Q.A sinusoidal voltage of peak value 283 V and frequency 50 Hz is applied to a series LCR circuit in which R=3 Ω, L=25.48 mH, and C=796 μF. Find
Concept understanding — Power Dissipation in Resistors
Power Dissipation in Resistors
Whenever charge is driven through a resistor, electrical energy is converted into heat. The rate of this conversion is the power dissipated.
Why a Resistor Heats Up
Inside a resistor, drifting electrons repeatedly collide with the vibrating lattice ions. Each collision transfers kinetic energy to the lattice, raising its temperature. The source (battery or AC supply) continually does work to keep the current flowing, and that work reappears as heat. This is Joule heating.
The Power Formulas (DC)
The power delivered to any device carrying current I across a potential difference V is
P=VI
For an ohmic resistor V=IR, so this can be written in three equivalent forms:
P=VI=I2R=RV2
The SI unit is the watt (W), where 1 W=1 J s−1.
Which form to use depends on what is fixed:
- Series elements share the same current, so P=I2R shows the larger resistor dissipates more.
- Parallel elements share the same voltage, so P=V2/R shows the smaller resistor dissipates more.
The total heat produced in time t is Q=Pt=I2Rt — Joule's law of heating.
Power Dissipation with AC
With alternating current the instantaneous power p(t)=i2(t)R fluctuates, but a resistor still only dissipates energy (it never returns any). The average power over a cycle is written with root-mean-square values:
Pavg=Irms2R=RVrms2=VrmsIrms
where for a sinusoid Irms=Im/2 and Vrms=Vm/2. This is precisely why rms values are defined: an AC of rms value Irms heats a resistor at the same average rate as a steady DC of value Irms.
A pure resistor has power factor 1 — voltage and current are in phase, so all the power supplied is dissipated. In inductors and capacitors, by contrast, the average dissipated power is zero; energy is only stored and returned.
Worked Example
A 100 Ω resistor carries a current of 0.5 A.
P=I2R=(0.5)2×100=25 W
In one minute it releases Q=Pt=25×60=1500 J of heat.
Do not mix peak and rms quantities. Using peak AC values in P=V2/R overestimates the average power by a factor of two for a sinusoid.
Everyday Relevance
Electric heaters, incandescent bulbs and fuses all rely on controlled I2R heating, while transmission engineers fight to minimise it — sending power at high voltage keeps I small and cuts the I2R line losses.
Power dissipation in resistors through Joule heating, P = I²R = V²/R, spans the NCERT Class 12 Physics chapters on current electricity and alternating current, and is one of the most frequently numerically tested formulas in CBSE boards, JEE Main and NEET. Searches for "power dissipated in a resistor formula rms value class 12 physics" will find this DC-and-AC comparison matches the NCERT-prescribed treatment.
Why this formula?
Power Dissipation in Resistors — Why the Formula Holds
Let's build this from first principles. The goal is to understand why a resistor dissipates power as heat, and how the formula P=I2R (and its equivalents) arise naturally.
1. What is "Power" in an Electrical Circuit?
Power is the rate of energy transfer — how much energy is converted from one form to another per unit time.
- In a resistor, electrical energy is converted into heat (thermal energy).
- The fundamental definition of electrical power is:
P=V⋅I
where:
- P = power (watts, W)
- V = voltage across the component (volts, V)
- I = current through the component (amperes, A)
Why this definition?
Voltage is energy per unit charge (V=qW), and current is charge per unit time (I=tq). Multiplying them gives energy per unit time — exactly power.
2. How Does a Resistor Behave? — Ohm's Law
A resistor obeys Ohm's Law:
V=I⋅R
where R is resistance (ohms, Ω). This is an empirical law — it describes how real resistors behave: the voltage across them is proportional to the current through them.
3. Deriving the Power Dissipation Formulas
We start with P=VI and substitute Ohm's Law in two ways.
