Skip to content
Question

Q.Study the cartoon given below carefully and answer the questions that follow. [Cartoon: a stone monument/gravestone bearing a circle of stars (the European Union emblem) rising out of the sea, surrounded by icebergs; the only printed text within the cartoon is an artist's signature/watermark along the right edge, which is illegible.]

(i) The above cartoon is related to which organisation ?
(a) ASEAN
(b) European Union
(c) SAARC
(d) BRICS
(ii) The above cartoon is about which one of the following ?
(a) Global warming
(b) Failure to make a trade agreement
(c) Failure to draft a common constitution
(d) Failure to protect the environment
(iii) What does the circle of stars shown in the cartoon represent ?
(a) Member-states of the organisation
(b) Unity of the organisation
(c) Success of the organisation
(d) Composition of the organisation
(iv) In which year was the organisation related to the cartoon established ?
(a) 1967
(b) 1985
(c) 1992
(d) 2006 [For Visually Impaired Candidates, in lieu of this question:
(i) Which organisation was established under the Marshall Plan ?
(a) Council of Europe
(b) Organisation for European Economic Cooperation
(c) European Community
(d) European Economic Community
(ii) Which two countries have resisted to adopt Maastricht Treaty ?
(a) Bulgaria, Romania
(b) Britain, France
(c) Denmark, Sweden
(d) Poland, Finland
(iii) China adopted the 'open door' policy to improve its economy in which year ?
(a) 1975
(b) 1977
(c) 1978
(d) 1979
(iv) Which set of five countries were the founders of ASEAN ?
(a) Indonesia, Malaysia, Philippines, Singapore and Thailand
(b) Indonesia, Malaysia, Philippines, Thailand and Brunei
(c) Indonesia, Philippines, Singapore, Thailand and Brunei
(d) Indonesia, Malaysia, Philippines, Vietnam and Thailand]
CBSECBSE Class XII Board 2023Subjective· 4mImportance★★★★★
🔒 Locked · start free trial →

You're viewing a preview — the full solution, concept, methods & PYQ mapping are locked.

Start your 14-day free trial to unlock the full solution →

The cartoon depicts the European Union as a monument struggling amidst challenges, specifically referencing its emblem and the difficulties it faced in achieving deeper political integration, such as drafting a common constitution.

The cartoon presents a powerful visual metaphor for an international organisation facing significant challenges. The central image is a stone monument, resembling a gravestone, bearing the distinctive emblem of a circle of stars. This monument rises from a turbulent sea, surrounded by numerous icebergs, suggesting a perilous and difficult environment. Understanding the symbolism of the emblem and the context of the organisation it represents is key to interpreting the cartoon's message.

(i) The above cartoon is related to which organisation?

The most prominent clue in the cartoon is the emblem on the monument: a circle of stars. This symbol is universally recognised as the emblem of the European Union. The European Union (EU) is a unique political and economic union of 27 member states located primarily in Europe. Its flag, adopted by its predecessor, the European Economic Community, in 1986, features twelve gold stars in a circle on a blue background. This emblem is a direct identifier.

  • (a) ASEAN (Association of Southeast Asian Nations) uses an emblem of ten stalks of padi (rice) bound together, representing the ten member states and their solidarity.
  • (c) SAARC (South Asian Association for Regional Cooperation) uses an emblem featuring a dove, symbolising peace, within a circle of eight hands, representing the eight member states.
  • (d) BRICS is an acronym for an association of five major emerging national economies (Brazil, Russia, India, China, and South Africa) and does not have a single, widely recognised emblem like the one shown.

Therefore, the organisation related to the cartoon is the European Union.

(ii) The above cartoon is about which one of the following?

The cartoon depicts the European Union monument rising from a troubled sea, surrounded by icebergs. The monument itself has the appearance of a gravestone, implying a project that is either struggling, facing demise, or has encountered a significant setback. The icebergs symbolise numerous obstacles, dangers, or cold, divisive forces.

Considering the history of the European Union, one of its most significant internal struggles and a major setback to its ambition for deeper political integration was the failure to draft a common constitution. In the early 2000s, there was a concerted effort to create a single, overarching constitution for the EU. However, this project faced strong resistance and was ultimately rejected in referendums in some member states, notably France and the Netherlands, in 2005. This failure was a profound disappointment for many who envisioned a more unified Europe and led to the eventual adoption of the Lisbon Treaty as a reform treaty instead of a full constitution. The "gravestone" imagery could powerfully represent the "death" of this constitutional project, with the icebergs symbolising the diverse national interests and political divisions that prevented its adoption.

  • (a) Global warming and (d) Failure to protect the environment, while related to icebergs, are not the primary focus of the EU's existential struggles as depicted by the monument itself. The cartoon is more about the internal health and direction of the organisation.
  • (b) Failure to make a trade agreement is too specific and a recurring, rather than a singular, foundational challenge that would merit such a stark depiction.

The most fitting interpretation, given the symbolism of a struggling monument and the historical context of major EU challenges, is the failure to draft a common constitution.

Important

The failure to adopt the Treaty establishing a Constitution for Europe (often referred to as the European Constitution) in 2005 was a significant moment in the EU's history, highlighting the difficulties in achieving deeper political integration among diverse member states.

(iii) What does the circle of stars shown in the cartoon represent?

The circle of twelve gold stars on a blue background is the official emblem of the European Union. Its meaning is clearly defined: it symbolises the ideals of unity, solidarity, and harmony among the peoples of Europe. …

Unlock everything free for 14 days

  • Full step-by-step solutions
  • Concept-first explanations
  • Methods, shortcuts & mistakes
  • PYQ mapping + timed mock tests

Full access for 14 days. No credit card required.