Q.Suppose we have four boxes A,B,C and D containing coloured marbles as given below: BoxABCDMarble colourRed1680White6216Black3214 One of the boxes has been selected at random and a single marble is drawn from it. If the marble is red, what is the probability that it was drawn from box A?, box B?, box C?
🔒You're viewing a preview — the full solution, concept, methods & PYQ mapping are locked.
🔒 Start your 14-day free trial to unlock the full solution →Concept understanding — Conditional Probability
Conditional Probability
Roll a die and ask "what is the chance of an even number?" — that is 3/6. But suppose someone tells you the result is greater than 3. Now you are no longer looking at all six faces, only at {4,5,6}, and two of those (4 and 6) are even, so the probability becomes 2/3. That change — from the probability of A to the probability of A given that B has already occurred — is conditional probability.
The Idea: Shrink the Sample Space
Conditioning on B throws away every outcome where B is false and treats B as the new "whole world." You measure A only against what is still possible.
Think of filtering a table of data: unconditional probability uses every row; conditional probability keeps only the rows where the condition is true.
The Definition
For events A and B with P(B)>0,
P(A∣B)=P(B)P(A∩B).
We divide by P(B) to rescale so that B itself has probability 1; the surviving part of A is the overlap A∩B. Checking the die: P(A∩B)=P({4,6})=62 and P(B)=63, so P(A∣B)=3/62/6=32, matching the intuition.
Rearranging gives the multiplication rule P(A∩B)=P(A∣B)P(B), which is usually the easier way to compute a joint probability when a problem says "given that."
Two Cautions
- P(A∣B) and P(B∣A) are generally not equal; swapping them is the classic mistake. They are linked by Bayes' theorem, P(A∣B)=P(B)P(B∣A)P(A). …
Concept: Conditional Probability — we need P(Box∣Red), found using Bayes' theorem.
Step 1: Prior probabilities. Each box is equally likely:
P(A)=P(B)=P(C)=P(D)=41.
Step 2: Likelihoods (probability of drawing a red marble from each box).
Total marbles per box: A has 1+6+3=10, B has 6+2+2=10, C has 8+1+1=10, D has 0+6+4=10.
P(Red∣A)=101,P(Red∣B)=106,P(Red∣C)=108,P(Red∣D)=0.
Step 3: Total probability of drawing a red marble.
P(Red)=41(101+106+108+0)=41⋅1015=4015=83.
Step 4: Apply Bayes' theorem.
P(A∣Red)=P(Red)P(Red∣A)P(A)=83101⋅41=3/81/40=401⋅38=1208=151. …
We use Bayes’ theorem to reverse the conditional probability: given that the drawn marble is red, we find the probability it came from each box. The answer for box A is 151, for box B is 52, and for box C is 158.
The problem gives us four boxes with different compositions of red, white, and black marbles. One box is chosen at random, then one marble is drawn from it. We are told the marble is red, and we need the probability that it came from each specific box.
This is a classic case of inverse probability — we know the probability of drawing a red marble given a particular box, but we want the probability of that box given that the marble is red. The tool for this is Bayes’ theorem, which is built on conditional probability.
Why Bayes’ theorem works here:
We start with the prior probability of each box being chosen (all equal, since selection is random). Then we update that probability using the likelihood of observing a red marble from that box. The denominator normalises by the total probability of getting a red marble from any box.
Let’s go step by step.
1. Define the events and priors
Let R be the event that the drawn marble is red.
Let A, B, C, D be the events that the chosen box is A, B, C, D respectively.
Since one box is selected at random from four, each has equal prior probability:
P(A)=P(B)=P(C)=P(D)=41.
2. Find the probability of drawing a red marble from each box
From the table:
- Box A: 1 red out of 1+6+3=10 marbles → P(R∣A)=101
- Box B: 6 red out of 6+2+2=10 marbles → P(R∣B)=106=53
- Box C: 8 red out of 8+1+1=10 marbles → P(R∣C)=108=54
- Box D: 0 red out of 0+6+4=10 marbles → P(R∣D)=0
A common mistake is to forget that Box D has no red marbles at all. Since P(R∣D)=0, it contributes nothing to the numerator in Bayes’ theorem — so the posterior probability for Box D is automatically zero. Many students waste time calculating it, but it’s immediate.
