Explain various methods for the treatment of goodwill on the admission of a new partner?

Long Answer Questions · Q6

Q. Explain various methods for the treatment of goodwill on the admission of a new partner?

Tripura TbseTextbookSubjective· 3mImportance★★★★★

63% · 61/97 Questions

🔒 Locked · start free trial →

You're viewing a preview — the full solution, concept, methods & PYQ mapping are locked.

Start your 14-day free trial to unlock the full solution →

Concept understanding — Admission Partner Adjustments

Let’s start with something you already know from daily life. Suppose you and a friend run a small tiffin service together. After a year, a third friend wants to join. You both agree to let her in. But the business has grown — you have a reputation, some regular customers, and maybe a little cash saved. She can’t just walk in and claim equal share of everything you built before she arrived. That wouldn’t be fair to you and your original partner.

So you sit down and decide: what is the business worth today? How much should the new partner bring in as her share of that past effort? And once she comes in, how do we rewrite the partnership deed so everyone’s rights are clear from Day 1?

That’s the heart of Admission of a Partner — and the adjustments that follow.

What does “Admission Partner Adjustments” mean?

When a new partner is admitted into an existing partnership, the old partnership is dissolved in the eyes of accounting, and a new one begins. The new partner brings in capital (cash or assets) and also buys a share of the goodwill — the value of the business’s reputation and past efforts. But that’s not all. Several things need to be revalued or adjusted so that the new partner doesn’t unfairly gain or lose from past decisions.

These adjustments are:

Revaluation of Assets and Liabilities – because the balance sheet values may be outdated.
Treatment of Goodwill – the new partner compensates old partners for their past efforts.
Adjustment of Reserves and Accumulated Profits/Losses – these belong to old partners only.
Adjustment of Capital Accounts – to bring all partners’ capitals in proportion to the new profit-sharing ratio.

Each of these has a clear accounting treatment. Let’s go through them one by one.

1. Revaluation of Assets and Liabilities

Why? The balance sheet shows assets at book value (historical cost minus depreciation). But the new partner should not benefit from an undervalued asset (like land that has appreciated) nor suffer from an overvalued one. Similarly, liabilities may be understated or overstated.

Accounting treatment:

We open a Revaluation Account (also called Profit & Loss Adjustment Account).

Increase in asset value → debit Asset, credit Revaluation A/c
Decrease in asset value → credit Asset, debit Revaluation A/c
Increase in liability → credit Liability, debit Revaluation A/c
Decrease in liability → debit Liability, credit Revaluation A/c

The net profit or loss on revaluation is transferred to the old partners’ capital accounts in their old profit-sharing ratio.

Note

The new partner does not share in revaluation profit/loss — it belongs entirely to the old partners.

Example format (Revaluation Account):

Particulars	₹	Particulars	₹
To Building (decrease)	10,000	By Land (increase)	20,000
To Provision for Doubtful Debts (increase)	5,000	By Creditors (decrease)	8,000
To Profit transferred to:
A’s Capital A/c (3/5)	7,800
B’s Capital A/c (2/5)	5,200
Total	28,000	Total	28,000

2. Treatment of Goodwill

Why? The new partner is buying a share of the business’s earning power built by old partners. She must compensate them for this.

Accounting treatment (as per NCERT):

The new partner brings her share of goodwill in cash. That cash is then withdrawn by the old partners (or left in the business). The journal entry:

When new partner brings goodwill in cash:

Cash/Bank A/c Dr.

To Goodwill A/c (or Premium for Goodwill A/c)
Then, distribute that amount to old partners in their sacrificing ratio:

Goodwill A/c Dr.

To Old Partners’ Capital A/cs (individually)

Watch out

The sacrificing ratio is the ratio in which old partners give up their share in favour of the new partner. It is not the same as the old ratio unless the new partner’s share is taken equally from all.

Sacrificing Ratio = Old Ratio – New Ratio

If the new partner does not bring cash for goodwill, we adjust through capital accounts (debit the new partner, credit the old partners).

3. Adjustment of Reserves and Accumulated Profits/Losses

Why? Any accumulated profits (like General Reserve, Profit & Loss A/c credit balance) belong to the old partners. The new partner should not get a share of past profits.

