Exercise 7.3 · Q2
Q.Two statements are given below followed by two conclusions numbered
(1) and (2). Take the given two statements to be true even if they seem to be at variance from commonly known facts. Read the conclusions and then decide which of the given conclusions logically follows from the two given statements, disregarding commonly known facts.
Statements: All the harmoniums are instruments. All the instruments are flutes.
Conclusions:
(A) If only conclusion
- All the flutes are instruments.
- All the harmoniums are flutes.
(A) If only conclusion
(1) follows.
(B) If only conclusion
(B) If only conclusion
(2) follows.
(C) If either
(C) If either
(1) or
(2) follows.
(D) If neither
(D) If neither
(1) nor
(2) follows.
(E) If both
(E) If both
(1) and
(2) follow.
Sikkim CbseNCERTSubjective· 1mImportance★★★★★est
32% · 11/34 Questions
✓ Free question
Chaining "All harmoniums are instruments" with "All instruments are flutes" validly gives "All harmoniums are flutes" (conclusion 2); conclusion 1 wrongly converts a universal statement, so it does not follow.
Syllogism rule (All + All = All): if "All are " and "All are " share the middle term , then "All are " follows validly. Converse trap: "All are " does NOT imply "All are " — a universal affirmative cannot be simply converted.
Here = harmoniums, = instruments, = flutes.
- Statement 1: All are ("All harmoniums are instruments").
- Statement 2: All are ("All instruments are flutes").
- Test Conclusion (1), "All flutes are instruments" i.e. All are : this is the converse of Statement 2, which is NOT logically guaranteed (there could be flutes that are not instruments). Conclusion (1) is invalid.
- Test Conclusion (2), "All harmoniums are flutes" i.e. All are : by the All+All=All rule on the shared term , this follows directly from Statements 1 and 2. Conclusion (2) is valid.
- Hence only Conclusion (2) follows.
✓Final answer
(B) If only conclusion (2) follows.
Unlock everything free for 14 days
- Full step-by-step solutions
- Concept-first explanations
- Methods, shortcuts & mistakes
- PYQ mapping + timed mock tests
Full access for 14 days. No credit card required.