Examples 7.8(a) · Example 1
Q.Statements:
I. Some goats are vegetarians.
II. All vegetarians are blessed.
Conclusions:
I. Some goats are blessed.
II. At least some blessed are vegetarians.
Give answer:
A - only conclusion I follows.
B - only conclusion II follows.
C - either conclusion I or II follows.
D - neither conclusion I nor II follows.
E - both conclusion I and II follow.
Sikkim CbseNCERTSubjective· 1mImportance★★★★★est
71% · 24/34 Questions
✓ Free question
Combine the "Some...are" (I-type) and "All...are" (A-type) statements using standard syllogism rules, and check the standalone conversion of statement II.
Syllogism rules used: (a) "Some A are B" + "All B are C" (middle term B) "Some A are C" is a valid conclusion.
(b) An A-type statement "All B are C" converts validly (by conversion, since B is known non-empty) to the I-type "Some C are B".
- Statement I: "Some goats are vegetarians" — Some G are V.
- Statement II: "All vegetarians are blessed" — All V are B.
- Conclusion I ("Some goats are blessed"): Since some goats are vegetarians, and all vegetarians (including that overlapping group) are blessed, those goats must also be blessed. So "Some G are B" is a valid, necessary conclusion — Conclusion I follows.
- Conclusion II ("At least some blessed are vegetarians"): Statement I confirms vegetarians exist (the class V is non-empty). From "All V are B" with V non-empty, conversion gives "Some B are V" — i.e. "At least some blessed are vegetarians." This is a valid immediate inference from statement II (using I) — Conclusion II also follows.
- Self-check with a diagram: draw circle V entirely inside circle B (statement II), and circle G overlapping V (statement I). Any point in the G∩V overlap is inside B, confirming "Some G are B"; and since V is inside B and non-empty, "Some B are V" is trivially true.
✓Final answer
Both conclusions I and II follow Answer: E.
Unlock everything free for 14 days
- Full step-by-step solutions
- Concept-first explanations
- Methods, shortcuts & mistakes
- PYQ mapping + timed mock tests
Full access for 14 days. No credit card required.