Accounting treatment:

Transfer the entire reserve/accumulated profit to old partners’ capital accounts in their old profit-sharing ratio.

Journal entry:

General Reserve A/c Dr.

To Old Partners’ Capital A/cs

Similarly, accumulated losses (debit balance of P&L A/c) are debited to old partners’ capital accounts.

4. Adjustment of Capital Accounts

Why? After all adjustments, the partners’ capitals may not be in the new profit-sharing ratio. The partnership deed may require capitals to be proportionate to profit shares.

Accounting treatment: …

Start your 14-day free trial to unlock the full solution →

Treatment of Goodwill on Admission of a New Partner

When a new partner joins, the existing partners sacrifice a portion of their profit share in his favour. Goodwill compensates them for this sacrifice. The incoming partner must bring his share of goodwill, which is then distributed among the old partners in their sacrificing ratio.

Three methods are used in practice, depending on whether the new partner brings goodwill in cash or not, and whether the firm wants to retain it in the books.

Method 1: Premium Method (Goodwill brought in cash and withdrawn)

The new partner pays his share of goodwill in cash. This amount is immediately withdrawn by the old partners in their sacrificing ratio.

Journal Entries:

Particulars	Debit (₹)	Credit (₹)
Bank/Cash A/c Dr.	xxx
To Premium for Goodwill A/c		xxx
(Goodwill brought in by new partner)

Premium for Goodwill A/c Dr.	xxx
To Old Partners' Capital A/cs		xxx
(Goodwill distributed in sacrificing ratio)

Old Partners' Capital A/cs Dr.	xxx
To Bank/Cash A/c		xxx
(Goodwill withdrawn by old partners)

Goodwill does not appear in the Balance Sheet after this treatment.

Method 2: Premium Method (Goodwill retained in the firm)

The new partner brings goodwill in cash, which is credited to the old partners' capital accounts in the sacrificing ratio but not withdrawn. The cash remains in the business.

Journal Entries:

Particulars	Debit (₹)	Credit (₹)
Bank/Cash A/c Dr.	xxx
To Premium for Goodwill A/c		xxx
(Goodwill brought in by new partner)

Premium for Goodwill A/c Dr.	xxx
To Old Partners' Capital A/cs		xxx
(Goodwill distributed in sacrificing ratio)

The cash increases the firm's assets; goodwill itself is not shown as an intangible asset.

Method 3: Goodwill not brought in cash (Adjustment through Capital Accounts)

The new partner does not bring goodwill separately. Instead, an adjustment entry is passed: the new partner's capital is debited and the old partners' capitals are credited in the sacrificing ratio with the new partner's share of goodwill.

Journal Entry:

Start your 14-day free trial to unlock the full solution →

Four methods exist for treating goodwill on admission: (1) Premium Method (new partner pays cash), (2) Revaluation Method (raise goodwill in books, then write off), (3) Adjustment through Capital Accounts (no cash, no asset), and (4) Hidden Goodwill (inferred from capital contribution). Each redistributes the old partners' share of goodwill to them in the old ratio.

Concept: Why Goodwill Adjustment is Necessary

When a new partner joins, the firm's goodwill—the value of its reputation, customer base, and earning capacity—already belongs to the old partners in their old profit-sharing ratio. The new partner will share future profits (including profits arising from this goodwill), so the old partners must be compensated for sacrificing a portion of their goodwill.

The accounting treatment ensures that the old partners receive, in their old ratio, the value of the goodwill they are giving up. The new partner effectively "pays" for his share of goodwill, either in cash (premium) or through a book adjustment that credits the old partners' capital accounts.

Method 1: Premium Method (Cash Payment by New Partner)

The new partner brings cash as premium for goodwill over and above his capital contribution. This cash is distributed to the old partners in their sacrificing ratio (usually the old ratio, unless stated otherwise).

Journal Entry:

Particulars	Debit (₹)	Credit (₹)
Bank/Cash A/c	XXX
To Old Partner A's Capital A/c		XXX
To Old Partner B's Capital A/c		XXX
(Being premium for goodwill brought in cash and distributed in old ratio)

Advantage: Simple and clean—no goodwill asset appears in the books; old partners receive immediate cash compensation.