Case A: Express power in terms of I and R
Replace V with IR:
P=(IR)⋅I=I2R
Interpretation:
- For a fixed resistance, power grows with the square of current.
- Doubling current quadruples the heat generated — this is why high currents cause wires to overheat.
Case B: Express power in terms of V and R
Replace I with RV:
P=V⋅(RV)=RV2
Interpretation:
- For a fixed voltage, power is inversely proportional to resistance.
- A low-resistance resistor (like a short circuit) dissipates huge power at a given voltage — that's why short circuits are dangerous.
4. The Physical "Why" — Energy Conversion at the Atomic Level
Why does this energy turn into heat?
- Electrons moving through a resistor collide with the atoms of the material.
- Each collision transfers kinetic energy from the electron to the atom, making the atom vibrate more — i.e., heating up the resistor.
- The rate at which this energy is lost by the electrons (and gained by the lattice) is exactly P=I2R.
Key insight:
The I2 term appears because:
- More current = more electrons per second.
- Each electron loses more energy if resistance is higher (more collisions per electron).
5. Summary of Key Formulas
| Formula | When to use |
|---|---|
| P=VI | Fundamental — always true for any circuit element |
| P=I2R | Best when you know current and resistance |
| P=RV2 | Best when you know voltage and resistance |
All three are equivalent for resistors obeying Ohm's Law.
6. Exam Tip — Common Mistake
Never mix formulas across different components:
- For a resistor, all three forms work.
- For a diode or battery, only P=VI holds — Ohm's Law does not apply, so I2R would be wrong.
Remember: The derivation starts from P=VI, then uses Ohm's Law. If the component doesn't follow Ohm's Law, the derived forms are invalid.
Final takeaway: Power dissipation in a resistor is the rate at which electrical energy is converted to heat, given by P=I2R because voltage and current are linked by resistance. The I2 factor explains why even small increases in current cause large heating effects — a critical concept for circuit safety and design.
Concept: Power Dissipation in Resistors — in an AC circuit, only the resistor dissipates power; the average power is P=VrmsIrmscosϕ=Irms2R.
Step 1 — Reactances and impedance
Inductive reactance:
XL=2πfL=2π(50)(25.48×10−3)=8 Ω
Capacitive reactance:
XC=2πfC1=2π(50)(796×10−6)1=4 Ω
Net reactance: X=XL−XC=4 Ω
Impedance: Z=R2+X2=32+42=5 Ω
Step 2 — Phase difference and power factor
tanϕ=RX=34⇒ϕ=tan−1(34)≈53.13∘ (voltage leads current)
Power factor: cosϕ=ZR=53=0.6
Step 3 — Power dissipated
RMS voltage: Vrms=2283≈200 V
RMS current: Irms=ZVrms=5200=40 A
Power: P=Irms2R=(40)2(3)=4800 W
- Impedance is 5 Ω;
- phase difference is 53.13∘ (voltage leads);
- power dissipated is 4800 W;
- power factor is 0.6.
For a series LCR circuit driven by an AC source, the impedance is the vector sum of resistance and net reactance. Here, XL=8 Ω, XC=4 Ω, so net reactance X=4 Ω, giving impedance Z=5 Ω. The phase angle ϕ=tan−1(X/R)=53.13∘ (voltage leads current). Power factor cosϕ=0.6, and power dissipated P=VrmsIrmscosϕ=4800 W.
Concept and Intuition
In a series LCR circuit, the resistor, inductor, and capacitor each oppose current in different ways. Resistance R dissipates energy as heat. Inductive reactance XL=ωL and capacitive reactance XC=1/(ωC) store and release energy but do not dissipate it — they merely cause a phase shift between voltage and current.
The total opposition to current is impedance Z, given by:
Z=R2+(XL−XC)2
The phase difference ϕ tells us whether the circuit behaves more like an inductor (voltage leads current, ϕ>0) or a capacitor (current leads voltage, ϕ<0):
tanϕ=RXL−XC
Power is only dissipated in the resistor. The average power over a cycle is:
P=VrmsIrmscosϕ
where cosϕ is the power factor.
