Q.Eight chairs are numbered to . Two women and men wish to occupy one chair each. First the women choose the chairs from amongst the chairs to and then men select from the remaining chairs. Find the total number of possible arrangements.
The problem is a two‑stage selection‑and‑arrangement: first the two women choose 2 distinct chairs from chairs 1–4 (order matters because they are distinct people), then the three men arrange themselves in 3 of the remaining 6 chairs. The total number of arrangements is .
The key idea here is that the women and men do not choose chairs simultaneously. The women pick first, and only from chairs 1 to 4. After they have taken their seats, the men pick from whatever chairs are left — which could be anywhere from 1 to 8, except the two already taken.
Because the people are distinct (each woman is a different person, each man is a different person), the order in which they occupy chairs matters. This is a permutation without repetition problem: we are arranging distinct people into distinct chairs, but with a restriction on which chairs the women may initially choose from.
Let’s break it into the two clear stages.
-
Women choose and sit in chairs 1–4
There are 4 chairs available (numbered 1, 2, 3, 4). Two distinct women need to pick two different chairs.
The first woman has 4 choices. After she sits, the second woman has 3 remaining chairs to choose from.
So the number of ways for the women to occupy two chairs from the set is:
This is a permutation: .
If the women were identical, we would use combinations (). But since they are different people, swapping them gives a different arrangement — so we multiply, not divide.
-
Men choose from the remaining chairs
After the two women have taken their seats, there are chairs left. Three distinct men need to sit in three of these chairs.
The first man has 6 choices, the second has 5, the third has 4. So the number of ways for the men is:
That is .
-
Combine the two stages
Since the women’s choice and the men’s choice are independent (the men’s options depend on which chairs the women took, but the counting already accounts for all possibilities), we multiply:
A common mistake is to treat the women’s choice as and then multiply by for the men, forgetting that the women are distinct. That gives , which is exactly half the correct answer. Always check: are the people identical or distinct? Here, they are distinct individuals.
The total number of possible arrangements is .
Unlock everything free for 14 days
- Full step-by-step solutions
- Concept-first explanations
- Methods, shortcuts & mistakes
- PYQ mapping + timed mock tests
Full access for 14 days. No credit card required.