3. Compute the total probability of drawing a red marble
Using the law of total probability:
P(R)=P(A)P(R∣A)+P(B)P(R∣B)+P(C)P(R∣C)+P(D)P(R∣D)
Substitute:
P(R)=41⋅101+41⋅53+41⋅54+41⋅0
Convert to a common denominator (20 works nicely):
- 41⋅101=401
- 41⋅53=203=406
- 41⋅54=204=408
So:
P(R)=401+406+408=4015=83
4. Apply Bayes’ theorem for each box
Bayes’ theorem says:
P(Box∣R)=P(R)P(Box)⋅P(R∣Box) …
Method: Bayes' Theorem across several boxes (watch the empty branch)
Use this when one of several containers is chosen at random, an item is drawn, and you must find the posterior probability for each container.
Steps
Step 1: Assign equal priors to the containers.
P(Hi)=n1 when the box is chosen at random.
Step 2: Compute each container's likelihood of the observed colour.
P(E∣Hi)=total items in box ifavourable items in box i. A box with none of the drawn colour has likelihood 0 — dismiss it immediately, its posterior is 0.
Step 3: Total probability of the evidence. …
Common Mistakes
Mistake 1: Spending effort on Box D instead of seeing P(R∣D)=0.
Why it's wrong: Box D has no red marbles, so its posterior is immediately 0. Correct approach: drop D from the numerator work once you note zero red.
Mistake 2: Forgetting to normalise by P(R).
Why it's wrong: the joint probabilities P(box∩R) are not the posteriors until divided by the total P(R)=83. Correct approach: divide each box's joint by 83.
Mistake 3: Misreading a box's red count or total. …
Showing the 12 most recent of 45 on this concept.
- COMEDK 2025Set 2025-A1 markMCQQ.Three bags contain a number of red and white balls are as follows. Bag I: 3 red balls Bag II: 2 red balls and 1 white ball Bag III: 3 White balls The probability that bag i will be chosen and a ball is selected from it is 6i,i=1,2,3. If a white ball is selected, what is the probablity that it came from Bag III (A) 119 (B) 112 (C) 0 (D) 111
›Reveal solutionSolution
This is a classic Bayes’ theorem problem: we are given prior probabilities for choosing each bag and the conditional probabilities of drawing a white ball from each bag; after observing a white ball, we want the posterior probability that it came from Bag III. The answer is 119.
We start by noting that the problem gives us three bags with different compositions, and a rule for choosing a bag: the probability of picking bag i is 6i. Then, from that bag, we pick a ball uniformly at random. We are told that a white ball was selected, and we need the probability that it came from Bag III. This is a textbook case for Bayes’ theorem, which lets us “reverse” conditional probabilities: we know P(white∣bag i), and we want P(bag i∣white).
Let’s work through it step by step.
- Define events and write down given probabilities. Let Bi be the event that bag i is chosen (i=1,2,3). We are told:
P(B1)=61,P(B2)=62,P(B3)=63.
Let W be the event that a white ball is drawn.
From the bag compositions:
- Bag I: 3 red, 0 white → P(W∣B1)=0.
- Bag II: 2 red, 1 white → P(W∣B2)=31.
- Bag III: 0 red, 3 white → P(W∣B3)=1.
- Compute the total probability of drawing a white ball. By the law of total probability:
P(W)=P(B1)P(W∣B1)+P(B2)P(W∣B2)+P(B3)P(W∣B3).
Substitute:
P(W)=61⋅0+62⋅31+63⋅1=0+182+63=91+21.
Get a common denominator (18):
P(W)=182+189=1811.
- Apply Bayes’ theorem to find P(B3∣W). Bayes’ theorem says:
P(B3∣W)=P(W)P(B3)P(W∣B3).
Plug in the numbers:
- COMEDK 2024Set 2024-E1 markMCQQ.Suppose we have three cards identical in form except that both sides of the first card are coloured red, both sides of the second are coloured black, and one side of the third card is coloured red and the other side is coloured black. The three cards are mixed and a card is picked randomly. If the upper side of the chosen card is coloured red, what is the probability that the other side is coloured black. (A) 61 (B) 21 (C) 0 (D) 31
›Reveal solutionSolution
This is a classic conditional probability problem (often called the "three cards" or "Bertrand's box" variant). The key is that seeing a red side updates the probability space to only the red sides, and among those, only one belongs to the mixed card. The answer is 1/3.
We are asked: given that the visible side is red, what is the probability that the other side is black? This is not simply "one of the two remaining cards has a black other side" because the cards are not equally likely once we condition on the observation.
Concept and Intuition
The pitfall is to think: "We see red, so the card is either the all-red or the mixed card. That's two possibilities, so the chance is 1/2." But this ignores that the all-red card has two red sides, while the mixed card has only one red side. When we pick a card at random and then look at a random side, each of the six sides is equally likely to be the one we see. Seeing red eliminates the three black sides, leaving only the three red sides. Among those three red sides, two belong to the all-red card and only one belongs to the mixed card. So the probability that the other side is black is 1/3.
