Skip to content
NCERT Exemplar · Q24

Q.Why do compounds having similar geometry have different magnetic moment?

CBSEShort· 2mImportance★★★★★
71% · 72/101 Questions
🔒 Locked · start free trial →

You're viewing a preview — the full solution, concept, methods & PYQ mapping are locked.

Start your 14-day free trial to unlock the full solution →

Magnetic moment depends on the number of unpaired electrons, which is determined by the ligand field strength and the metal ion's electron configuration — not just the geometry. Two compounds with identical geometry can have different magnetic moments if the metal ion or the ligand field strength differs, leading to different numbers of unpaired electrons.

The magnetic moment of a transition metal complex is a direct measure of its number of unpaired electrons. For first-row transition metals, the spin-only formula μ=n(n+2)\mu = \sqrt{n(n+2)} BM (where nn is the number of unpaired electrons) works very well. So when two compounds share the same geometry — say, both are octahedral — but have different magnetic moments, the reason must lie in a different number of unpaired electrons.

Why would the same geometry give different nn? The answer lies in the ligand field strength and the metal ion's electron configuration. In octahedral geometry, the dd orbitals split into t2gt_{2g} (lower energy) and ege_g (higher energy). For a given dnd^n configuration, the electrons can arrange themselves in two ways:

  • High-spin: Electrons occupy all five dd orbitals singly before pairing, maximizing unpaired electrons. This happens when the ligand field splitting Δo\Delta_o is small (weak field ligands like HX2O\ce{H2O}, FX−\ce{F-}).
  • Low-spin: Electrons pair up in the lower t2gt_{2g} orbitals before occupying ege_g, minimizing unpaired electrons. This happens when Δo\Delta_o is large (strong field ligands like CNX−\ce{CN-}, CO\ce{CO}).

Thus, two octahedral complexes of the same metal ion (same dnd^n) can have different magnetic moments if one has weak-field ligands (high-spin) and the other has strong-field ligands (low-spin). Even if the metal ion is different, the dnd^n count and ligand strength together determine the moment.

Let's work through a concrete example to see this clearly.

  1. Identify the metal ion and its dnd^n configuration.

    Consider [CoFX6]X3−\ce{[CoF6]^{3-}} and [Co(NHX3)X6]X3+\ce{[Co(NH3)6]^{3+}}. Both are octahedral. Cobalt in the +3 oxidation state has the electron configuration [Ar] 3d6[\ce{Ar}]\,3d^6. So d6d^6 for both.

  2. Determine the ligand field strength.

    FX−\ce{F-} is a weak field ligand (low in the spectrochemical series). NHX3\ce{NH3} is a moderate field ligand, but for CoX3+\ce{Co^{3+}}, it is strong enough to cause pairing. In fact, CoX3+\ce{Co^{3+}} is a d6d^6 ion that is particularly prone to low-spin configurations with ligands like NHX3\ce{NH3}, CNX−\ce{CN-}, etc.

  3. Predict the electron configuration in the t2gt_{2g} and ege_g orbitals.

    For [CoFX6]X3−\ce{[CoF6]^{3-}} (weak field, high-spin):

    • Δo\Delta_o is small.
    • Electrons fill according to Hund's rule: t2g4eg2t_{2g}^4 e_g^2 (four electrons in t2gt_{2g} with one pair, two unpaired in ege_g).
    • Number of unpaired electrons n=4n = 4.
    • Magnetic moment μ=4(4+2)=24≈4.90\mu = \sqrt{4(4+2)} = \sqrt{24} \approx 4.90 BM.

    For [Co(NHX3)X6]X3+\ce{[Co(NH3)6]^{3+}} (strong field, low-spin):

    • Δo\Delta_o is large.
    • Electrons pair up in t2gt_{2g}: t2g6eg0t_{2g}^6 e_g^0 (all six electrons paired in t2gt_{2g}).
    • Number of unpaired electrons n=0n = 0.
    • Magnetic moment μ=0\mu = 0 BM (diamagnetic).
  4. Compare the magnetic moments.

    The fluoride complex has a moment of about 4.9 BM, while the ammine complex is diamagnetic. Both are octahedral, but the magnetic moments are drastically different — purely because of the ligand field strength.

Watch out

A common mistake is to assume that geometry alone determines the magnetic moment. In fact, the same geometry can yield high-spin or low-spin configurations depending on the ligand. Always check the spectrochemical series and the metal ion's dnd^n count. …

Unlock everything free for 14 days

  • Full step-by-step solutions
  • Concept-first explanations
  • Methods, shortcuts & mistakes
  • PYQ mapping + timed mock tests

Full access for 14 days. No credit card required.