Skip to content
Question

Q.Read the given source carefully and answer the questions that follow : On clearance and settled cultivation Passing through one village in the lower Rajmahal hills, Buchanan wrote : The view of the country is exceedingly fine, the cultivation, especially the narrow valleys of rice winding in all directions, the cleared lands with scattered trees, and the rocky hills are in perfection; all that is wanted is some appearance of progress in the area and a vastly extended and improved cultivation, of which the country is highly susceptible. Plantations of Asan and Palas, for Tessar (Tassar silk worms) and Lac, should occupy the place of woods to as great an extent as the demand will admit; the remainder might be all cleared, and the greater part cultivated, while what is not fit for the purpose, might rear Plamira (palmyra) and Mowa (mahua). (33.1) How was the landscape described regarding cultivation ?

(1) (33.2) Which crops were recommended for expanding agriculture ?
(1) (33.3) Explain the proposal given by Buchanan for utilizing the land for economic development. (2)
CBSECBSE Class XII Board 2026Subjective· 4mImportance★★★★★
🔒 Locked · start free trial →

You're viewing a preview — the full solution, concept, methods & PYQ mapping are locked.

Start your 14-day free trial to unlock the full solution →

Buchanan's 1810s survey of the Rajmahal hills reveals the colonial vision of transforming a forested, shifting-cultivation landscape into settled, commercially productive agriculture through forest clearance, plantation crops, and intensive cultivation.

Francis Buchanan was a physician-surveyor employed by the East India Company in the early nineteenth century to conduct detailed surveys of territories under British control. His reports were not merely descriptive; they were instruments of colonial policy, assessing how "wasteland" could be made revenue-productive. The passage comes from his survey of the Rajmahal hills in present-day Jharkhand, an area inhabited by the Paharias and Santhals who practiced shifting cultivation (jhum) in forested uplands.

When Buchanan writes that the landscape is "exceedingly fine," he is admiring it through a colonial lens—the "narrow valleys of rice," "cleared lands with scattered trees," and "rocky hills" represent a picturesque scene, but one that falls short of his ideal. The phrase "all that is wanted is some appearance of progress" is telling. For Buchanan, "progress" meant permanent fields, commercial crops, and visible signs of sedentary agriculture. The existing cultivation—likely a mix of jhum and valley rice—was insufficient because it did not maximize revenue or conform to British notions of productive land use.

Note

Buchanan's surveys were part of a broader colonial project to map, classify, and "improve" Indian landscapes. His recommendations directly influenced policies that displaced forest-dwelling communities and criminalized shifting cultivation.

The crops Buchanan recommended reveal the commercial priorities of the Company. He proposed replacing forests with plantations of Asan and Palas trees, which hosted tassar silkworms and lac insects respectively—both high-value export commodities. Where land was unsuitable for cultivation, he suggested planting palmyra and mahua, trees with economic uses (palmyra for toddy and fiber, mahua for oil and liquor). The emphasis was not on subsistence but on cash crops and forest products that could be taxed and traded.

Important

Buchanan's vision was fundamentally about converting "unproductive" forests into revenue-generating assets. This colonial logic treated forests as empty spaces to be cleared, ignoring the livelihoods of communities who depended on them for shifting cultivation, hunting, and gathering. …

Unlock everything free for 14 days

  • Full step-by-step solutions
  • Concept-first explanations
  • Methods, shortcuts & mistakes
  • PYQ mapping + timed mock tests

Full access for 14 days. No credit card required.