Q.Electronic configuration of a transition element X in +3 oxidation state is [Ar]3d5. What is its atomic number?
Concept understanding — Ionization Energy Trends
Ionization Energy: The First Meeting
Imagine you're holding onto something precious — say, a favourite pen. How hard would someone have to pull to take it from your hand? That's the core idea behind ionization energy. In an atom, the "something precious" is an electron, and the "pulling force" is energy.
Ionization energy (IE) is the minimum energy required to remove the most loosely bound electron from a gaseous atom in its ground state.
Why "gaseous" and "ground state"? Because we want a fair comparison — no extra energy from neighbours or from the atom being already excited. We measure how tightly the atom holds its outermost electron when it's alone and calm.
The unit you'll see most often in exams: kJ/mol (kilojoules per mole of atoms).
The Intuition: What Controls the Grip?
Two factors decide how hard an atom holds its outermost electron:
-
Nuclear charge — more protons in the nucleus means a stronger pull on the electron. Simple: bigger positive charge, tighter grip.
-
Distance from the nucleus — the farther the electron is, the weaker the pull. Think of a magnet: it holds a paperclip strongly up close, but barely at arm's length.
But there's a subtle twist: shielding (or screening). Inner electrons partially block the nuclear charge from reaching the outer electron. The outermost electron doesn't "feel" the full nuclear charge — it feels only the effective nuclear charge (Zeff).
Zeff=Z−S, where Z is the atomic number and S is the shielding constant (roughly the number of inner electrons). This is the net positive charge pulling on the outer electron.
So the real question becomes: How large is Zeff for the outermost electron, and how far away is it?
The Precise Trend: Across a Period
As you move left to right across a period (say, from Li to Ne in period 2):
- Nuclear charge increases steadily (more protons).
- Electrons are added to the same shell — no new inner layers.
- Shielding stays roughly constant (same number of inner electrons).
- Result: Zeff increases → the outer electron is pulled in tighter → ionization energy increases.
Across a period: IE increases (generally).
Example:
Li (IE = 520 kJ/mol) → Be (900) → B (801) → C (1086) → N (1402) → O (1314) → F (1681) → Ne (2081)
Wait — why does B have lower IE than Be? And O lower than N? That's the exception, not the rule. We'll come back to it.
The Precise Trend: Down a Group
As you move down a group (say, from Li to Cs in group 1):
- Nuclear charge increases (more protons).
- But electrons are added to new, higher shells — the outermost electron is much farther from the nucleus.
- Shielding also increases significantly (more inner electrons).
- Result: distance dominates → the outer electron is held more loosely → ionization energy decreases.
Down a group: IE decreases.
Example:
Li (520) → Na (496) → K (419) → Rb (403) → Cs (376) — all in kJ/mol.
The Two Exceptions (and Why They Matter)
Exception 1: Group 13 vs Group 2 (e.g., B vs Be)
Be has a full 2s2 subshell. B has 2s22p1. The 2p electron is slightly higher in energy and slightly better shielded by the 2s electrons than the 2s electrons shield each other. So removing the 2p electron from B takes less energy than removing a 2s electron from Be.
Don't memorise "IE increases across a period" blindly. Group 13 always has lower IE than Group 2 in the same period.
Exception 2: Group 16 vs Group 15 (e.g., O vs N)
N has a half-filled 2p3 subshell — each 2p orbital has one electron. This is an especially stable arrangement (exchange energy stabilisation). O has 2p4 — one orbital gets a second electron. That extra electron experiences electron-electron repulsion, making it easier to remove. So O has lower IE than N.
| Period | Group 15 (IE) | Group 16 (IE) | Which is higher? |
|--------|--------------|--------------|------------------|
| 2 | N (1402) | O (1314) | N > O |
| 3 | P (1012) | S (1000) | P > S |
| 4 | As (947) | Se (941) | As > Se |
The pattern holds for all periods.
The Big Picture: What You Must Remember
Ionization energy increases across a period (with two dips) and decreases down a group.
The dips occur at Group 13 (lower than Group 2) and Group 16 (lower than Group 15).
The underlying reason is always the same: effective nuclear charge and distance. When Zeff is high and the electron is close, IE is high. When the electron is far or repulsion helps it leave, IE is low.
A Final Check: First vs Second Ionization Energy
Removing one electron from an atom leaves a positive ion. Removing a second electron from that ion is always harder — the ion has a higher positive charge pulling on the remaining electrons.
Second IE > First IE — always. For example, Na: first IE = 496 kJ/mol, second IE = 4562 kJ/mol. That's nearly 10 times larger. This huge jump tells you that the second electron comes from a different shell (closer to the nucleus).
