Q.The displacement of a particle is represented by the equation . The motion is
The given displacement is periodic but not simple harmonic because it cannot be expressed as a single sine or cosine term with a constant angular frequency — its period is , but it contains higher harmonics.
The key to this question lies in understanding what makes a motion simple harmonic. Simple harmonic motion (SHM) requires the restoring force (and hence acceleration) to be directly proportional to the displacement from equilibrium, and the displacement must be a pure sinusoidal function of time — something like or . The given function is a cube of a sine, not a pure sine. That alone should raise suspicion.
Let’s break it down step by step.
- Check if the motion is periodic. A function is periodic if for some finite . Since has period , any integer power of it will also repeat after . Indeed,
So the motion is periodic with period . This eliminates option (A).
- Test if it is simple harmonic. For SHM, the displacement must satisfy for some constant . Let’s compute the acceleration. First derivative:
Second derivative (using product rule):
Simplify:
Using ,
So
This is not proportional to alone — there is an extra term. Hence the motion is not SHM.
- A cleaner way: rewrite using a trigonometric identity. Recall the triple-angle formula:
With ,
This expresses as a sum of two sine waves: one with angular frequency and another with . A simple harmonic oscillator can only vibrate at a single frequency. The presence of the term means the motion is a superposition of two harmonics — it is periodic but not simple harmonic.
The identity is a powerful shortcut. It immediately reveals that the motion contains a frequency component at , which disqualifies it from being SHM.
- Determine the period from the rewritten form. The term has period , and has period . The overall period is the least common multiple of these two periods, which is . So the period is , not .
A common mistake is to think that because looks like a sine wave, it must be SHM. But SHM requires a linear restoring force — a cubic term like introduces nonlinearity. Also, don’t confuse the period of with that of ; they are the same here, but that doesn’t make it SHM.
Thus the motion is periodic with period , but it is not simple harmonic.
The correct option is (B) — periodic but not simple harmonic.
Unlock everything free for 14 days
- Full step-by-step solutions
- Concept-first explanations
- Methods, shortcuts & mistakes
- PYQ mapping + timed mock tests
Full access for 14 days. No credit card required.