12Pr−2=(14−r)!12! and 11Pr−1=(12−r)!11!. Their ratio is (14−r)!12!×11!(12−r)!=(14−r)!12×(12−r)!=(14−r)(13−r)12 (since (14−r)!=(14−r)(13−r)(12−r)!). Setting (14−r)(13−r)12=143: cross-multiplying, 12×14=3(14−r)(13−r)⇒168=3(14−r)(13−r)⇒(14−r)(13−r)=56. Since 56=8×7, take 14−r=8, 13−r=7, giving r=6 (both consistent). Check: 12P4=11880, 11P5=55440, ratio 11880:55440=3:14. ✓