Q.Given an one dimensional system with total energy E=2mpx2+V(x)=constant, where px is the x component of the linear momentum and V(x) is the potential energy of the system. Show that total time derivative of energy gives us force Fx=−dxdV(x). Verify Hooke's law by choosing potential energy V(x)=21kx2.
Concept understanding — Simple Harmonic Motion Energy
Simple Harmonic Motion Energy: From Intuition to Precision
Imagine a pendulum swinging, or a mass bouncing on a spring. You push it once, and it keeps moving back and forth. Where does that energy go? It doesn't vanish — it just changes form. That's the core idea.
The Intuition: A Trade Between Two Forms
Think of a child on a swing. At the highest point, the swing is momentarily still — all the energy is stored as potential energy (the height you could fall from). At the lowest point, the swing is moving fastest — all that stored energy has turned into kinetic energy (the energy of motion). In between, it's a mix of both.
For a spring-mass system (the simplest SHM), the same trade happens:
When the mass is at the extreme position (maximum displacement), it's momentarily at rest — all energy is potential.
When the mass passes through the equilibrium position (the centre), it's moving fastest — all energy is kinetic.
Everywhere else, it's a blend.
The key insight: total mechanical energy stays constant (if no friction). Energy is never created or destroyed — it just shifts between potential and kinetic.
The Precise Statement
For a particle of mass m executing SHM with angular frequency ω and amplitude A:
Etotal=21mω2A2
This is a constant. At any displacement x from equilibrium:
Kinetic energy: K=21mv2=21mω2(A2−x2)
Potential energy: U=21kx2=21mω2x2 (since k=mω2)
Total energy: E=K+U=21mω2A2
Notice: when x=±A, K=0 and U=E. When x=0, K=E and U=0.
Why This Matters for Exams
Three things to remember:
Total energy depends only on amplitude and frequency — not on the mass's position or speed at any instant. It's a fixed number for a given oscillation.
Energy is proportional to the square of amplitude: double the amplitude, quadruple the energy. This is a common exam trap — students think doubling amplitude doubles energy. It doesn't.
The potential energy curve is a parabola: U=21kx2. This is why SHM is called "harmonic" — the restoring force (F=−kx) comes from this parabolic potential well.
Watch out
A frequent mistake: writing U=21mω2x2 but forgetting that ω2=k/m. Both forms are equivalent — use whichever is given in the problem.
A Quick Check
A mass of 0.5 kg oscillates on a spring with k=8 N/m and amplitude 0.1 m. Find total energy.
Or directly: E=21kA2=21(8)(0.01)=0.04 J. Same result.
The Big Picture
SHM energy is a beautiful example of conservation of mechanical energy. The system constantly converts potential to kinetic and back, with the total never changing. This is why a pendulum (ideally) swings forever — and why real pendulums eventually stop (friction steals energy, converting it to heat).
For exams: if you know A and either k or ω and m, you can find total energy. If you know total energy and x, you can find K and U separately. It's all connected.
This is exactly the kind of concept that turns up under searches like "Simple Harmonic Motion Energy class 11 physics syllabus" or "Simple Harmonic Motion Energy solved examples" — and it belongs squarely in the Class 11 Physics NCERT/CBSE curriculum. Beyond board exams, it's a dependable scoring topic in JEE Main, NEET and state engineering/medical entrance exams once the core logic clicks.
Differentiate E=px2/2m+V(x) with respect to time; since E is constant, dE/dt=0 gives Fx=−dV/dx; with V=21kx2 this gives Hooke's law F=−kx.
✓Final answer
Fx=−dxdV(x)=−kx, confirming Hooke's law.
Step 1. Total energy is E=2mpx2+V(x)= constant. Differentiating both sides with respect to time: dtdE=mpxdtdpx+dxdVdtdx.
Step 2. Since E is constant, dE/dt=0. Also, px/m=vx=dx/dt, so the equation becomes vxdtdpx+dxdVvx=0.
Step 3. Dividing through by vx (non-zero in general): dtdpx+dxdV=0. By Newton's second law, dpx/dt=Fx, so Fx=−dxdV -- force is minus the spatial derivative of potential energy, as required.
Step 4. Substituting V(x)=21kx2: dxdV=kx, so Fx=−kx -- exactly Hooke's law, verifying that the SHM force law follows directly from this quadratic potential energy.
✓Final answer
Differentiating E=px2/2m+V(x)= constant with respect to time gives Fx=−dV/dx; substituting V(x)=21kx2 gives Fx=−kx, Hooke's law.
Differentiate the total-energy expression with respect to time, set dE/dt = 0 (energy is conserved), use dp_x/dt = F_x, and substitute the given quadratic potential energy.
Forgetting to use the chain rule correctly when differentiating V(x) with respect to time (dV/dt = (dV/dx)(dx/dt), not just dV/dx).
Not dividing out the common factor of v_x, leaving an unnecessarily complicated expression instead of the clean F_x = -dV/dx.