Step-by-step reasoning
-
Label the sides.
Let the cards be:
- Card A: both sides red (sides R1,R2)
- Card B: both sides black (sides B1,B2)
- Card C: one red, one black (sides R3,B3)
-
Count equally likely outcomes.
When we pick a card uniformly at random and then look at a random side, there are 3×2=6 equally likely side-views. Each of the six sides has probability 1/6 of being the one we see.
-
Condition on seeing a red side.
The red sides are: R1,R2 (from card A) and R3 (from card C). That's 3 red sides. So the conditional space has 3 equally likely possibilities. …
-
- COMEDK 2026Set 2026-M1 markMCQQ.Advika chooses one of three scarves every morning: Red, Blue, or Green. The probability she chooses Red is 20%. The probability she chooses Blue is twice the probability of choosing Red. On the remaining days she wears a Green scarf. Once a scarf is chosen, she decides whether to wear a Hat (H) and Sunglasses (S). These choices are independent of each other but depend on the scarf colour: Scarf colour Red Blue Green P(H)0.50.40.1P(S)0.80.50.5 Advika is spotted outdoors wearing both a Hat and Sunglasses. What is the probability that she is wearing the Red scarf? (A) 31313 (B) 218 (C) 94 (D) 138
›Reveal solutionSolution
Bayes' theorem on scarf colour given that both a hat and sunglasses are worn. Priors P(R)=0.2, P(B)=0.4, P(G)=0.4; likelihoods P(H∩S∣colour)=P(H)P(S). The posterior P(R∣H∩S)=94 — option (C).
Concept. Hat and sunglasses are independent given the scarf, so P(H∩S∣colour)=P(H∣colour)⋅P(S∣colour). Bayes' theorem then reverses the conditioning to give the probability of the scarf colour from the observed accessories.
Step 1 — Priors.
P(R)=20%=0.2,P(B)=2P(R)=0.4,P(G)=1−0.2−0.4=0.4.
Step 2 — Likelihood of wearing both accessories for each colour.
P(H∩S∣R)=0.5×0.8=0.40,
P(H∩S∣B)=0.4×0.5=0.20,
P(H∩S∣G)=0.1×0.5=0.05. …
- COMEDK 2026Set 2026-A1 markMCQQ.Vishnu has two jars of marbles, Jar A and Jar B. Jar A contains 3 yellow marbles and 2 green marbles. Jar B contains 4 yellow marbles and 3 green marbles. Vishnu flips a fair coin. If it lands heads, he picks two marbles at random without replacement from Jar A. If it lands tails, he picks two marbles at random with replacement from Jar B. Given that Vishnu picked one yellow and one green marble, what is the probability that they came from Jar B? (A) 4121 (B) 8949 (C) 8940 (D) 4120
›Reveal solutionSolution
P(E∣A)=53 (without replacement), P(E∣B)=4924 (with replacement); Bayes gives P(B∣E)=8940 — option (C).
Likelihoods of drawing one yellow and one green (E).
Jar A (3 yellow, 2 green; two draws without replacement):
P(E∣A)=(25)(13)(12)=106=53.
Jar B (4 yellow, 3 green; two draws with replacement):
P(E∣B)=2⋅74⋅73=4924.
Bayes' theorem with P(A)=P(B)=21 (the 21 cancels): …
- COMEDK 2023Set 2023-E1 markMCQQ.Bag A contains 3 white and 2 red balls. Bag B contains only 1 white ball. A fair coin is tossed. If head appears then 1 ball is drawn at random from bag A and put into bag B. However if tail appears then 2 balls are drawn at random from bag A and put into bag B. Now one ball is drawn at random from bag B. Given that the drawn ball from B is white, the probability that head appeared on the coin is (A) 3023 (B) 2312 (C) 2311 (D) 3019
›Reveal solutionSolution
Computing P(white drawn∣H)=54 and P(white∣T)=1511, Bayes' theorem gives P(H∣white)=2312.
Head (transfer 1 ball from A(3W,2R) to B(1W), then draw from B's 2 balls):
P(white)=53(1)+52(21)=53+51=54.
