How will you deal with the realisation expenses of the firm of Rashim and Bindiya in the following cases: (1)

Numerical Questions · Q6

Q. How will you deal with the realisation expenses of the firm of Rashim and Bindiya in the following cases:

(1) Realisation expenses amount to Rs. 1,00,000.

(2) Realisation expenses amounting to Rs. 30,000 are paid by Rashim, a partner.

(3) Realisation expenses are to be borne by Rashim and he will be paid Rs. 70,000 as remuneration for completing the dissolution process. The actual expenses incurred by Rashim were Rs. 1,20,000.

Goa GbshseTextbookSubjective· 3mImportance★★★★★

78% · 54/69 Questions

🔒 Locked · start free trial →

You're viewing a preview — the full solution, concept, methods & PYQ mapping are locked.

Start your 14-day free trial to unlock the full solution →

Concept understanding — Realisation Expenses Accounting

Realisation Expenses Accounting — A First Look

Think of a partnership firm that has decided to close down. The partners have agreed to sell off everything — land, machinery, stock, debtors — and pay off all liabilities. But selling assets and settling debts costs money: you pay a broker to auction the machinery, a lawyer to draft the sale deed, a transporter to move the stock, and maybe a commission to the person who collects the dues. These out-of-pocket costs incurred only because the firm is being wound up are called realisation expenses.

In everyday life, if you and a friend decide to sell your shared bicycle and split the money, you might spend ₹50 on an advertisement. That ₹50 is a realisation expense — it is not a regular business cost; it is a cost of closing down.

What the NCERT Textbook Says

The NCERT Class-12 Accountancy textbook (Part II, Chapter 5: Dissolution of a Partnership Firm) defines realisation expenses as:

"Expenses incurred on the dissolution of a firm, such as expenses on the sale of assets, payment of liabilities, legal charges, etc."

The key point: these expenses arise only after the decision to dissolve and are directly linked to converting assets into cash and clearing debts. They are not part of normal trading or operating expenses.

Why It Matters

If you ignore realisation expenses, the final amount available for distribution among partners will be overstated. Partners would think they have more money to share than they actually do. The accounting treatment ensures that:

The Realisation Account (which summarises all gains and losses on sale of assets and settlement of liabilities) is charged with these expenses.
The net profit or loss on realisation is correctly computed.
Partners' capital accounts are adjusted only for the true final figure.

Accounting Treatment — The Core Rule

Important

Realisation expenses are always debited to the Realisation Account.

The journal entry is:

Realisation A/c          Dr.   [Amount]
     To Bank A/c (or Cash A/c)   [Amount]
(Being realisation expenses paid)

Why debit Realisation Account?

The Realisation Account is a temporary account that collects all gains and losses from dissolution. Paying an expense reduces the net gain (or increases the net loss) from realisation. So it is debited — just like any expense is debited to a profit-and-loss account.

Why credit Bank/Cash?

Because the firm pays cash out of its bank balance or cash in hand.

What If a Partner Bears the Expenses?

Sometimes the partnership deed says that a particular partner will personally pay the realisation expenses (or the firm pays, but the partner is entitled to a fixed fee for doing the work). Two common variations:

Partner pays from his own pocket

The firm does not record any entry. The partner simply bears the cost. No accounting treatment needed in the firm's books.
Partner is paid a fixed amount for handling dissolution

Example: Partner A is to be paid ₹5,000 for his services in winding up. This is treated as a realisation expense. Entry:
```
Realisation A/c          Dr.   5,000
     To Bank A/c                 5,000
```
(If the amount is to be credited to the partner's capital account instead of paying cash, credit the partner's capital account.)

The Format / Proforma — Where Does It Appear?

In the NCERT textbook, the Realisation Account is prepared in a T‑shape (two-sided account). Realisation expenses appear on the debit side of this account. Here is the standard format:

Realisation Account

Dr.			Cr.
Particulars	Amount (₹)	Particulars	Amount (₹)
To Sundry Assets (transferred)	xxx	By Sundry Liabilities (transferred)	xxx
To Bank (liabilities paid)	xxx	By Bank (assets sold)	xxx
To Bank (realisation expenses)	xxx	By Loss transferred to Partners' Capital A/c (if loss)	xxx
To Profit transferred to Partners' Capital A/c (if profit)	xxx
Total	xxxx	Total	xxxx

Start your 14-day free trial to unlock the full solution →

Realisation Expenses — Rashim & Bindiya

Case 1: Expenses paid by the firm (₹1,00,000)

The firm pays the expenses directly. The journal entry is:

Particulars	Debit (₹)	Credit (₹)
Realisation A/c Dr.	1,00,000
To Bank A/c		1,00,000
(Being realisation expenses paid)

The amount is debited to the Realisation Account, reducing the net gain (or increasing the loss) to be shared by partners in their profit-sharing ratio.

