Q.[Fe(H2O)6]3+ is strongly paramagnetic whereas [Fe(CN)6]3− is weakly paramagnetic. Explain.
🔒You're viewing a preview — the full solution, concept, methods & PYQ mapping are locked.
🔒 Start your 14-day free trial to unlock the full solution →Concept understanding — Magnetic Moment Calculation
From a Paperclip to a Magnet: The Intuition
You already know that a magnet can pick up iron nails. But what is actually happening inside that nail when it gets near the magnet? And why does a plastic comb, rubbed on hair, pick up tiny bits of paper — but never iron filings?
The answer lies in magnetization — the process by which a material becomes magnetic.
Think of a piece of iron as a chaotic crowd of tiny compass needles. Each needle is an atomic magnetic moment (a tiny magnet, arising from the spin of electrons). In unmagnetized iron, these needles point in random directions. Their magnetic effects cancel out, so the iron as a whole shows no net magnetism.
Now bring a strong magnet close. Its magnetic field acts like a command: "Line up!" The tiny compass needles inside the iron start rotating, aligning themselves with the external field. The more they align, the stronger the iron's own magnetic field becomes. This alignment is magnetization.
Magnetization is not the same as inducing a current. It is a purely magnetic reorientation of atomic dipoles inside a material.
The Precise Definition
Magnetization (M) is the net magnetic dipole moment per unit volume of a material. It tells you how strongly a material is magnetized — how many tiny atomic magnets are aligned, and in which direction.
If a material has N atoms per unit volume, each with an average magnetic moment μavg, then:
M=Nμavg
The SI unit of M is amperes per metre (A/m). Why? Because a magnetic dipole moment has units of A·m², and dividing by volume (m³) gives A/m.
M=volumetotal magnetic dipole moment
How Magnetization Connects to the Magnetic Field
When a material gets magnetized, it produces its own magnetic field. The total magnetic field B inside the material is the sum of:
- The external applied field H (caused by free currents, like the current in a solenoid)
- The material's response — the magnetization M
The fundamental relation is:
B=μ0(H+M)
where μ0=4π×10−7T⋅m/A is the permeability of free space.
Do not confuse H (magnetic field intensity, or "magnetizing field") with B (magnetic flux density). H is what you apply; M is what the material does; B is the total field you measure.
The Three Kinds of Magnetic Materials
Not all materials respond the same way to an external field. The magnetization M is proportional to H for most materials (at least for small fields):
M=χmH
where χm is the magnetic susceptibility — a dimensionless number that tells you how easily a material magnetizes.
| Material Type | χm | Behaviour | Example |
|---|---|---|---|
| Diamagnetic | Small and negative (≈−10−5) | Weakly repelled by a magnet; M opposes H | Water, copper, bismuth |
| Paramagnetic | Small and positive (≈10−5 to 10−3) | Weakly attracted; M aligns with H | Aluminium, oxygen gas |
| Ferromagnetic | Large and positive (≫1) | Strongly attracted; M can be huge and persists even after H is removed | Iron, nickel, cobalt |
Why this formula?
Magnetic Moment Calculation: Why the Formula Holds
Let's build this from first principles — understanding the why before the formula.
1. What is Magnetic Moment?
A magnetic moment (μ) is a measure of the strength and orientation of a magnet or current loop. It tells us how strongly an object will interact with an external magnetic field.
The core idea: any moving charge creates a magnetic field. A loop of current is like a tiny bar magnet — its magnetic moment quantifies this.
2. The Fundamental Formula: Current Loop
The Setup
Consider a planar loop of wire carrying a steady current I, enclosing an area A.
Why μ=IA?
Step 1: Force on a moving charge
A charge q moving with velocity v in a magnetic field B experiences:
F=q(v×B)
Step 2: Torque on a current loop
For a rectangular loop of sides a and b (A=ab), placed in a uniform B:
- Current I means charge flows. On side of length a, the force magnitude is F=IaB (since I=tq and v=ta).
- These forces on opposite sides form a couple (equal, opposite, not collinear).
- Torque τ=force×perpendicular distance=(IaB)×(bsinθ)
Step 3: Recognize the pattern
τ=I(ab)Bsinθ=IABsinθ
This looks exactly like:
τ=μBsinθ
Comparing, we identify:
μ=IA
Why this works: The torque on a current loop is proportional to the current and the area — this product naturally defines the magnetic moment.
3. For a Single Moving Charge (Orbital Magnetic Moment)
The Setup
An electron of charge −e moves in a circular orbit of radius r with speed v.
Why μ=2evr?
