Skip to content

Physics · Ch 1 — Units and Measurements

Estimation of error

1.8.1

Estimation of error

Suppose a physical quantity is measured repeatedly, giving a set of nn readings a1,a2,a3,…,ana_1, a_2, a_3, \ldots, a_n. The arithmetic mean of these readings is

amean=a1+a2+a3+⋯+ann=1n∑i=1nai— (1.3)a_{mean} = \dfrac{a_1 + a_2 + a_3 + \cdots + a_n}{n} = \dfrac{1}{n}\sum_{i=1}^{n} a_i \qquad \text{--- (1.3)}

and this arithmetic mean is taken as the most probable value of the quantity being measured — it is, in a well-defined statistical sense, our best single estimate given the scatter in the repeated readings.

The magnitude of the difference between the mean value and any one individual reading is called the absolute error in that particular observation. So for the reading a1a_1, the absolute error is Δa1=∣amean−a1∣\Delta a_1 = |a_{mean} - a_1|, and similarly for a2a_2 it is Δa2=∣amean−a2∣\Delta a_2 = |a_{mean} - a_2|, and so on up to Δan=∣amean−an∣\Delta a_n = |a_{mean} - a_n| for the nn-th reading.

Averaging these individual absolute errors gives the mean absolute error in the measurement:

Δamean=Δa1+Δa2+⋯+Δann=1n∑i=1nΔai— (1.4)\Delta a_{mean} = \dfrac{\Delta a_1 + \Delta a_2 + \cdots + \Delta a_n}{n} = \dfrac{1}{n}\sum_{i=1}^{n}\Delta a_i \qquad \text{--- (1.4)}

The measured value of the quantity aa can then be reported as a=amean±Δameana = a_{mean} \pm \Delta a_{mean}, which is understood to mean that the true value of aa most likely lies somewhere between amean−Δameana_{mean} - \Delta a_{mean} and amean+Δameana_{mean} + \Delta a_{mean}.

The ratio of the mean absolute error to the arithmetic mean value is called the relative error:

Relative error=Δameanamean— (1.5)\text{Relative error} = \dfrac{\Delta a_{mean}}{a_{mean}} \qquad \text{--- (1.5)}

and when the relative error is expressed as a percentage (i.e. multiplied by 100), it is called the percentage error:

Percentage error=Δameanamean×100— (1.6)\text{Percentage error} = \dfrac{\Delta a_{mean}}{a_{mean}} \times 100 \qquad \text{--- (1.6)} …

Misc Ex 1.5Mean, absolute, relative and percentage error of a sphere's radius

Worked out. Worked example applying the full error-estimation procedure of section 1.8.1 to five repeated radius measurements of a sphere (5.63 m, 5.54 m, 5.44 m, 5.40 m, 5.35 m). The method computes the arithmetic mean as the most probable value, then the absolute error of each individual reading from that mean, then averages those absolute errors to get the mean absolute error, and finally computes the relative error (mean absolute error divided by the mean) and the percentage error (relative error × 100), obtaining a most probable radius of 5.472 m with about 1.7% percentage error — a direct numerical walkthrough of Equa …

Misc Activity 1Measuring external diameter of a hollow cylinder with Vernier callipers

Worked out. A hands-on activity instructing the student to use a Vernier callipers of least count 0.01 cm to measure the external diameter of a hollow cylinder at three different positions along the cylinder, and then compute (i) the mean diameter, (ii) the absolute mean error, and (iii) the percentage error in the measurement of the diameter — directly practising the same mean/absolute-error/percentage-error procedure worked out symbolically and numerically earlier in this section, but on the student's own real measurements rather than gi …