Case 2: Expenses paid by partner Rashim (₹30,000)

When a partner pays realisation expenses on behalf of the firm, the firm reimburses the partner. The entry:

Particulars	Debit (₹)	Credit (₹)
Realisation A/c Dr.	30,000
To Rashim's Capital A/c		30,000
(Being realisation expenses paid by Rashim, credited to his capital)

Rashim's capital account is credited (not Bank), because the firm owes him the amount. When the final payment is made, his capital account is settled.

Case 3: Expenses borne by Rashim with fixed remuneration (₹70,000); actual expenses ₹1,20,000

Here, the agreement is that Rashim bears all realisation expenses himself, and in return receives ₹70,000 as remuneration. Since actual expenses (₹1,20,000) exceed the fixed remuneration, Rashim bears the extra ₹50,000 personally.

Journal entries:

Particulars	Debit (₹)	Credit (₹)
Realisation A/c Dr.	70,000
To Rashim's Capital A/c		70,000
(Being remuneration payable to Rashim for dissolution)

Start your 14-day free trial to unlock the full solution →

Realisation expenses are always debited to the Realisation Account (as a charge against the firm's assets) and credited to the Bank Account (or the partner's capital account if paid by the partner). The treatment varies only in who bears the cost and whether a partner receives remuneration.

Concept and Accounting Treatment

Realisation expenses are the costs incurred to sell off assets and settle liabilities during the dissolution of a partnership firm. The fundamental rule is: all expenses relating to realisation are debited to the Realisation Account because they reduce the net proceeds available for distribution among partners. The credit side depends on who pays:

If the firm pays directly → Credit Bank Account.
If a partner pays out of their own pocket → Credit that Partner's Capital Account (the firm owes the partner).
If a partner bears the expenses (as per agreement) → The partner's capital account is debited (they bear the loss), and the Realisation Account is credited (no cash outflow from the firm). Any remuneration paid to the partner for completing dissolution is also debited to Realisation Account and credited to the partner's capital account.

The key distinction: expenses are a charge against realisation proceeds, while remuneration is an additional cost for the partner's services. Both reduce the amount available for partners, but remuneration is specifically agreed upon.

Solution: Journal Entries for Each Case

Case 1: Realisation expenses amount to ₹1,00,000 (paid by the firm)

Particulars	Debit (₹)	Credit (₹)
Realisation A/c Dr.	1,00,000
To Bank A/c		1,00,000
(Being realisation expenses paid)

Explanation: The firm pays directly, so Bank is credited. Realisation A/c is debited as the expense reduces the net assets.

Case 2: Realisation expenses amounting to ₹30,000 are paid by Rashim, a partner

Particulars	Debit (₹)	Credit (₹)
Realisation A/c Dr.	30,000
To Rashim's Capital A/c		30,000
(Being realisation expenses paid by partner Rashim)

Explanation: Rashim pays from his personal funds, so the firm owes him ₹30,000. This increases his capital account (credit). Realisation A/c is debited as usual.

Case 3: Realisation expenses to be borne by Rashim; he receives ₹70,000 as remuneration; actual expenses incurred by Rashim are ₹1,20,000

This case has two components:

Expenses borne by Rashim (₹1,20,000) – The firm does not pay; Rashim bears the cost.
Remuneration to Rashim (₹70,000) – The firm pays Rashim for his services.

Journal Entries:

Particulars	Debit (₹)	Credit (₹)
Realisation A/c Dr.	70,000
To Rashim's Capital A/c		70,000
(Being remuneration payable to Rashim for completing dissolution)
Rashim's Capital A/c Dr.	1,20,000
To Realisation A/c		1,20,000
(Being realisation expenses of ₹1,20,000 borne by Rashim)

Explanation:

The remuneration (₹70,000) is an expense of realisation, so Realisation A/c is debited and Rashim's Capital credited (he is to be paid).
The actual expenses (₹1,20,000) are borne by Rashim personally. This means the firm does not pay them; instead, Rashim's capital account is reduced (debited) because he bears the loss. Realisation A/c is credited because the firm's liability for these expenses is extinguished.

Net effect on Rashim's Capital Account:

Credit: ₹70,000 (remuneration)

Debit: ₹1,20,000 (expenses borne)

Net debit: ₹50,000 (Rashim's capital decreases by ₹50,000 overall)

Working Notes …

Start your 14-day free trial to unlock the full solution →

←Previous question · questions-for-practiceQ5 — Give journal entries for the following transactions: (1) To record the…→Next question · questions-for-practiceQ7 — The book value of assets (other than cash and bank) transferred to Rea…

Q.How will you deal with the realisation expenses of the firm of Rashim and Bindiya in the following cases:

Concept and Accounting Treatment

Solution: Journal Entries for Each Case

Case 1: Realisation expenses amount to ₹1,00,000 (paid by the firm)

Case 2: Realisation expenses amounting to ₹30,000 are paid by Rashim, a partner

Case 3: Realisation expenses to be borne by Rashim; he receives ₹70,000 as remuneration; actual expenses incurred by Rashim are ₹1,20,000

Working Notes …

🎓Unlock everything free for 14 days

Unlock everything free for 14 days