When goodwill does not appear in the books

When goodwill does not appear in the books, the retiring partner has a right to be compensated for their share of the firm's goodwill, but no existing goodwill account needs to be written off. The adjustment is done entirely through the partners' capital accounts.

The logic is simple: the continuing partners will enjoy the future profits that the retiring partner helped build. So, the continuing partners (who gain in future profits) must pay the retiring partner for that share. The payment is not in cash — it is a book adjustment. The gaining partners' capital accounts are debited, and the retiring partner's capital account is credited.

The journal entry is:

The amount debited to each gaining partner is calculated using the gaining ratio, not the old profit-sharing ratio. The gaining ratio is:

Gaining Share = New Share – Old Share

If the result is positive, the partner has gained. If negative, the partner has sacrificed.

---

Example 1: Simple case — all continuing partners gain

A, B, and C share profits in the ratio 3:2:1. B retires. Goodwill is valued at ₹60,000. A and C continue in the ratio 3:1.

Step 1: B's share of goodwill = 2/6 × 60,000 = ₹20,000

Step 2: Calculate gaining ratio.

• A's old share = 3/6, new share = 3/4. Gain = 3/4 - 3/6 = (9-6)/12 = 3/12 = 1/4
• C's old share = 1/6, new share = 1/4. Gain = 1/4 - 1/6 = (3-2)/12 = 1/12

Gaining ratio = 1/4 : 1/12 = 3:1

Step 3: A's capital will be debited with 3/4 × 20,000 = ₹15,000

C's capital will be debited with 1/4 × 20,000 = ₹5,000

Journal entry:

---

Key points to remember

• The journal entry is passed without opening a Goodwill account. The adjustment is purely through capital accounts.
• The gaining ratio is always used to determine how much each continuing partner pays. …