Step-by-Step Solution
1. Find the angular frequency ω
Given frequency f=50 Hz:
ω=2πf=2π×50=100π rad/s
2. Calculate inductive reactance XL
L=25.48 mH=25.48×10−3 H
XL=ωL=100π×25.48×10−3
Using π≈3.14:
XL=100×3.14×25.48×10−3=314×0.02548≈8.00 Ω
Notice 25.48×3.14≈80.0, then divide by 1000 gives exactly 8 Ω. This neat round number is common in exam problems.
3. Calculate capacitive reactance XC
C=796 μF=796×10−6 F
XC=ωC1=100π×796×10−61
First compute ωC=100π×796×10−6=314×796×10−6
314×796≈250,000 (since 314×800=251,200, minus 314×4=1,256 gives 249,944)
So ωC≈0.25
XC=0.251=4.00 Ω
4. Compute net reactance X
X=XL−XC=8−4=4 Ω
The circuit is inductive (positive reactance).
5. Find impedance Z
Z=R2+X2=32+42=9+16=25=5 Ω
Z=R2+(XL−XC)2
6. Determine phase difference ϕ
tanϕ=RX=34⇒ϕ=tan−1(34)≈53.13∘
Since XL>XC, voltage leads current by 53.13∘.
7. Calculate rms values of source voltage and current
Peak voltage V0=283 V
Vrms=2V0=1.414283≈200 V
A common mistake is to use peak values directly in power formulas. Always convert to rms for AC power calculations.
Irms=ZVrms=5200=40 A
8. Find power factor
Power factor=cosϕ=ZR=53=0.6
9. Compute power dissipated
P=VrmsIrmscosϕ=200×40×0.6=4800 W
Alternatively, since only the resistor dissipates power:
P=Irms2R=402×3=1600×3=4800 W
The I2R formula is often quicker and avoids needing the power factor separately — but both give the same result.
- Impedance Z=5 Ω;
- Phase difference ϕ=53.13∘ (voltage leads current);
- Power dissipated P=4800 W;
- Power factor cosϕ=0.6.
Method: Phasor Analysis of Series LCR Circuit
This method uses phasor diagrams and impedance triangle to solve AC circuit problems step-by-step.
Step 1: Find Inductive and Capacitive Reactance
Given:
- V0=283 V, f=50 Hz
- R=3 Ω, L=25.48 mH=25.48×10−3 H
- C=796 μF=796×10−6 F
Angular frequency:
ω=2πf=2π×50=100π rad/s
Inductive reactance:
XL=ωL=100π×25.48×10−3
XL=100×3.1416×25.48×10−3≈8 Ω
Capacitive reactance:
XC=ωC1=100π×796×10−61
XC≈4 Ω
Step 2: Calculate Impedance (Part a)
Net reactance:
X=XL−XC=8−4=4 Ω
Impedance magnitude:
Z=R2+X2=32+42=9+16=25
Z=5 Ω
Step 3: Find Phase Difference (Part b)
Phase angle ϕ (voltage leads current if XL>XC):
tanϕ=RX=34
ϕ=tan−1(34)≈53.13∘
Since XL>XC, voltage leads current by 53.13∘.
Step 4: Compute Power Dissipated (Part c)
RMS voltage:
Vrms=2V0=2283≈200 V
RMS current:
Irms=ZVrms=5200=40 A
Power dissipated (only in resistor):
P=Irms2R=(40)2×3=4800 W
Step 5: Determine Power Factor (Part d)
Power factor:
cosϕ=ZR=53=0.6 (lagging)
The power factor is lagging because the circuit is inductive (XL>XC).
