Comparing Fractions – The Intuition First
Imagine two pizzas of the same size. One is cut into 4 equal slices, and you take 3 of them — that's 43 of a pizza. The other is cut into 8 equal slices, and you take 5 of them — that's 85 of a pizza. Which one gives you more pizza?
Your eyes might tell you that 5 slices looks like more than 3 slices. But the slices themselves are different sizes. So you can't just compare the top numbers (numerators) — you have to account for how big each piece is. That's the whole problem of comparing fractions: the denominator tells you the size of each piece, and the numerator tells you how many of those pieces you have.
A fraction ba means: take a whole, divide it into b equal parts, and take a of them. The denominator b is the size of each part (smaller denominator = bigger parts). The numerator a is the count of parts.
So comparing 43 and 85 is like comparing "3 big pieces" vs "5 smaller pieces." Which is more? You need a common language.
The Precise Method: Same Denominator
The cleanest way to compare any two fractions is to rewrite them so they have the same denominator. Once the denominators match, you just compare the numerators — the fraction with the larger numerator is larger.
Example: Compare 43 and 85.
Find a common denominator. The smallest one that both 4 and 8 divide into is 8.
- 43=4×23×2=86
- 85 stays 85
Now compare: 86 vs 85. Since 6>5, we have 43>85.
That matches the pizza intuition: three quarters of a pizza is indeed more than five eighths.
To compare ba and dc:
- Find a common denominator (often b×d works).
- Rewrite: ba=b×da×d, dc=d×bc×b.
- Compare numerators a×d and c×b.
The Cross-Multiplication Shortcut
You don't actually have to write the new denominators. Just compare the cross-products:
For ba and dc:
- Compute a×d and c×b.
- If a×d>c×b, then ba>dc.
Example: Compare 32 and 53.
Cross-multiply: 2×5=10, 3×3=9. Since 10>9, we have 32>53.
Cross-multiplication is just the "same denominator" method in disguise — you're comparing a×d and c×b because the common denominator b×d is the same for both.
Special Cases That Save Time
Same denominator: Just compare numerators. 107>103 because 7>3. …