Skip to content

Chemistry · Ch 5 — Coordination Chemistry

Werner's Theory of Coordination Compounds

5.2

Werner's Theory of Coordination Compounds

Swiss chemist Alfred Werner was the first to propose a theory of coordination compounds explaining their observed behaviour, put forward in 1893 -- remarkably, before the electron itself had even been discovered (by J.J. Thomson in 1896), using nothing but simple reaction chemistry, work for which he won the 1913 Nobel Prize in Chemistry as the first inorganic chemist to do so. The puzzle Werner set out to explain: cobalt(III) chloride and ammonia both have their ordinary valences fully satisfied on their own, yet they react to form a family of distinctly coloured complexes -- CoCl₃.6NH₃ (yellow), CoCl₃.5NH₃ (purple), trans-CoCl₃.4NH₃ (green) and cis-CoCl₃.4NH₃ (violet) -- that precipitate different numbers of moles of AgCl per mole of complex when treated with excess silver ion. Werner's postulates: (1) most elements exhibit two kinds of valence, primary valence (in modern terms, the metal's oxidation state) and secondary valence (in modern terms, its coordination number), and every element tends to satisfy both; for cobalt here, the primary valence is 3 and the secondary valence is 6. (2) The primary valence is positive in most cases (zero in certain cases) and is always satisfied by negative ions -- in CoCl₃.6NH₃ the primary valence +3 is satisfied by three Cl⁻ ions. (3) The secondary valence is satisfied by negative ions, neutral molecules, positive ions, or a combination of these -- in CoCl₃.6NH₃ the secondary valence 6 is satisfied by six neutral NH₃ molecules, while in CoCl₃.5NH₃ it is satisfied by five NH₃ molecules plus one Cl⁻ ion. (4) There are two spheres of attraction around the metal atom/ion: an inner sphere, the coordination sphere, whose groups are firmly attached to the metal, and an outer sphere, the ionisation sphere, whose groups are loosely bound and can be separated into free ions on dissolving the complex. (5 …

Table 5.2-aColour and AgCl precipitated by the cobalt(III)-ammonia complexes

Complex | Colour | Moles of AgCl precipitated per mole of complex with excess Ag⁺

CoCl₃.6NH₃ | Yellow | 3

CoCl₃.5NH₃ | Purple | 2

trans-CoCl₃.4NH₃ | Green | 1

cis-CoCl₃.4NH₃ | Violet | 1

Even though the valences of cobalt(III) chloride and ammonia are both fully satisfied on their own, these four compounds form anyway -- and behave completely differently towards excess si …

Figure 5.1Inner and outer spheres of attraction in CoCl₃.6NH₃

What this figure shows. A central cobalt ion M surrounded by an inner sphere (labelled coordination sphere) containing six NH₃ molecules firmly bound to the metal, drawn inside a boundary; outside that boundary, in the outer sphere (labelled ionization sphere), three Cl atoms are shown loosely associated. The picture captures Werner's postulate 4: the six ammonia molecules are firmly attached to cobalt in the inner coordination sphere, while the three chloride ions sit in the looser outer ionisation sphere and can be separated into free …

Table 5.2-bWerner's postulates applied to the CoCl₃.nNH₃ series

Complex | Groups satisfying secondary valence (non-ionisable, inner sphere) | Ionisable Cl⁻ ions (outer sphere) | Moles of AgCl formed

CoCl₃.6NH₃ | 6 NH₃ | 3 Cl⁻ | 3 AgCl

CoCl₃.5NH₃ | 5 NH₃ & 1 Cl⁻ | 2 Cl⁻ | 2 AgCl

CoCl₃.4NH₃ (trans) | 4 NH₃ & 2 Cl⁻ | 1 Cl⁻ | 1 AgCl

CoCl₃.4NH₃ (cis) | 4 NH₃ & 2 Cl⁻ | 1 Cl⁻ | 1 AgCl …

Misc 5.2-cEvaluate yourself: CrCl₃.4H₂O secondary valence

Worked out. A self-check problem posed in this section: when the coordination compound CrCl₃.4H₂O is mixed with silver nitrate solution, only one mole of silver chloride precipitates per mole of the compound, and there are no free (uncoordinated) solvent water molecules in the compound. The student is asked to assign the secondary valence of the metal and write the structural formula. Since only 1 of the 3 chlorides precipitates as AgCl, 2 Cl⁻ must be non-ionisable (inside the coordination sphere) alongside all 4 water molecules, giving secondary valence (coordination number) …