Quick Verification
- P=VrmsIrmscosϕ=200×40×0.6=4800 W ✓
Final Answers:
- (a) Z=5 Ω
- (b) ϕ=53.13∘ (voltage leads current)
- (c) P=4800 W
- (d) cosϕ=0.6 (lagging)
Here are the common mistakes students make when solving this exact problem, along with how to avoid each.
Mistake 1: Forgetting to convert units (mH, μF → H, F)
The mistake:
Plugging L=25.48 and C=796 directly into formulas without converting to henries and farads.
How to avoid:
Always write the conversion step explicitly:
- L=25.48 mH=25.48×10−3 H
- C=796 μF=796×10−6 F
Check: If you get an impedance near 3 Ω, you likely converted correctly. If it’s huge or tiny, re-check units.
Mistake 2: Using peak voltage (V0) in RMS formulas for power
The mistake:
Using P=RV02 or P=V0I0cosϕ directly — these give peak power, not average power.
How to avoid:
Remember: Power dissipation in AC circuits uses RMS values.
- Vrms=2V0=2283≈200 V
- Average power: P=VrmsIrmscosϕ or P=Irms2R
Key fact: Only Irms2R gives the correct average power dissipated.
Mistake 3: Confusing phase difference sign (ϕ)
The mistake:
Writing ϕ=tan−1(RXL−XC) but then using the wrong sign when calculating power factor.
How to avoid:
- XL=ωL, XC=ωC1
- If XL>XC, ϕ>0 (voltage leads current — inductive circuit)
- If XL<XC, ϕ<0 (voltage lags current — capacitive circuit)
- Power factor cosϕ is always positive (use ∣ϕ∣ or cosϕ=ZR directly)
Tip: Use cosϕ=ZR — it’s foolproof and avoids sign errors.
Mistake 4: Forgetting ω=2πf (not f)
The mistake:
Using f=50 Hz directly in XL=ωL as XL=fL.
How to avoid:
Always write:
ω=2πf=2π×50=100π rad/s
Then:
XL=ωL=100π×25.48×10−3
XC=ωC1=100π×796×10−61
Mistake 5: Calculating impedance Z incorrectly
The mistake:
Writing Z=R+(XL−XC) or Z=R2+XL2+XC2.
How to avoid:
The correct formula is:
Z=R2+(XL−XC)2
Why: XL and XC are opposite in phase — they subtract, not add.
Mistake 6: Using P=VrmsIrms without cosϕ
The mistake:
Assuming P=VrmsIrms gives power dissipated.
How to avoid:
In an LCR circuit, voltage and current are out of phase. The true power is:
P=VrmsIrmscosϕ
Only the resistive component dissipates power.
Alternative (safer):
P=Irms2R
This automatically accounts for phase — no cosϕ needed.
Mistake 7: Rounding too early
The mistake:
Rounding intermediate values (e.g., XL, XC, Z) to 2–3 digits, then getting a final answer that’s off.
How to avoid:
Keep at least 4 significant figures in intermediate steps. Round only the final answer.
Example:
- XL=100π×0.02548≈8.004 Ω (not 8.0)
- XC=100π×796×10−61≈4.000 Ω (not 4.0)
- Then XL−XC=4.004 Ω, Z=32+4.0042≈5.00 Ω
Quick Summary Checklist
| Step | Common Mistake | Fix |
|---|---|---|
| Units | Use mH/μF directly | Convert to H/F |
| Voltage | Use V0 for power | Use Vrms=V0/2 |
| ω | Use f instead | ω=2πf |
| Z | Add XL and XC | Subtract: XL−XC |
| Power | P=VI | P=Irms2R or P=VrmsIrmscosϕ |
| Rounding | Round early | Keep 4+ digits until final |
Final tip: For part (c), the cleanest path is:
- Find Z
- Irms=Vrms/Z
- P=Irms2R
This avoids any phase sign confusion and gives the correct answer every time.