In exams, this jump is used to identify the group of an element — a sudden large increase in successive ionization energies indicates you've stripped off all valence electrons and are now pulling from a core shell.
"Ionization energy trends periodic table" and "periodicity class 11 chemistry important questions" are extremely common searches, both anchored in the Classification of Elements and Periodicity chapter of the NCERT/CBSE Class 11 Chemistry curriculum. The Group 13 and Group 16 exceptions in particular are a favourite trap question in board exams and JEE Main.
Why this formula?
Ionization Energy Trends: The Why Behind the Trends
Ionization energy (IE) is the minimum energy required to remove the most loosely bound electron from a gaseous atom in its ground state.
It is measured in kJ/mol or eV/atom.
The key trend is:
IE increases across a period (left → right) and decreases down a group (top → bottom).
But why? Let’s break down the reasoning step-by-step.
1. The Core Formula: Coulomb’s Law
The energy needed to remove an electron is fundamentally governed by the electrostatic attraction between the electron and the nucleus.
F=r2k⋅Zeff⋅e2
Where:
- Zeff = effective nuclear charge (net positive charge felt by the electron)
- r = distance of the electron from the nucleus
- e = charge of electron
- k = Coulomb constant
Key insight: The stronger the attraction, the higher the ionization energy.
2. Why IE Increases Across a Period
Reasoning:
- As you move left → right, protons increase in the nucleus.
- Electrons are added to the same principal energy level (same shell).
- Shielding by inner electrons remains roughly constant (same number of inner shells).
- Therefore, Zeff increases — the outer electrons feel a stronger pull.
Result:
IE∝Zeff
So IE increases across a period.
Example:
- Na (Z=11): IE = 496 kJ/mol
- Mg (Z=12): IE = 738 kJ/mol
- Al (Z=13): IE = 578 kJ/mol (slight dip due to p-orbital shielding — see exception below)
3. Why IE Decreases Down a Group
Reasoning:
- As you move down a group, principal quantum number n increases.
- The outermost electron is farther from the nucleus (r increases).
- Shielding increases because more inner electron shells are present.
- Zeff increases only slightly (not enough to compensate for distance).
Result:
IE∝r21
So IE decreases down a group.
Example:
- Li (n=2): IE = 520 kJ/mol
- Na (n=3): IE = 496 kJ/mol
- K (n=4): IE = 419 kJ/mol
4. The Mathematical Expression (Approximation)
For a hydrogen-like atom (single electron), the ionization energy is given by:
IE=n213.6eV⋅Z2
For multi-electron atoms, we replace Z with Zeff:
IE≈n213.6eV⋅Zeff2
Why this holds:
- Zeff accounts for shielding by inner electrons.
- n is the principal quantum number of the electron being removed.
- The 1/n2 dependence comes from the Bohr model — energy levels scale as En∝−Z2/n2.
5. Exceptions (Why the Trend Isn’t Perfect)
a) Group 13 vs Group 2 (e.g., Al vs Mg)
- Al has a p-orbital electron (higher energy, easier to remove) than Mg’s s-orbital.
- Also, p-orbitals are more shielded by s- and p-electrons.
b) Group 16 vs Group 15 (e.g., O vs N)
- N has a half-filled p-subshell (extra stability).
- O has one paired electron — electron-electron repulsion makes removal easier.
6. Summary Table
| Factor | Across Period (→) | Down Group (↓) |
|---|---|---|
| Zeff | Increases | Increases slightly |
| r (distance) | Decreases slightly | Increases |
| Shielding | Constant | Increases |
| IE | Increases | Decreases |
Final Takeaway
Ionization energy is not just a number — it’s a direct consequence of Coulomb’s law, modified by shielding and orbital shape.
The trend is driven by Zeff (across) and distance + shielding (down).
Always ask: “How strongly is this electron held?” — and the answer lies in the balance of nuclear charge, distance, and shielding.
The key idea is that the +3 oxidation state means three electrons have been removed from the neutral atom.
- The given configuration for XX3+ is [Ar]3d5. Argon has atomic number 18, so XX3+ has 18+5=23 electrons.
- Since the ion has lost 3 electrons, the neutral atom must have 23+3=26 electrons.
- Atomic number equals the number of electrons in a neutral atom, so the atomic number is 26.
The atomic number is 26, which corresponds to option (ii).
The +3 oxidation state has lost three electrons from the neutral atom. The 3d5 configuration in +3 means the neutral atom had 3d64s2 (since 4s electrons are lost first). That gives atomic number 26 — iron (Fe). So the answer is (ii) 26.