When used: When the partnership deed or agreement explicitly requires the new partner to pay premium in cash.

Method 2: Revaluation Method (Raise Goodwill, Then Write Off)

The firm's goodwill is raised as an asset (credited to old partners' capital in the old ratio), then immediately written off in the new profit-sharing ratio (all partners, including the new one, share the write-off).

Step 1 – Raise Goodwill:

Particulars	Debit (₹)	Credit (₹)
Goodwill A/c	XXX
To Old Partner A's Capital A/c		XXX
To Old Partner B's Capital A/c		XXX
(Being goodwill raised and credited to old partners in old ratio)

Step 2 – Write Off Goodwill:

Particulars	Debit (₹)	Credit (₹)
All Partners' Capital A/cs (A, B, C)	XXX
To Goodwill A/c		XXX
(Being goodwill written off in new profit-sharing ratio)

Net Effect: Old partners gain in the old ratio and lose in the new ratio; the difference is their compensation. The new partner only loses (debited in the new ratio), which is his implicit payment for goodwill.

Advantage: Goodwill does not remain on the Balance Sheet (conservative accounting).

When used: When partners prefer not to show goodwill as an asset but still want a full adjustment.

Watch out

A common mistake is to write off goodwill in the old ratio instead of the new ratio. The write-off must be shared by all partners (including the new one) in their new profit-sharing ratio; otherwise, the new partner escapes his share of the cost.

Method 3: Adjustment Through Capital Accounts (No Cash, No Asset)

Goodwill is not brought in cash and not recorded as an asset. Instead, the new partner compensates the old partners by a direct debit to his capital account and credits to the old partners' capital accounts in their sacrificing ratio.

Journal Entry:

Particulars	Debit (₹)	Credit (₹)
New Partner's Capital A/c	XXX
To Old Partner A's Capital A/c		XXX
To Old Partner B's Capital A/c		XXX
(Being adjustment for new partner's share of goodwill through capital accounts)

Calculation: New partner's share of goodwill = Total Goodwill × New Partner's Share. This amount is debited to the new partner and credited to old partners in their old (sacrificing) ratio.

Advantage: Clean Balance Sheet—no goodwill asset, no cash transaction. Purely a book adjustment.

When used: When the new partner does not bring premium in cash, but the old partners still want compensation recorded in their capital accounts.

Tip

If the new partner's capital is to be adjusted to a fixed amount after the goodwill adjustment, first make the goodwill entry, then bring in or withdraw cash to reach the target capital balance.

Method 4: Hidden Goodwill (Inferred from Capital Contribution)

Sometimes goodwill is not explicitly stated but can be inferred from the new partner's capital contribution and his agreed profit share.

Logic:

New partner brings ₹X for a 1/n share.
This implies the total capital of the firm (after admission) should be ₹X × n.
Compare this implied total with the actual total capital (old partners' capital + new partner's capital).
The difference is the hidden goodwill, which is credited to old partners in their old ratio.

Example Calculation (Working Note):

Suppose the new partner brings ₹50,000 for a 1/4 share.

Implied total capital = ₹50,000 × 4 = ₹2,00,000.
Actual total capital (old partners ₹1,20,000 + new ₹50,000) = ₹1,70,000.
Hidden goodwill = ₹2,00,000 − ₹1,70,000 = ₹30,000.

Journal Entry: …

Start your 14-day free trial to unlock the full solution →

←Previous question · questions-for-practiceQ5 — Explain how will you deal with goodwill when new partner is not in a p…→Next question · questions-for-practiceQ7 — How will you deal with the accumulated profits and losses and reserves…

Q.Explain various methods for the treatment of goodwill on the admission of a new partner?

Concept: Why Goodwill Adjustment is Necessary

Method 1: Premium Method (Cash Payment by New Partner)

Method 2: Revaluation Method (Raise Goodwill, Then Write Off)

Method 3: Adjustment Through Capital Accounts (No Cash, No Asset)

Method 4: Hidden Goodwill (Inferred from Capital Contribution)

🎓Unlock everything free for 14 days

Unlock everything free for 14 days