- CBSE 2026Set 55/1/11 markMCQQ.Two heaters rated as (P1,V) and (P2,V) are connected in series across a dc source of 2V volt. The power consumed by the combination will be (A) (P1+P2) (B) 2P1+P2 (C) 2(P1+P2)P1P2 (D) 4(P1+P2)P1P2
›Reveal solutionSolution
Each heater's resistance is found from its rated power and voltage; in series across 2V, the total power dissipated is 4(P1+P2)P1P2.
Why this approach works
When a device is rated at (P,V), it means that at voltage V it consumes power P. This rating tells us the device's resistance through P=RV2, so R=PV2. Once we know the resistances, we can treat the heaters as ordinary resistors in a series circuit and calculate the actual power consumed at the new operating voltage.
The key insight: rated values describe behavior at a specific voltage, but resistance is an intrinsic property that doesn't change. We extract the resistance from the rating, then analyze the actual circuit.
Step-by-step solution
-
Find the resistance of each heater from its rating.
For heater 1 rated at (P1,V):
R1=P1V2
For heater 2 rated at (P2,V):
R2=P2V2
-
Calculate the total resistance in series.
When connected in series, resistances add:
Rtotal=R1+R2=P1V2+P2V2=V2(P11+P21)=V2⋅P1P2P1+P2
-
Apply the actual supply voltage.
The combination is connected across 2V. The power consumed by a resistor is:
P=RtotalVapplied2
Substituting:
P=V2⋅P1P2P1+P2(2V)2=V2⋅P1P2P1+P24V2
- Simplify the expression.
P=4V2⋅V2(P1+P2)P1P2=4(P1+P2)P1P2
Watch outA common mistake is to think that connecting devices rated at voltage V across 2V means each gets 4V and then trying to scale the rated powers directly. This fails because power doesn't scale linearly with voltage — it scales with V2. Always work through resistance first.
TipNotice the factor of 4 in the denominator comes from (2V)2=4V2. The factor P1+P2P1P2 is the "harmonic mean" structure that appears whenever you combine resistances in series and express the result in terms of powers.
✓Final answerThe correct option is (D) 4(P1+P2)P1P2.
-
- CBSE 2026Set 55/2/11 markMCQQ.Two statements are given – one labelled Assertion (A) and the other Reason (R). Select the correct answer from the codes below: (A) Both (A) and (R) are true and (R) is the correct explanation of (A). (B) Both (A) and (R) are true, but (R) is not the correct explanation of (A). (C) (A) is true, but (R) is false. (D) (A) is false and (R) is also false. Assertion (A) : Two electric heaters of power P1 and P2(>P1) are joined in series across a dc source of voltage V. The power consumed by the combination will be less than that consumed by P1 when connected across the same source. Reason (R) : The power consumed by an electric device when connected to a dc source of voltage V is proportional to its resistance.
›Reveal solutionSolution
The key idea is that in series, the combined resistance is larger than either heater's resistance, so the total power drawn from the source is smaller. The assertion is true; the reason is false because power is inversely proportional to resistance for a fixed voltage, not proportional.
Concept and intuition
When you connect a device to a fixed DC voltage source V, the power it consumes is given by P=V2/R. For a fixed voltage, power is inversely proportional to resistance — a higher resistance draws less current and therefore consumes less power. The reason statement gets this backwards.
Now, when two heaters are joined in series, their resistances add up. Since each heater's resistance is Ri=V2/Pi (from Pi=V2/Ri), the series combination has a total resistance Rseries=R1+R2, which is larger than either R1 or R2 alone. With a larger resistance, the power drawn from the same voltage source must be smaller than the power drawn by either individual heater. In particular, it will be less than P1 (the smaller power heater, which has the larger resistance). So the assertion is correct, but for a reason opposite to what is stated.
Step-by-step reasoning
- Express each heater's resistance in terms of its rated power. For a heater rated at power P when connected to voltage V, we have P=V2/R, so R=V2/P. Therefore:
R1=P1V2,R2=P2V2.