Step 1: Treat orbit as a current loop
- Time for one revolution: T=v2πr
- Current (charge per unit time): I=Te=2πrev
Step 2: Apply μ=IA
- Area of orbit: A=πr2
- So: μ=(2πrev)(πr2)=2evr
Step 3: Express in terms of angular momentum
- Orbital angular momentum: L=mvr
- Therefore: μ=2meL
Why this matters: The magnetic moment is directly proportional to angular momentum. The factor 2me is called the gyromagnetic ratio — it links mechanics to magnetism.
4. For a Solenoid (Many Turns)
The Setup
A solenoid of N turns, length l, carrying current I, cross-sectional area A.
Why μ=NIA? …
Concept: Magnetic Moment Calculation — The number of unpaired electrons (n) determines the magnetic moment (μ=n(n+2) BM), which depends on whether the ligand is weak-field (high-spin) or strong-field (low-spin).
Step 1: Fe3+ has 3d5 configuration.
Step 2: H2O is a weak-field ligand — no pairing occurs. The five electrons occupy all five d orbitals singly: t2g3eg2 (high-spin). n=5, so μ=5(7)≈5.92 BM — strongly paramagnetic. …
The difference in paramagnetic strength arises from the ligand field splitting: weak-field HX2O ligands leave FeX3+ with five unpaired electrons (high-spin, strong paramagnetism), while strong-field CNX− ligands cause pairing, leaving only one unpaired electron (low-spin, weak paramagnetism).
The key here is not just counting electrons — it’s understanding how the ligand environment reshapes the electron configuration of the central metal ion. Both complexes contain FeX3+, which has a 3d5 configuration. But the magnetic behaviour is dramatically different because the ligands control whether those five d-electrons remain unpaired or are forced into pairs.
Let’s walk through the reasoning step by step.
-
Determine the oxidation state and d-electron count.
In both complexes, iron is in the +3 oxidation state.
Fe (atomic number 26) has the ground-state configuration [Ar]3d64s2.
Losing three electrons (two from 4s and one from 3d) gives FeX3+: 3d5.
So we have five electrons to place in the d-orbitals.
-
Recall the effect of ligand field splitting in octahedral complexes.
In an octahedral field, the five d-orbitals split into two sets:
- Lower energy: t2g (three orbitals: dxy,dxz,dyz)
- Higher energy: eg (two orbitals: dx2−y2,dz2) The energy gap between them is called Δo (or 10Dq). The magnitude of Δo depends on the ligand: strong-field ligands (like CNX−) cause a large splitting; weak-field ligands (like HX2O) cause a small splitting.
-
Apply Hund’s rule vs. pairing energy.
For a d5 configuration, there are two possible arrangements:
- High-spin: electrons occupy all five orbitals singly before any pairing occurs. This requires Δo to be smaller than the pairing energy (P).
- Low-spin: electrons pair up in the t2g orbitals, leaving some orbitals empty. This happens when Δo>P.
If Δo<P→high-spin;if Δo>P→low-spin
-
Analyse [Fe(HX2O)X6]3+.
Water is a weak-field ligand. For FeX3+, Δo for HX2O is about 13,700 cm−1, while the pairing energy P is roughly 17,600 cm−1.
Since Δo<P, the electrons avoid pairing.
The five d-electrons occupy all five orbitals singly:
t2g3 eg2
This gives five unpaired electrons.
Magnetic moment: μ=n(n+2)=5×7=35≈5.92 BM — strongly paramagnetic.
- Analyse [Fe(CN)X6]3−. Cyanide is a strong-field ligand. For FeX3+, Δo for CNX− is about 35,000 cm−1, far above P. Now Δo>P, so electrons pair up in the t2g orbitals before occupying eg. The configuration becomes:
t2g5 eg0
This means four electrons are paired in two orbitals, and one electron remains unpaired in the third t2g orbital. …
Method: Spin-Only Magnetic Moment Calculation Using Crystal Field Theory
Why This Method?
Magnetic moment depends on the number of unpaired electrons. Crystal Field Theory (CFT) explains how ligands affect electron pairing by splitting the d-orbitals into different energy levels.