The key to this problem is understanding how transition metals lose electrons when forming ions. Many students memorise the electronic configurations of neutral atoms but forget that when a transition element forms a positive ion, the 4s electrons are lost before the 3d electrons. This is a classic exam trap.
Let’s break it down.
-
What does [Ar]3d5 in the +3 state tell us?
The ion XX3+ has the same electron configuration as argon plus five electrons in the 3d subshell. So the total number of electrons in XX3+ is:
18 (from Ar)+5=23 electrons.
-
Relating ion electrons to neutral atom electrons
A neutral atom has the same number of electrons as its atomic number Z. When it loses 3 electrons to become XX3+, the number of electrons drops by 3. So:
Electrons in XX3+=Z−3
We already know this equals 23, so:
Z−3=23⟹Z=26
That gives atomic number 26 directly — provided the order of electron loss has been accounted for correctly, which the next step verifies.
-
Why the 4s electrons matter
The neutral atom with Z=26 is iron. Its ground state configuration is [Ar]3d64s2. When iron forms FeX3+, it loses the two 4s electrons first, then one 3d electron. So:
Fe: [Ar]3d64s2
FeX3+: [Ar]3d5
This matches perfectly.
A common mistake is to assume the +3 ion’s configuration comes directly from the neutral atom’s configuration by removing 3d electrons first. If you did that, you might think the neutral atom had 3d8 (since 3d5 in +3 means 3d8 in neutral), giving Z=26 anyway — but that’s a coincidence here. For other elements, that wrong reasoning would give the wrong answer. Always remember: 4s is higher in energy than 3d for neutral atoms, so 4s electrons are lost first when forming cations.
- Checking the options
- (i) 25: Mn — neutral [Ar]3d54s2; MnX3+ would be [Ar]3d4 (lose two 4s and one 3d). Not correct.
- (ii) 26: Fe — neutral [Ar]3d64s2; FeX3+ is [Ar]3d5. Correct.
- (iii) 27: Co — neutral [Ar]3d74s2; CoX3+ is [Ar]3d6. Not correct.
- (iv) 24: Cr — neutral [Ar]3d54s1 (exception); CrX3+ is [Ar]3d3. Not correct.
For quick verification: the +3 oxidation state of a first-row transition metal with 3d5 configuration is almost always iron. Manganese in +3 gives 3d4, and chromium in +3 gives 3d3. So if you see [Ar]3d5 for a +3 ion, think iron.
The atomic number is 26, which corresponds to option (ii).
Method: Electronic Configuration Reconstruction
This method works backwards from the given ion’s configuration to find the neutral atom’s atomic number.
Steps
-
Write the given ion’s configuration
X3+:[Ar]3d5
This means the ion has 23 electrons (Argon has 18 electrons + 5 from 3d5).
-
Add back the lost electrons
Since the ion has a +3 charge, the neutral atom has 3 more electrons than the ion.
Number of electrons in neutral X = 23+3=26
-
Atomic number = number of electrons in neutral atom
For a neutral atom, atomic number = electron count.
So atomic number = 26.
-
Verify with known element
Atomic number 26 is Iron (Fe).
Check: Fe ([Ar]3d64s2) loses 3 electrons (4s2 first, then one 3d) to give Fe3+:[Ar]3d5 — which matches.
Final Answer
Atomic number = 26 → Option (ii)
Common Mistakes & How to Avoid Them
Mistake 1: Forgetting the +3 Oxidation State Means 3 Electrons Removed
Many students directly count electrons from the given configuration [Ar]3d5 and conclude:
- Total electrons = 18 (Ar) + 5 = 23
- Then assume atomic number = 23 (which isn't even an option)
Why this is wrong:
The configuration [Ar]3d5 is for the +3 ion, not the neutral atom. You must add back the 3 electrons that were removed.
How to avoid:
Always ask: "Is this configuration for the neutral atom or an ion?" If it's an ion, reverse the charge to find the neutral atom's electron count.
Mistake 2: Confusing Atomic Number with Number of Electrons in the Ion
Some students see 3d5 and immediately think of Mn (Z=25) because neutral Mn has [Ar]3d54s2. They pick option (i) 25 without checking the oxidation state.
Why this is wrong:
Neutral Mn has 25 electrons. But here, the +3 ion has 23 electrons (18 from Ar + 5 from 3d). So the neutral atom must have 23 + 3 = 26 electrons, which corresponds to Fe (Z=26).