Since P2>P1, it follows that R2<R1 (higher power means lower resistance).
- Find the total resistance when they are in series.
Rseries=R1+R2=V2(P11+P21).
Clearly Rseries>R1 (and also >R2).
- Compute the power consumed by the series combination. Using P=V2/R again:
Pseries=RseriesV2=V2(P11+P21)V2=P11+P211=P1+P2P1P2.
- Compare Pseries with P1. Since P1>0, we have P1+P2>P2, so
Pseries=P1+P2P1P2<P2P1P2=P1.
Hence the series combination consumes less power than P1 alone. The assertion is true.
- Examine the reason statement. Reason (R) says: "The power consumed by an electric device when connected to a dc source of voltage V is proportional to its resistance." From P=V2/R, for fixed V, power is inversely proportional to resistance, not directly proportional. So (R) is false.
Watch outA common mistake is to think P=I2R and conclude power is proportional to resistance. But that formula applies when current is fixed, not voltage. Here the source provides a fixed voltage, so P=V2/R is the correct relation.
TipFor two devices in series across a fixed voltage, the total power is always less than the power of the smaller-rated device. This is a quick sanity check: series connections increase resistance, so they reduce power draw.
✓Final answerAssertion (A) is true, but Reason (R) is false. The correct option is (C).
- CBSE 2025Set ANNUAL1 markMCQQ.If R1 and R2 are respectively the filament resistance of a 200 W bulb and a 100 W bulb designed to operate on the same voltage, then –(a) R1 = 2R2(b) R2 = 2R1(c) R2 = 4R1(d) R1 = 4R2
›Reveal solutionSolution
Since power P=V2/R at fixed voltage, the lower-power bulb has the higher filament resistance.
Both bulbs operate at the same voltage V. Using P=RV2, so R=PV2.
For the 200 W bulb: R1=200V2
For the 100 W bulb: R2=100V2=2002V2=2R1
So the lower-wattage bulb has double the resistance of the higher-wattage bulb (since it draws less current at the same voltage).
✓Final answerR2=2R1 (option b).
- CBSE 2024Set ANNUAL1 markMCQQ.Energy dissipated in LCR circuit is in(a) L only(b) C only(c) R only(d) All of these
›Reveal solutionSolution
Over a full AC cycle, a pure inductor and a pure capacitor store and release energy with zero net dissipation; only the resistive element genuinely converts electrical energy to heat.
In an LCR series circuit driven by an AC source, the current and voltage across L and C are 90 degrees out of phase with each other, so the average power delivered to a pure inductor or a pure capacitor over one complete cycle is zero:
PL=PC=0(average, over one cycle)
Energy is stored in the magnetic field of L and the electric field of C during part of the cycle and returned to the source during the other part - no net energy is lost there. Only the resistor R, where voltage and current are in phase, dissipates energy irreversibly as Joule heating:
Pavg=Irms2R=VrmsIrmscosϕ
So the energy dissipated in an LCR circuit occurs entirely in R.
✓Final answer(c) R only.
- CBSE 2023Set 55/4/11 markMCQQ.Two statements are given — one labelled Assertion (A) and the other labelled Reason (R). Select the correct answer from the codes (A), (B), (C) and (D) as given below. (A) Both Assertion (A) and Reason (R) are true and Reason (R) is the correct explanation of the Assertion (A). (B) Both Assertion (A) and Reason (R) are true, but Reason (R) is not the correct explanation of the Assertion (A). (C) Assertion (A) is true, but Reason (R) is false. (D) Assertion (A) is false and Reason (R) is also false. Assertion (A) : When three electric bulbs of power 200 W, 100 W and 50 W are connected in series to a source, the power consumed by the 50 W bulb is maximum. Reason (R) : In a series circuit, current is the same through each bulb, but the potential difference across each bulb is different.
