‘‘The Government Budget of a country cannot have fiscal deficit without the existence of revenue deficit.’’ De

Question 28 of 54

Q. ‘‘The Government Budget of a country cannot have fiscal deficit without the existence of revenue deficit.’’ Defend or refute the given statement.

Punjab PsebCBSE Class XII Board 2020Subjective· 4mImportance★★★★★

52% · 28/54 Questions

🔒 Locked · start free trial →

You're viewing a preview — the full solution, concept, methods & PYQ mapping are locked.

Start your 14-day free trial to unlock the full solution →

Concept understanding — Fiscal Deficit Definition

Fiscal Deficit: What It Really Means

Think of your household budget. If your monthly expenses exceed your income, you have a shortfall. You cover it by borrowing from someone — a friend, a bank. That shortfall is your personal "deficit."

Now scale that up to the entire country. The government earns money (mostly through taxes) and spends money (on roads, salaries, defence, subsidies). When the government's total spending exceeds its total non-borrowed income, it runs a fiscal deficit. It's the gap the government must fill by borrowing.

The Precise Definition (NCERT Class 12)

The NCERT Macroeconomics textbook defines fiscal deficit as:

Fiscal Deficit = Total Expenditure − Total Receipts excluding borrowings

Let's unpack that. "Total Receipts excluding borrowings" means all the money the government gets without going into debt — mainly tax revenue and non-tax revenue (like fees, dividends from public sector companies, etc.). Borrowings are not counted as "receipts" here because they are the source of finance for the deficit, not income.

So the formula is:

\text{Fiscal Deficit} = \text{Total Expenditure} - \text{(Revenue Receipts + Non-debt Capital Receipts)}

Where:

Total Expenditure = Revenue Expenditure (day-to-day running costs) + Capital Expenditure (building assets like highways, dams)
Revenue Receipts = Tax revenue + Non-tax revenue (fees, fines, dividends)
Non-debt Capital Receipts = Money from selling government assets (disinvestment), loan recoveries — these don't create debt

The fiscal deficit is not the same as "total borrowing." It is the amount that must be borrowed. In practice, the government covers this gap by:

Borrowing from the market (selling bonds)
Borrowing from the RBI
Drawing down cash balances

Why Does It Matter?

A fiscal deficit isn't automatically bad — it depends on why it exists and how it's financed.

When it's good: If the government borrows to build a national highway network, that creates jobs, boosts transport, and generates future tax revenue. The deficit is an investment.

When it's bad: If the deficit is caused by wasteful subsidies or paying salaries without any productive outcome, and the government keeps borrowing year after year, it piles up debt. Future generations must repay it. Large deficits can also fuel inflation if the RBI prints money to finance them.

Important

The fiscal deficit is the single most watched number in the Union Budget. It tells you how much the government is living beyond its means. A high fiscal deficit (say, above 6% of GDP) signals stress; a low one (below 3%) signals fiscal discipline.

A Simple Diagram (in words)

Imagine a vertical bar representing total government expenditure. Below it, a shorter bar represents total receipts (excluding borrowings). The gap between the top of the expenditure bar and the top of the receipts bar is the fiscal deficit. That gap is filled by borrowings.

Total Expenditure:  |████████████████████████████████|
                    |                                |
                    |           FISCAL DEFICIT       |
                    |           (borrowings)         |
Total Receipts:     |████████████████████████        |
                    |                                |
                    |   Revenue + Non-debt Capital   |
                    |________________________________|
``` …

Start your 14-day free trial to unlock the full solution →

The statement is false. A fiscal deficit can exist even when revenue deficit is zero or when there is a revenue surplus, because fiscal deficit includes capital expenditure while revenue deficit does not.

The claim rests on a misunderstanding of how the two deficits are defined and what they measure. To see why it fails, we need to look at what each deficit captures.

Revenue deficit measures the gap between revenue receipts and revenue expenditure:

\text{Revenue Deficit} = \text{Revenue Expenditure} - \text{Revenue Receipts}

Revenue expenditure covers day-to-day running costs—salaries, interest payments, subsidies, pensions—items that do not create assets. Revenue receipts include tax revenue and non-tax revenue like fees and dividends.

Fiscal deficit, on the other hand, is the total shortfall when all government expenditure exceeds all receipts except borrowing:

\text{Fiscal Deficit} = \text{Total Expenditure} - \text{Total Receipts (excluding borrowing)}

Equivalently,

\text{Fiscal Deficit} = (\text{Revenue Expenditure} + \text{Capital Expenditure}) - (\text{Revenue Receipts} + \text{Capital Receipts excluding borrowing})

The crucial difference is that fiscal deficit includes capital expenditure—spending on infrastructure, machinery, buildings, loans to states—while revenue deficit does not.

Now consider a scenario where the government balances its revenue account perfectly: revenue receipts exactly match revenue expenditure, so revenue deficit is zero. But suppose the government undertakes a large capital expenditure programme—building highways, airports, or power plants—financed partly by borrowing. Total expenditure now exceeds total non-borrowed receipts, creating a fiscal deficit even though revenue deficit is absent.

In fact, a government can even run a revenue surplus (revenue receipts exceed revenue expenditure) and still have a fiscal deficit if capital expenditure is large enough. Imagine revenue surplus of ₹50,000 crore but capital expenditure of ₹1,00,000 crore with capital receipts (excluding borrowing) of only ₹20,000 crore. The fiscal deficit would be ₹30,000 crore despite the revenue surplus. …

Start your 14-day free trial to unlock the full solution →

←Previous questionQ12 — Give any two examples of non-tax revenue receipts.→Next questionQ14 — Which of the following is not a non-tax revenue receipt ? (Choose the …

Q.‘‘The Government Budget of a country cannot have fiscal deficit without the existence of revenue deficit.’’ Defend or refute the given statement.

🎓Unlock everything free for 14 days

Unlock everything free for 14 days