bank) to Realisation Account
  3. Transferring all external liabilities to Realisation Account
  4. Recording sale of assets and payment of liabilities
  5. Recording any realisation expenses
  6. Transferring profit/loss on realisation to Partners' Capital Accounts
  7. Closing Partners' Capital Accounts by paying off the balances
Important

In dissolution of partnership firm, the firm's books are closed permanently. All accounts are balanced and closed. In dissolution of partnership, the firm's books continue with adjustments.

Practical Example to Illustrate the Difference

Suppose A, B, and C are partners. If C retires:

  • Dissolution of partnership: The old partnership (A, B, C) is dissolved. A new partnership (A, B) is formed. The business continues. C's capital is paid off after revaluation and goodwill adjustments.
  • Dissolution of partnership firm: The entire business is wound up. All assets are sold, all debts are paid, and A, B, and C receive their final settlement. No business continues.
✓Final answer

Dissolution of partnership is a change in the partnership relation where the firm continues to exist (e.g., retirement, admission), while dissolution of partnership firm is the complete winding up of the business where the firm ceases to exist. The key test is whether the business continues after the event.

Unlock everything free for 14 days

  • Full step-by-step solutions
  • Concept-first explanations
  • Methods, shortcuts & mistakes
  • PYQ mapping + timed mock tests

Full access for 14 days. No credit card required.