Imagine you drop a spoonful of sugar into a glass of water. Stir once, and it disappears. Now try the same with a spoonful of sand. It just sits at the bottom. Why? The sugar molecules are able to break apart and mingle with water molecules — we say sugar dissolves in water. Sand does not.
That "disappearing" act is solubility. But in chemistry, we don't just ask if something dissolves — we ask how much and under what conditions. For ionic compounds (salts), the answer is surprisingly predictable. That predictability is what we call the Solubility Rules.
The Core Idea: "Like Dissolves Like" — But Ionic Compounds Are Different
For molecular substances like sugar, the rule of thumb is "like dissolves like" — polar dissolves in polar, non-polar in non-polar. But ionic compounds are made of charged particles (cations and anions). When you drop an ionic solid into water, the water molecules (which are polar) try to pull the ions apart. Whether they succeed depends on a tug-of-war:
The water molecules want to surround and separate the ions (hydration energy).
The ions themselves are held together by electrostatic forces (lattice energy).
If the hydration energy wins, the salt dissolves. If the lattice energy wins, it stays solid.
Note
You don't need to calculate these energies for exams. The Solubility Rules are a shortcut — a set of patterns discovered by observing thousands of salts.
The Precise Statement: The Solubility Rules
Here are the rules as you'll use them in exams. They are hierarchical — the first applicable rule overrides later ones.
Solubility Rules for Ionic Compounds in Water
Rule
Statement
Examples
1
All nitrates (NO3−) are soluble.
NaNO3, AgNO3, Pb(NO3)2
2
All acetates (CH3COO−) are soluble.
NaCH3COO, AgCH3COO
3
All chlorides (Cl−), bromides (Br−), and iodides (I−) are soluble, except with Ag+, Pb2+, and Hg22+.
All carbonates (CO32−), phosphates (PO43−), sulfides (S2−), and hydroxides (OH−) are insoluble, except with Group 1 metals (Li+, Na+, K+, etc.) and NH4+.
All compounds of Group 1 metals (Li+, Na+, K+, Rb+, Cs+) and ammonium (NH4+) are soluble.
NaCl, KOH, NH4NO3
Watch out
A common mistake: students remember "all chlorides are soluble" and forget the exceptions. AgCl is insoluble — that's why it's used in photography and qualitative analysis. Always check the exceptions first.
How to Use the Rules (Step-by-Step)
Suppose you need to predict whether PbSO4 dissolves in water.
Identify the ions: Pb2+ and SO42−.
Check the rules in order:
Rule 1 (nitrates)? No. …
Why this formula?
Solubility Rules: Why They Work (Not Just What They Say)
Solubility rules are not arbitrary — they emerge from thermodynamics and electrostatic interactions between ions in water. Let's break down the why behind the key patterns.
1. The Core Idea: "Like Dissolves Like" at the Ionic Level
Water dissolves ionic compounds because it is polar. The δ+ hydrogen ends attract anions, and the δ− oxygen end attracts cations.
Driving force: The lattice energy (energy holding the solid together) vs. the hydration energy (energy released when ions are surrounded by water).
Net energy change:
ΔHsolution=Lattice Energy−Hydration Energy
If ΔHsolution is negative (exothermic) or small positive, the compound tends to dissolve.
2. Why Some Salts Are Always Soluble (Group 1 & NH₄⁺)
Rule: All salts of NaX+, KX+, NHX4X+ are soluble.
Why?
These cations are large and have low charge density (charge/size ratio is small).
Their lattice energies are relatively low because the ions are far apart in the crystal.
Their hydration energies are high enough to overcome the lattice energy.
Key formula: For a cation like KX+, the hydration energy is roughly:
ΔHhyd∝rq2
where q is charge and r is ionic radius.
Since q=1 and r is large, ΔHhyd is moderate — but lattice energy is even smaller.
Result: The net ΔHsolution is negative → spontaneous dissolution.
3. Why Nitrates, Acetates, and Chlorates Are Always Soluble
Rule: All nitrates (NOX3X−), acetates (CHX3COOX−), and chlorates (ClOX3X−) are soluble.
Why?
These anions are large and polyatomic — their charge is spread over many atoms.
This delocalization of charge means they have low charge density.
They form weak ionic bonds with cations (low lattice energy).
Water can easily hydrate them because the negative charge is not concentrated.
Key insight: The lattice energy for NaNOX3 is much smaller than for NaCl because NOX3X− is larger and more polarizable.
4. The "Exceptions" — Why Some Salts Are Insoluble
4.1. Carbonates, Phosphates, Sulfides (Except with Group 1 & NH₄⁺)
Rule: Most carbonates (COX3X2−), phosphates (POX4X3−), and sulfides (SX2−) are insoluble.
Why?
These anions have high charge (−2 or −3) and are small (especially SX2−).