How to avoid:
- Write the neutral configuration first: [Ar]3d54s2 is Mn (Z=25)
- Remove 3 electrons (from 4s first, then 3d): [Ar]3d4 — but the question gives [Ar]3d5, so this doesn't match Mn.
- For Fe (Z=26): neutral is [Ar]3d64s2; remove 3 electrons → [Ar]3d5 ✓
Mistake 3: Forgetting the 4s Orbital Fills Before 3d (But Empties First)
Students sometimes remove electrons from 3d before 4s, leading to wrong configurations.
Correct order for removal:
When forming positive ions, electrons are removed from the 4s orbital first, even though 3d fills first in the neutral atom.
How to avoid:
Remember the mnemonic: "Last in, first out" for transition metals — 4s fills last but empties first.
Mistake 4: Rushing and Not Checking All Options
Some students calculate 26, see it's an option, and mark it without verifying if other options could also give [Ar]3d5 in +3 state.
Quick verification:
| Atomic No. | Neutral Config. | After losing 3e⁻ | Matches? |
|---|---|---|---|
| 25 (Mn) | [Ar]3d54s2 | [Ar]3d4 | ✗ |
| 26 (Fe) | [Ar]3d64s2 | [Ar]3d5 | ✓ |
| 27 (Co) | [Ar]3d74s2 | [Ar]3d6 | ✗ |
| 24 (Cr) | [Ar]3d54s1 | [Ar]3d4 | ✗ |
How to avoid:
Always do a quick sanity check — write the neutral configuration for each option and remove electrons in the correct order.
Final Answer
The atomic number is 26 (Option (ii)).
- KEAM 2026Set eng-2026-04184 marksMCQQ.The correct decreasing order of the first ionization enthalpies among the elements C, N, O, F is (A) N > O > F > C (B) O > F > N > C (C) C > N > O > F (D) F > N > O > C (E) C > O > N > F
›Reveal solutionSolution
The order is F>N>O>C; nitrogen's stable half-filled 2p3 configuration gives it a higher first IE than oxygen.
Generally first ionization enthalpy increases across a period (C < N < O < F), but the extra-stable half-filled 2p3 of nitrogen makes it harder to ionize than oxygen (whose paired 2p4 electron is easier to remove).
Approximate values (kJ mol⁻¹): C ≈ 1086, N ≈ 1402, O ≈ 1314, F ≈ 1681.
Decreasing order:
F>N>O>C
✓Final answerThe correct option is (D).
- KEAM 2026Set eng-2026-04224 marksMCQQ.Which of the following represents the correct increasing order of first ionization enthalpy for Ca, Ba, S, Se and Ar? (A) Ca < S < Ba < Se < Ar (B) Ar < S < Ba < Se < Ca (C) Ba < Ca < Se < S < Ar (D) Ba < Ca < S < Se < Ar (E) Ca < S < Ar < Se < Ba
›Reveal solutionSolution
First ionization enthalpies rise across a period and fall down a group: Ba < Ca < Se < S < Ar.
Approximate IE1 values (kJ/mol): Ba ≈ 503, Ca ≈ 590, Se ≈ 941, S ≈ 1000, Ar ≈ 1521. Ba is below Ca in group 2 (lower IE); S is above Se in group 16 (higher IE); Ar, a noble gas, is highest. Increasing order: Ba < Ca < Se < S < Ar.
✓Final answerThe correct option is (C).
- KEAM 2025Set eng-2025-04274 marksMCQQ.The alkali metal with the highest first enthalpy of ionization is (A) Cs (B) Rb (C) K (D) Na (E) Li
›Reveal solutionSolution
Down Group 1, atomic size increases and the outer electron is less tightly held, so ionization enthalpy falls — making Li the highest and Cs the lowest.
Among the alkali metals (Li, Na, K, Rb, Cs), the first ionization enthalpy decreases down the group. As we move down, the atomic radius increases and the valence electron is farther from the nucleus and more shielded, so it is removed more easily.
Lithium, being the smallest, holds its outer electron most tightly and therefore has the highest first ionization enthalpy of the listed alkali metals.
✓Final answerThe correct option is (E).
- KEAM 2025Set pha-2025-0429F4 marksMCQQ.The correct order of ionization enthalpy is (A) C < B < O < N (B) B < O < C < N (C) N < C < O < B (D) B < C < O < N (E) C < B < O < N
›Reveal solutionSolution
[!TLDR]
Ranking the first ionization enthalpies of B, C, N and O gives the increasing order B<C<O<N, so option (D) is correct.
