Q.Which of the following examples represent (nearly) simple harmonic motion and which represent periodic but not simple harmonic motion?
Simple harmonic motion requires a restoring force exactly proportional to displacement (linear). Among the given examples, only the U-tube mercury column and the ball bearing in a smooth bowl are nearly SHM for small amplitudes; Earth’s rotation is periodic but not SHM, and polyatomic molecular vibrations are periodic but generally not simple harmonic.
The key to recognising simple harmonic motion (SHM) is the linear restoring force — the force must be proportional to the displacement from equilibrium and directed opposite to it. That gives the equation , or equivalently . If the force law is different (e.g., constant, or nonlinear), the motion is periodic but not simple harmonic.
Let’s examine each case.
-
Rotation of Earth about its axis
The Earth spins with a nearly constant angular velocity. There is no restoring force at all — it’s uniform circular motion, not oscillatory. The motion repeats every 24 hours, so it is periodic, but there is no force proportional to displacement. Hence it is periodic but not SHM.
-
Oscillating mercury column in a U-tube
When you push the mercury down on one side, the imbalance in height creates a pressure difference. The restoring force is proportional to the height difference (since ), and for small displacements this gives . That’s exactly the SHM condition.
TipThe U-tube oscillator is a classic example of SHM — the restoring force is linear because the weight of the unbalanced column is directly proportional to the displacement.
So this represents nearly SHM (exactly SHM for small amplitudes, ignoring friction).
-
Ball bearing inside a smooth curved bowl
For a bowl that is spherical (or parabolic near the bottom), the restoring force along the tangent is . For small angles, , and the displacement along the arc is , so , which is linear. Hence the motion is nearly SHM for small releases.
Watch outFor large amplitudes, , and the motion becomes periodic but anharmonic (not SHM). The problem says “nearly” — so small oscillations qualify.
-
General vibrations of a polyatomic molecule
A polyatomic molecule has many vibrational modes. For very small displacements from equilibrium, the potential energy is approximately quadratic (Taylor expansion), so each normal mode is SHM. But the problem says “general vibrations” — that includes large-amplitude motions where anharmonic terms matter. Also, the molecule has many coupled oscillators; the overall motion is a superposition of many frequencies. It is periodic (if all frequencies are commensurate) but not simple harmonic because the net motion is not a single sine wave.
NoteIf the question meant a single normal mode at small amplitude, it would be SHM. But “general vibrations” implies the full, possibly anharmonic, motion — so it’s periodic but not SHM.
- Periodic but not SHM;
- nearly SHM;
- nearly SHM;
- periodic but not SHM.
Unlock everything free for 14 days
- Full step-by-step solutions
- Concept-first explanations
- Methods, shortcuts & mistakes
- PYQ mapping + timed mock tests
Full access for 14 days. No credit card required.