›Reveal solutionSolution
In a series circuit, the bulb with the lowest rated power has the highest resistance, and since power dissipated in series is P=I2R, the 50 W bulb consumes the most power. The reason correctly states that current is same but voltage differs, but it does not explain why the 50 W bulb gets maximum power — that requires linking resistance to rated power. So both statements are true, but Reason is not the correct explanation.
The Concept — Why This Works
The trap here is intuitive: we usually think a 200 W bulb is "more powerful." But that's when each bulb is connected individually to the same voltage (say 220 V). In that case, a higher wattage means it draws more current and glows brighter.
In series, the situation flips. The key idea:
- Each bulb is designed for a fixed voltage (the mains voltage). Its resistance is fixed by R=V2/Prated.
- A lower rated power means a higher resistance (since P is in the denominator).
- In series, current I is the same through all bulbs. Power dissipated in a bulb is Pactual=I2R.
- So the bulb with the largest resistance (the 50 W bulb) dissipates the most power in series.
That's the core physics. Now let's check the statements carefully.
Step-by-Step Verification
1. Find the resistances of the bulbs.
Assume each bulb is rated for the same voltage V (typically 220 V in household circuits, but the exact value doesn't matter — it cancels out).
Using P=V2/R, we get R=V2/P.
- For 200 W bulb: R200=V2/200
- For 100 W bulb: R100=V2/100
- For 50 W bulb: R50=V2/50
Clearly, R50>R100>R200.
2. Connect them in series to the same source voltage V.
Total resistance: Rtotal=R200+R100+R50.
Current in the circuit:
I=RtotalV
This current is the same through each bulb (series property).
3. Power consumed by each bulb in series.
For any bulb: Pactual=I2R.
Since I is common, the bulb with the largest R gets the largest Pactual.
That's the 50 W bulb. So Assertion (A) is true.
4. Check Reason (R).
Reason says: "In a series circuit, current is the same through each bulb, but the potential difference across each bulb is different."
This is a true statement about series circuits.
But does it explain why the 50 W bulb consumes maximum power? Not directly. The reason only states a general property of series circuits. The actual explanation requires the link between rated power and resistance, and then P=I2R. The reason doesn't mention resistance or the inverse relation between rated power and resistance. So Reason is true but not the correct explanation of the Assertion.
Watch outA common mistake is to think that the bulb with the highest rated power (200 W) will consume the most power in series. That's wrong because in series, power depends on resistance, not on the rated wattage directly. Always convert rated power to resistance first.
TipFor quick recall: In series, the bulb with the lowest wattage glows brightest. In parallel, the bulb with the highest wattage glows brightest. This is a favourite exam shortcut.
Conclusion
Both Assertion and Reason are individually true, but Reason does not provide the correct explanation for the Assertion.
✓Final answerThe correct option is (B) — Both Assertion (A) and Reason (R) are true, but Reason (R) is not the correct explanation of the Assertion (A).
- CBSE 2022Set ANNUAL1 markMCQQ.Of the two bulbs in a house, one glows brighter than the other. Which of the two has a larger resistance?(a) The brighter bulb(b) The dim bulb(c) Both have same resistance(d) The brightness does not depend upon the resistance
›Reveal solutionSolution
Both bulbs share the same house-supply voltage, so power (and hence brightness) is inversely proportional to resistance: P=V2/R.
In a house, bulbs are connected in parallel across the same mains voltage V. The electrical power dissipated (which determines brightness) is:
P=RV2
Since V is the same for both bulbs, P∝R1 — a bulb glows brighter when it dissipates more power, which happens when its resistance is lower.
So the brighter bulb has the smaller resistance, and the dimmer bulb has the larger resistance.
✓Final answerThe dim bulb has the larger resistance.