Concept
In this NCERT/CBSE-aligned periodic-trends topic, ionization enthalpy increases across a period as nuclear charge grows. The one exception among these elements is nitrogen: its stable, exactly half-filled 2s22p3 subshell makes it harder to ionize than oxygen, whose 2p4 configuration has one paired electron that is easier to remove.
Solution
The standard first ionization enthalpies (kJ/mol) are:
B≈801,C≈1086,O≈1314,N≈1402
Arranging from smallest to largest:
801(B)<1086(C)<1314(O)<1402(N)
Hence B<C<O<N. The reversal of O and N is the tell-tale half-filled-stability effect.
[!ANSWER]
(D) B<C<O<N
- KEAM 2025Set pha-2025-0429F4 marksMCQQ.The first and second ionization enthalpies of lanthanoids are comparable with the element (A) Chromium (B) Calcium (C) Germanium (D) Cesium (E) Cadmium
›Reveal solutionSolution
The first and second ionization enthalpies of the lanthanoids are relatively low and lie in the same range as those of calcium, reflecting the ease of forming the common +2/+3 states.
Reasoning
Across the lanthanoid series the first and second ionization enthalpies remain fairly low and change little (poor shielding by 4f electrons keeps them comparable). Their values are of the same order as calcium's, which is why lanthanoids readily attain the +3 (and sometimes +2) oxidation states. This comparison with calcium is a standard NCERT statement.
✓Final answerThe correct option is (B).
- KEAM 2024Set eng-2024-06094 marksMCQQ.The decreasing order of first ionisation enthalpy of the following elements is (A) N>O>C>Be (B) O>N>C>Be (C) Be>C>O>N (D) O>N>Be>Ce (E) N>O>Be>C
›Reveal solutionSolution
Approximate IE1 values: N (1402) > O (1314) > C (1086) > Be (899 kJmol−1), giving N>O>C>Be.
Ionisation enthalpy generally rises across a period, but nitrogen's extra stable half-filled 2p3 configuration makes its IE1 higher than oxygen's (removing an electron from O's paired 2p4 is easier). Carbon (2p2) is lower than both, and beryllium (2s2) lowest of these four:
N(1402)>O(1314)>C(1086)>Be(899) kJmol−1.
Hence the decreasing order is N>O>C>Be.
✓Final answerThe correct option is (A).
- KEAM 2023Set eng-2023-P1-A14 marksMCQQ.The correct of variation of first ionisation enthalpies is: (A) Ne<Xe>Li>K<Cs (B) Xe<Li>K<Cs<Ne (C) Cs>K>Li>Xe<Ne (D) Li>K>Cs>Ne<Xe (E) Ne>Xe>Li>K>Cs
›Reveal solutionSolution
Ionisation enthalpy order is Ne > Xe > Li > K > Cs.
Concept and Intuition
Noble gases have the highest ionisation enthalpies (stable closed shells), and within a group it falls down the column. So the two noble gases lead, with Ne above Xe, followed by the alkali metals Li > K > Cs (decreasing down group 1).
Step-by-Step Solution
- Noble gases first: Ne (approx 2081 kJ/mol) > Xe (approx 1170).
- Alkali metals are far lower and decrease down the group: Li (520) > K (419) > Cs (376).
- Combined order: Ne > Xe > Li > K > Cs.
Common Mistakes
- Placing alkali metals above noble gases, or reversing the down-group trend (thinking Cs > Li).
✓Final answerThe correct option is (E) — Ne > Xe > Li > K > Cs.
ANSWER: E
- KEAM 2021Set eng-2021-P1-A14 marksMCQQ.The first ionisation enthalpy is the least in (A) Germanium (B) Antimony (C) Tellurium (D) Arsenic (E) Bismuth
›Reveal solutionSolution
Bismuth has the lowest first ionisation enthalpy of the options.
Concept and Intuition
First ionisation enthalpy generally increases across a period and decreases down a group as the outer electron gets farther from the nucleus and more shielded. Among the options, bismuth sits lowest in the periodic table.
Step-by-Step Solution
- Approximate IE1 values (kJ mol−1): Ge 762, As 944, Sb 831, Te 869, Bi 703.
- The smallest is bismuth at ≈703.
Common Mistakes
- Assuming a period-3/4 element like Ge is lowest, ignoring the group trend that favours Bi.
✓Final answerThe correct option is (E) — Bismuth.
ANSWER: E
🎓Unlock everything free for 14 days
- ✓Full step-by-step solutions
- ✓Concept-first explanations
- ✓Methods, shortcuts & mistakes
- ✓PYQ mapping + timed mock tests
Full access for 14 days. No credit card required.