Skip to content
Exercises · Q16

Q.How are the equilibrium price and quantity affected when

(a) both demand and supply curves shift in the same direction?
(b) demand and supply curves shift in opposite directions?
Uttar Pradesh UpmspTextbookSubjective· 3mImportance★★★★★
62% · 18/29 Questions
🔒 Locked · start free trial →

You're viewing a preview — the full solution, concept, methods & PYQ mapping are locked.

Start your 14-day free trial to unlock the full solution →

When demand and supply shift together in the same direction, quantity always moves that way but price is ambiguous (depends on relative magnitudes); when they shift in opposite directions, price always moves with demand but quantity is ambiguous.

The equilibrium in a market sits at the intersection of demand and supply. When either curve shifts, that intersection moves—changing price, quantity, or both. The interesting cases arise when both curves shift simultaneously, because the two forces can reinforce or oppose each other depending on direction and magnitude.

Start with the mechanics. A rightward shift in demand (higher demand at every price) pushes equilibrium price up and quantity up. A rightward shift in supply (more supplied at every price) pushes price down but quantity up. Notice that the two shifts agree on quantity—both want more traded—but disagree on price. That disagreement is the heart of the ambiguity.

(a) Both curves shift in the same direction

Case 1: Both shift right (increase in demand and supply)

Quantity unambiguously rises. Both forces want more goods traded in the market, so the new equilibrium quantity exceeds the old one regardless of which shift is larger.

Price, however, is ambiguous:

  • If demand shifts more than supply, the upward price pressure from demand dominates → price rises.
  • If supply shifts more than demand, the downward price pressure from supply dominates → price falls.
  • If the shifts are exactly equal in magnitude, price stays unchanged.

Case 2: Both shift left (decrease in demand and supply)

Quantity unambiguously falls. Both curves now want less traded, so equilibrium quantity drops.

Price remains ambiguous by the same logic:

  • Larger leftward demand shift → price falls (demand pulling it down harder).
  • Larger leftward supply shift → price rises (supply pulling it up harder).
  • Equal shifts → price unchanged.
Note

The intuition: when both curves move together, they "agree" on the direction of quantity but "compete" over price. The larger shift wins the price tug-of-war.

(b) Curves shift in opposite directions

Case 1: Demand increases (shifts right), supply decreases (shifts left)

Price unambiguously rises. Demand pulls price up, supply pulls price up (a leftward supply shift means less available, so higher price). Both forces agree.

Quantity is ambiguous:

  • If demand increases more than supply decreases, the quantity-increasing effect of demand dominates → quantity rises.
  • If supply decreases more than demand increases, the quantity-reducing effect dominates → quantity falls.
  • Equal magnitudes → quantity unchanged.

Case 2: Demand decreases (shifts left), supply increases (shifts right)

Price unambiguously falls. Demand pulls it down, supply pulls it down. Agreement again.

Quantity is ambiguous:

  • Larger demand decrease → quantity falls.
  • Larger supply increase → quantity rises.
  • Equal shifts → quantity unchanged. …

Unlock everything free for 14 days

  • Full step-by-step solutions
  • Concept-first explanations
  • Methods, shortcuts & mistakes
  • PYQ mapping + timed mock tests

Full access for 14 days. No credit card required.