- CBSE 2020Set 55/1/11 markMCQQ.Two resistors R1 and R2 of 4 Ω and 6 Ω are connected in parallel across a battery. The ratio of power dissipated in them, P1:P2 will be (A) 4:9 (B) 3:2 (C) 9:4 (D) 2:3
›Reveal solutionSolution
In a parallel circuit, voltage is the same across both resistors, so power is inversely proportional to resistance. Since P=V2/R, the ratio P1:P2=R2:R1=6:4=3:2. The correct option is (B).
The key to this problem is understanding what stays constant when resistors are in parallel. Many students jump to using P=I2R without checking whether current is the same — that formula works only when the current through each resistor is identical, which is true in series but not in parallel.
In a parallel connection, the voltage across each resistor is the same (the battery voltage). That’s the anchor. So the natural formula to use is P=RV2, because V is common to both.
Let’s walk through it.
-
Identify the fixed quantity.
R1=4 Ω and R2=6 Ω are in parallel across the same battery. The voltage V across each is identical.
-
Choose the right power formula.
Power dissipated in a resistor is P=RV2. Since V is the same for both, the power is inversely proportional to resistance:
P1=R1V2,P2=R2V2
- Write the ratio.
P1:P2=R1V2:R2V2=R11:R21=R2:R1
- Substitute the values.
P1:P2=6:4=3:2
Watch outA common mistake is to use P=I2R and assume the same current flows through both resistors. In parallel, current splits — the smaller resistor draws more current. Using I2R without first finding the individual currents leads to the wrong ratio 4:6=2:3, which is option (D) — a tempting distractor.
TipFor any two resistors in parallel, the power ratio is simply the inverse of the resistance ratio. You don’t even need the voltage value. This shortcut saves time in exams.
✓Final answerThe ratio is 3:2, which corresponds to option (B).
-
- CBSE 2020Set 55/3/11 markMCQQ.The element of a heater is rated (P, V). If it is connected across a source of voltage 2V, then the power consumed by it will be (A) P (B) 2P (C) 2P (D) 4P
›Reveal solutionSolution
The power consumed by a resistor depends on the square of the applied voltage. Halving the voltage reduces the power to one-fourth of the original value, so the answer is 4P.
Concept and Intuition
This problem tests a fundamental relationship in electricity: how power changes when voltage changes, assuming the resistance stays constant. The heater element is essentially a resistor — its resistance is fixed by its material and construction. When the manufacturer rates it as (P,V), they mean: "If you connect this heater to a V volt supply, it will dissipate P watts of power."
The key insight is that resistance doesn't change when you change the voltage. So we first find the resistance from the rated values, then use that resistance to compute the new power at the reduced voltage.
Watch outA common mistake is to assume power is directly proportional to voltage. It's not — power depends on the square of voltage for a fixed resistor. Halving the voltage does NOT halve the power; it quarters it.
Step-by-Step Solution
- Write the power formula for a resistor. For a resistor of resistance R, the power dissipated when connected to a voltage V is:
P=RV2
This comes from combining Ohm's law V=IR with P=VI.
- Find the resistance from the rated values. The heater is rated (P,V), meaning at voltage V it consumes power P. So:
P=RV2⇒R=PV2
This resistance is a property of the heater element and does not change.
-
Now connect it to a source of voltage 2V.
The new voltage is V′=2V. The resistance is still R=PV2.
-
Calculate the new power P′.
Using the same formula:
P′=R(V′)2=PV2(2V)2
Simplify step by step:
P′=PV24V2=4V2×V2P=4P
TipYou can also think of it without calculating R explicitly. Since P∝V2 for a fixed resistor, if voltage becomes 21 times, power becomes (21)2=41 times. So P′=4P directly.
✓Final answerThe power consumed will be 4P, which corresponds to option (D).
🎓Unlock everything free for 14 days
- ✓Full step-by-step solutions
- ✓Concept-first explanations
- ✓Methods, shortcuts & mistakes
- ✓PYQ mapping + timed mock tests
Full access for 14 days. No credit card required.