Tail (transfer 2 balls from A to B(1W), then draw from B's 3 balls):
P(WW)=103⇒P(white)=1,P(WR)=106⇒32,P(RR)=101⇒31. …
- COMEDK 2021Set 2021-B1 markMCQQ.An urn contains 5 red and 5 black coloured balls. A ball is picked at random, its colour noted and then is put back into the urn. Now, additional two balls of the same colour are put into the urn and then a ball is drawn at random. What is the probability that the ball now chosen is red. (A) 7/24 (B) 1/2 (C) 5/8 (D) 2/3
›Reveal solutionSolution
By symmetry the second-draw red probability averages to 21.
Start: 5 red, 5 black (10 total). First ball is drawn, replaced, then 2 more of the same colour are added, so the urn always has 12 balls before the second draw.
- First ball red (P=105=21): urn now 7R, 5B ⇒ P(red)=127. …
- COMEDK 2025Set 2025-E1 markMCQQ.A pot contains 5 red and 2 green balls. A ball is drawn at random from this pot. If a drawn ball is green, then a red ball is added to the pot. If a drawn ball is red, then a green ball is added to the pot, while the original ball drawn is not replaced in the pot. Now a second ball is drawn at random from the pot, what is the probability that the second ball drawn is a red ball? (A) 4912 (B) 4932 (C) 73 (D) 4927
›Reveal solutionSolution
Condition on the first draw: P(2nd red)=72⋅76+75⋅74=4932.
Start: 5 red, 2 green, total 7. The first ball is not replaced, and a ball of the other colour is added.
Case 1 — first ball is green. P=72.
Remove that green (5R,1G), then add a red ⇒6R,1G (total 7).
P(2nd red∣green first)=76
Case 2 — first ball is red. P=75.
Remove that red (4R,2G), then add a green ⇒4R,3G (total 7). …
- COMEDK 2024Set 2024-M1 markMCQQ.An urn contains 2 white and 2 black balls. A ball is drawn at random. If it is white it is not replaced into the urn. Otherwise it is replaced along with another ball of the same colour. The process is repeated. The probability that the third ball drawn is black is (A) 3017 (B) 6037 (C) 6031 (D) 3023
›Reveal solutionSolution
Conditioning on the first two draws (white -> not replaced; black -> replaced plus one extra black) and using total probability gives P(3rd black)=3023 — option (D).
Rules. Start with 2 white, 2 black (total 4). Drawing white removes it (whites −1, total −1). Drawing black puts it back and adds one more black (blacks +1, total +1).
First two draws and the composition just before the 3rd draw
- WW: 42⋅31=61; urn becomes W0, B2 (total 2) ⇒P(black)=1.
- WB: 42⋅32=31; urn becomes W1, B3 (total 4) ⇒P(black)=43.
- BW: 42⋅52=51; urn becomes W1, B3 (total 4) ⇒P(black)=43.
- BB: 42⋅53=103; urn becomes W2, B4 (total 6) ⇒P(black)=32. …
- COMEDK 2026Set 2026-M1 markMCQQ.A teacher has two jars of candy on her desk: Jar 1: Contains 3 Strawberry candies and 2 Orange candies. Jar 2: Contains 1 Strawberry candy and 4 Orange candies. The teacher randomly picks two candies from Jar 1 and drops them into Jar 2. Then, a student reaches into Jar 2 and picks two candies. What is the probability that the student picks two Strawberry candies? (A) 356 (B) 214 (C) 703 (D) 141
›Reveal solutionSolution
Condition on how many strawberries move from Jar 1 to Jar 2, then compute the chance of drawing two strawberries from the now 7-candy Jar 2. Total =141.
Setup. Jar 1 has 3 Strawberry (S) and 2 Orange (O). Two candies are moved into Jar 2, which started with 1 S and 4 O. After the transfer Jar 2 holds 7 candies. Let k = number of strawberries transferred.
Transfer probabilities (choosing 2 of 5 from Jar 1, (25)=10):
P(k=2)=10(23)=103,P(k=1)=10(13)(12)=106,P(k=0)=10(22)=101.
Draw two S from Jar 2 (which now has 1+k strawberries out of 7, (27)=21):
- k=2: Jar 2 has 3 S ⇒21(23)=213=71. …
- KCET 2021Set A-11 markMCQQ.A car manufacturing factory has two plants X and Y. Plant X manufactures 70% of cars and plant Y manufactures 30% of cars. 80% of cars at plant X and 90% of cars at plant Y are rated as standard quality. A car is chosen at random and is found to be of standard quality. The probability that it has come from plant X is (A) 7356 (B) 8456 (C) 8356 (D) 7956
›Reveal solutionSolution
This is a reverse-probability question (effect → cause), so use Bayes' theorem with the total probability of a standard-quality car in the denominator.
Step 1 — Define the events.