This gives them very high charge density.
They form extremely strong ionic bonds with cations (very high lattice energy).
The hydration energy, though large, is not enough to overcome the lattice energy.
Example: For CaCOX3:
Lattice energy≈−2800 kJ/mol
Hydration energy≈−2400 kJ/mol
Net ΔHsolution≈+400 kJ/mol → insoluble
4.2. Silver, Lead, Mercury Halides
Rule: AgCl, PbClX2, HgX2ClX2 are insoluble (most other chlorides are soluble).
Why?
AgX+, PbX2+, HgX2X2+ are soft (polarizable) cations.
They form covalent character in their bonds with halides (especially ClX−, BrX−, IX−).
This covalent contribution increases the effective lattice energy beyond what simple ionic models predict.
Water cannot break these partially covalent bonds.
The maximum molarity of CuS in water is simply the square root of its Ksp, because the salt dissociates in a 1:1 ratio. The answer is 2.45×10−8M.
The key to this problem is understanding what "maximum molarity" means in the context of a sparingly soluble salt. When you drop CuS into water, only a tiny amount dissolves. The dissolved CuS breaks apart completely into ions:
CuS(s)⇌Cu2+(aq)+S2−(aq)
The solution becomes saturated when no more solid can dissolve. At that point, the product of the ion concentrations hits a fixed ceiling — the solubility product constant, Ksp. That ceiling is what we use to find the molar solubility.
For a salt AxBy, Ksp=[Ay+]x[Bx−]y. For a 1:1 salt like CuS, Ksp=s2, where s is the molar solubility.
Now, let's walk through the calculation.
Write the dissociation equilibrium.
Every mole of CuS that dissolves gives one mole of Cu2+ and one mole of S2−. If the molar solubility is s mol/L, then:
[Cu2+]=s,[S2−]=s
Write the Ksp expression.
From the equilibrium:
Ksp=[Cu2+][S2−]=s⋅s=s2
Plug in the given value.
We know Ksp=6×10−16. So:
Method: Solubility Product (Ksp) to Molar Solubility
Concept (Why this works)
For a sparingly soluble salt, the solubility product Ksp is the equilibrium constant for its dissolution. At saturation, the product of ion concentrations (each raised to the power of its stoichiometric coefficient) equals Ksp. The maximum molarity of the salt that can stay dissolved is its molar solubility, s.
Steps
Step 1: Write the dissociation equation
CuS(s)⇌Cu2+(aq)+S2−(aq)
CuS is a 1:1 (AB-type) salt -- one mole of CuS gives one mole of Cu2+ and one mole of S2−.
Step 2: Express ion concentrations in terms of molar solubility s
Here are the common mistakes students make when solving this type of solubility product problem, along with how to avoid each.
1. Forgetting the Stoichiometry of Dissociation
The Mistake:
Students often write Ksp=[Cu2+][S2−] and then set [Cu2+]=[S2−]=s, but then incorrectly write Ksp=s2 without checking the dissociation equation.
Why it happens:
They memorise the formula Ksp=s2 for all 1:1 salts, but CuS dissociates as:
CuS(s)⇌Cu2+(aq)+S2−(aq)
Here, one mole of CuS gives one mole of each ion, so s=[Cu2+]=[S2−] and Ksp=s2 is actually correct for this case. The mistake is assuming this holds for every salt (e.g., for Ag2CrO4, Ksp=4s3).
How to avoid:
Always write the balanced dissociation equation first. Then express each ion concentration in terms of s (molar solubility). Only then substitute into the Ksp expression.
2. Confusing Molar Solubility with Ksp
The Mistake:
Students think Kspis the solubility, so they answer 6×10−16 M directly.
Why it happens:
They see “solubility product” and “maximum molarity” and assume they are the same number.
How to avoid:
Remember:
Ksp = equilibrium constant (product of ion concentrations at saturation).
Molar solubility (s) = concentration of the salt that dissolves (in mol/L).
For CuS:
Ksp=s2⇒s=Ksp
So the correct calculation is:
s=6×10−16=6×10−8≈2.45×10−8 M
Key result: The maximum molarity is 2.45×10−8 M, not 6×10−16 M.
3. Incorrect Square Root Calculation
The Mistake:
Taking 6×10−16 and writing 3×10−8 (forgetting to take square root of 6) or 6×10−8 (taking square root of exponent only).
Why it happens:
Rushing the arithmetic or not knowing that a×10b=a×10b/2.
How to avoid:
Break it down step by step:
6×10−16=6×10−16=6×10−8
Then approximate 6≈2.45.
Always check: the exponent should be halved (from −16 to −8).
4. Ignoring Units or Significant Figures
The Mistake:
Writing the answer as 2.45×10−8 without units, or using too many/few decimal places.