Skip to content
Worked Examples · Example 8.16

Q.Write resonance structures of CH₃COO⁻ and show the movement of electrons by curved arrows.

CBSENCERTSubjective· 2mImportance★★★★★est
12% · 16/130 Questions
✓ Free question

The acetate ion (CH3COO−\text{CH}_3\text{COO}^-) has two equivalent resonance structures where the negative charge is delocalised equally over both oxygen atoms. The actual ion is a hybrid of these two forms, with each C–O bond having a bond order of 1.5.

Why Resonance Matters Here

The acetate ion is a classic example of resonance stabilisation. If you try to draw a single Lewis structure for CH3COO−\text{CH}_3\text{COO}^-, you'll face a dilemma: which oxygen gets the negative charge? The answer is that neither oxygen "owns" the charge permanently — instead, the charge is shared between them through a delocalised π-electron system.

This delocalisation makes the acetate ion much more stable than a simple Lewis structure would suggest. The two C–O bonds become identical, with a bond length somewhere between a single and a double bond.

Drawing the Resonance Structures

Step 1: Draw the basic skeleton

The acetate ion has a methyl group (CH3\text{CH}_3) attached to a carboxylate group (COO−\text{COO}^-). The carbon of the carboxylate is sp2sp^2 hybridized, forming a planar structure.

    O
    ||
H₃C — C
    |
    O⁻

This is one possible Lewis structure — but it's not the whole story.

Step 2: Identify the delocalisable electrons

The key players are:

  • The π-bond (double bond) between carbon and the top oxygen
  • The lone pair on the negatively charged bottom oxygen

These four electrons (2 from the π-bond, 2 from the lone pair) can move because they're in a conjugated system — the pp orbitals on all three atoms (C, O₁, O₂) overlap.

Step 3: Push the electrons with curved arrows

From the structure above, the lone pair on the bottom oxygen moves to form a π-bond between that oxygen and carbon. Simultaneously, the existing π-bond between carbon and the top oxygen breaks, and those electrons move onto the top oxygen as a lone pair.

The curved arrow starts at the electron source (the lone pair) and points to where the bond forms. A second arrow starts at the π-bond and points to the oxygen that receives the electrons.

This gives the second resonance structure:

    O⁻
    |
H₃C — C
    ||
    O

Step 4: Recognise the equivalence

These two structures are identical in energy — they're just mirror images. The methyl group doesn't participate in the resonance, so it stays unchanged.

Tip

A quick way to check: count the total number of electrons in each structure. Both have 24 valence electrons (4 from C, 1 from each H, 6 from each O, plus 1 for the negative charge). The connectivity is the same; only the π-bond location changes.

Step 5: Draw the resonance hybrid

The actual acetate ion is not flipping between these two forms — it's a single, stable hybrid. The two C–O bonds are identical, each with a bond order of 1.5. The negative charge is spread equally over both oxygen atoms.

You can represent this with a dashed line between the two oxygens and the carbon, or with a δ⁻ on each oxygen.

Watch out

A common mistake is to draw the curved arrow from the π-bond to the oxygen without also showing the lone pair moving to form the new π-bond. Both arrows are essential — you're moving four electrons total, not just two. If you only show one arrow, you'll end up with an impossible structure (a carbon with only 6 electrons).

The Final Structures

Here are the two resonance structures with curved arrows:

Structure 1 (left form):

    O                    O⁻
    ||                   |
H₃C — C      →      H₃C — C
    |                   ||
    O⁻                  O

The arrow from the lone pair on O−\text{O}^- points toward the C–O bond region. The arrow from the C=O π-bond points toward the top oxygen.

Structure 2 (right form):

    O⁻                  O
    |                   ||
H₃C — C      →      H₃C — C
    ||                  |
    O                   O⁻

The arrows are reversed — the lone pair on the new O−\text{O}^- moves to form the π-bond, and the old π-bond breaks to give a lone pair on the other oxygen.

The resonance hybrid is often written as:

H3C−C(O−O)\text{H}_3\text{C} - \text{C} \left( \begin{array}{c} \text{O}^- \\ \text{O} \end{array} \right)

with a dashed line or a δ−\delta^- on both oxygens to show equal charge distribution.

✓Final answer

The acetate ion has two equivalent resonance structures, with the negative charge delocalised equally over both oxygen atoms, represented by curved arrows showing the movement of a lone pair to form a π-bond and the simultaneous breaking of the existing π-bond.

Unlock everything free for 14 days

  • Full step-by-step solutions
  • Concept-first explanations
  • Methods, shortcuts & mistakes
  • PYQ mapping + timed mock tests

Full access for 14 days. No credit card required.