- X: the car came from plant X — P(X)=0.70
- Y: the car came from plant Y — P(Y)=0.30
- S: the car is of standard quality
The conditional (likelihood) data given:
P(S∣X)=0.80,P(S∣Y)=0.90
Note X and Y are mutually exclusive and exhaustive (0.7+0.3=1), which is exactly what Bayes' theorem needs.
Step 2 — Why Bayes and not simple conditioning.
We are told the effect (the chosen car is standard) and asked for the probability of the cause (it came from X). That inversion — P(X∣S) from P(S∣X) — is precisely Bayes' theorem:
P(X∣S)=P(X)P(S∣X)+P(Y)P(S∣Y)P(X)P(S∣X)
Step 3 — Compute the numerator.
P(X)P(S∣X)=0.70×0.80=0.56
Step 4 — Compute the denominator (total probability of a standard car).
P(S)=0.70×0.80+0.30×0.90=0.56+0.27=0.83
Step 5 — Divide. …
- COMEDK 2024Set 2024-A1 markMCQQ.P and Q are considering to apply for a job. The probability that P applies for the job is 41. The probability that P applies for the job given that Q applies for the job is 21, and the probability that Q applies for the job given that P applies for the job is 31. Then the probability that P does not apply for the job given that Q does not apply for the job is (A) 54 (B) 87 (C) 65 (D) 1211
›Reveal solutionSolution
We are given conditional probabilities and need to find P(P∣Q). Using the definitions of conditional probability and the law of total probability, we compute P(Q) and P(Q), then apply Bayes' theorem to get 54, which corresponds to option (A).
Concept and intuition:
This is a classic problem of working backwards from conditional probabilities to find a joint probability table. We know P(P), P(P∣Q), and P(Q∣P). From these, we can find P(P∩Q) in two ways, which lets us solve for P(Q). Then we can compute the desired conditional probability P(P∣Q) using the complement rule and the definition of conditional probability.
Step-by-step solution:
- Write down what is given. Let P = event that P applies, Q = event that Q applies. We have:
P(P)=41,P(P∣Q)=21,P(Q∣P)=31.
- Use the definition of conditional probability to express P(P∩Q) in two ways. From P(P∣Q)=P(Q)P(P∩Q), we get
P(P∩Q)=P(P∣Q)⋅P(Q)=21P(Q).
From P(Q∣P)=P(P)P(P∩Q), we get
P(P∩Q)=P(Q∣P)⋅P(P)=31⋅41=121.
- Equate the two expressions for P(P∩Q) to find P(Q).
21P(Q)=121⇒P(Q)=61.
- Find P(Q) and P(P∩Q).
P(Q)=1−P(Q)=1−61=65.
Also, P(P∩Q)=P(P)−P(P∩Q)=41−121=123−121=122=61.
- Find P(P∩Q). Since P∩Q is the complement of P∪Q, we can use:
P(P∩Q)=1−P(P∪Q).
First, P(P∪Q)=P(P)+P(Q)−P(P∩Q)=41+61−121. …
- KCET 2025Set A-11 markMCQQ.Meera visits only one of the two temples A and B in her locality. Probability that she visits temple A is 52. If she visits temple A, 31 is the probability that she meets her friend, whereas it is 72 if she visits temple B. Meera met her friend at one of the two temples. The probability that she met her at temple B is (A) 167 (B) 165 (C) 163 (D) 169
›Reveal solutionSolution
The friend has already been met (the effect); we want the probability of the cause (temple B) — that reversal of conditioning is exactly Bayes' theorem.
Step 1 — Name the events.
Let A = "Meera visits temple A", B = "Meera visits temple B", F = "she meets her friend".
She visits only one of the two temples, so A and B are mutually exclusive and exhaustive:
P(A)=52⟹P(B)=1−52=53.
Given: P(F∣A)=31, P(F∣B)=72.
Step 2 — Why Bayes.
We are told the outcome (F happened) and asked for the probability of a cause (B). Bayes' theorem inverts the conditioning:
P(B∣F)=P(A)P(F∣A)+P(B)P(F∣B)P(B)P(F∣B).
The denominator is P(F) by the law of total probability — the friend can be met on either branch.
Step 3 — Compute the two branch probabilities.
P(A∩F)=52×31=152,P(B∩F)=53×72=356.
Step 4 — Total probability of meeting the friend. …
🎓Unlock everything free for 14 days
- ✓Full step-by-step solutions
- ✓Concept-first explanations
- ✓Methods, shortcuts & mistakes
- ✓PYQ mapping + timed mock tests
Full access for 14 days. No credit card required.