Skip to content
NCERT Exemplar · Q3

Q.In a nuclear reactor, moderators slow down the neutrons which come out in a fission process. The moderator used have light nuclei. Heavy nuclei will not serve the purpose because

(a) they will break up.
(b) elastic collision of neutrons with heavy nuclei will not slow them down.
(c) the net weight of the reactor would be unbearably high.
(d) substances with heavy nuclei do not occur in liquid or gaseous state at room temperature.
Telangana TsbieMCQ· 1mImportance★★★★★
74% · 37/50 Questions
✓ Free question

The key idea is that in an elastic collision, a neutron transfers maximum kinetic energy to a target of comparable mass. Heavy nuclei absorb very little energy per collision, so they cannot effectively slow (moderate) neutrons. The correct option is (B).

The question is about moderation — the process of slowing down fast neutrons produced in fission so they can sustain a chain reaction. A moderator must reduce neutron speed efficiently without absorbing them. The physics here is purely about elastic collisions and energy transfer.

Let’s walk through why heavy nuclei fail.

  1. The physics of a single elastic collision When a neutron (mass mm) collides elastically with a stationary nucleus (mass MM), the fraction of kinetic energy lost by the neutron depends only on the mass ratio. For a head-on collision (maximum energy transfer), the neutron’s final kinetic energy EfE_f is related to its initial energy EiE_i by:

Ef=(M−mM+m)2EiE_f = \left( \frac{M - m}{M + m} \right)^2 E_i

The energy transferred to the nucleus is:

ΔE=Ei−Ef=[1−(M−mM+m)2]Ei=4Mm(M+m)2Ei\Delta E = E_i - E_f = \left[ 1 - \left( \frac{M - m}{M + m} \right)^2 \right] E_i = \frac{4Mm}{(M+m)^2} E_i

  1. Why light nuclei are effective

    If M≈mM \approx m (e.g., hydrogen, where M=1M = 1 u, m≈1m \approx 1 u), then ΔE≈Ei\Delta E \approx E_i — the neutron can lose almost all its energy in one collision. For deuterium (M=2M = 2 u) or carbon (M=12M = 12 u), the energy loss per collision is still substantial. This is why light elements like hydrogen (in water), deuterium (in heavy water), and carbon (in graphite) are used as moderators.

  2. Why heavy nuclei fail

    If M≫mM \gg m (e.g., lead, M=207M = 207 u), then:

ΔE≈4mMEi\Delta E \approx \frac{4m}{M} E_i

which is a tiny fraction. For lead, ΔE≈4207Ei≈0.019Ei\Delta E \approx \frac{4}{207} E_i \approx 0.019 E_i — less than 2% per collision. To slow a neutron from fission energy (~2 MeV) to thermal energy (~0.025 eV), you would need thousands of collisions, making moderation impractical. The neutron would likely be absorbed or escape before slowing down.

Watch out

A common mistake is to think heavy nuclei “break up” or that the issue is about state of matter. Option (A) is wrong because elastic collisions do not cause nuclear breakup at these energies. Option (C) is irrelevant — weight is a design issue, not a physics principle. Option (D) is false (e.g., lead is liquid at reactor temperatures, and many heavy elements exist as gases or liquids).

  1. The correct reasoning The moderator’s job is to slow neutrons via elastic collisions. Heavy nuclei absorb too little energy per collision to be effective. This is a direct consequence of conservation of momentum and energy in elastic collisions — no other physics is needed.
✓Final answer

The correct option is (B) — elastic collision of neutrons with heavy nuclei will not slow them down.

Unlock everything free for 14 days

  • Full step-by-step solutions
  • Concept-first explanations
  • Methods, shortcuts & mistakes
  • PYQ mapping + timed mock tests

Full access for 14 days. No credit card required.