Step 1: Determine the oxidation state and d-electron count
-
[Fe(H2O)6]3+
Fe atomic number = 26
Fe³⁺ = 26 − 3 = 23 electrons → d5 configuration
-
[Fe(CN)6]3−
Same Fe³⁺ → also d5 configuration
Step 2: Identify ligand field strength and orbital splitting
- H2O is a weak field ligand → small Δo (crystal field splitting energy)
- CN− is a strong field ligand → large Δo
For an octahedral complex:
- Weak field → high-spin (electrons fill all orbitals singly before pairing)
- Strong field → low-spin (electrons pair up in lower t2g orbitals first)
Step 3: Write the electron distribution in t2g and eg orbitals
| Complex | Ligand type | Spin state | t2g | eg | Unpaired electrons |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| [Fe(H2O)6]3+ | Weak field | High-spin | ↑ ↑ ↑ | ↑ ↑ | 5 |
| [Fe(CN)6]3− | Strong field | Low-spin | ↑↓ ↑↓ ↑ | — | 1 |
Step 4: Apply the spin-only formula
μ=n(n+2) BM
where n = number of unpaired electrons, BM = Bohr magneton.
- For [Fe(H2O)6]3+ (n=5): …
Here is a breakdown of the common mistakes students make when explaining the magnetic behavior of [Fe(H2O)6]3+ and [Fe(CN)6]3−, along with how to avoid them.
Mistake 1: Forgetting to Check the Oxidation State First
The Mistake: Students jump straight to the ligand (H₂O vs. CN⁻) without first calculating the oxidation state of Iron. This leads to using the wrong electronic configuration (e.g., assuming Fe is in +2 state or using the wrong d-count).
How to Avoid:
Always start with the charge balance.
- For [Fe(H2O)6]3+: The complex has a +3 charge. H₂O is neutral. Therefore, x+0=+3⟹Fe is in +3 state.
- For [Fe(CN)6]3−: The complex has a -3 charge. CN⁻ has a -1 charge. Therefore, x+6(−1)=−3⟹x−6=−3⟹Fe is in +3 state.
Key Result: Both complexes contain Fe(III), which has a d5 configuration. The difference in magnetism is not due to a different number of electrons, but due to how those 5 electrons are arranged.
Mistake 2: Confusing Strong Field vs. Weak Field Ligands
The Mistake: Students memorize that CN⁻ is a strong field ligand and H₂O is a weak field ligand, but they apply this rule blindly without considering the geometry or the specific metal ion. They might also forget that H₂O can act as a strong field ligand for some metals (like Co³⁺), but not for Fe³⁺.
How to Avoid:
- Memorize the Spectrochemical Series: I⁻ < Br⁻ < S²⁻ < SCN⁻ < Cl⁻ < NO₃⁻ < N₃⁻ < F⁻ < OH⁻ < C₂O₄²⁻ < H₂O < NCS⁻ < CH₃CN < py < NH₃ < en < bipy < phen < NO₂⁻ < PPh₃ < CN⁻ ≈ CO.
- Apply it to the specific metal: For Fe³⁺ (a d5 system), H₂O is a weak field ligand (causes high spin), while CN⁻ is a strong field ligand (causes low spin).
Mistake 3: Drawing the Wrong Crystal Field Splitting Diagram
The Mistake: Students draw the t2g and eg levels but place the electrons incorrectly. Common errors include:
- Forgetting Hund's rule (electrons must occupy all orbitals singly before pairing).
- Pairing electrons in the t2g set for the weak field case.
- Not pairing electrons in the t2g set for the strong field case.
How to Avoid:
Draw the diagram step-by-step.
For [Fe(H2O)6]3+ (Weak Field, High Spin):
- Δo is small.
- Fill all 5 orbitals singly first.
- Configuration: t2g3eg2.
- Number of unpaired electrons: 5.
For [Fe(CN)6]3− (Strong Field, Low Spin):
- Δo is large.
- Electrons pair up in the lower energy t2g orbitals before occupying eg.
- Configuration: t2g5eg0.
- Number of unpaired electrons: 1.
Mistake 4: Confusing "Paramagnetic" with "Diamagnetic"
The Mistake: Students might say a complex with 1 unpaired electron is diamagnetic, or they might forget that "weakly paramagnetic" still means it has unpaired electrons (just fewer of them).
How to Avoid:
- Paramagnetic: Has at least one unpaired electron. Attracted to a magnetic field.
- Diamagnetic: All electrons are paired. Repelled by a magnetic field.
- Strongly paramagnetic: Many unpaired electrons (here, 5). …
Showing the 12 most recent of 15 on this concept.
- CBSE 2026Set ANNUAL1 markQ.Write the formula for calculating 'spin only' magnetic moment.
›Reveal solutionSolution
The spin-only formula estimates a transition metal ion's magnetic moment purely from its number of unpaired electrons, ignoring orbital contribution.
…
- CBSE 2026Set ANNUAL1 markQ.Give one example of a complex having tetrahedral geometry and paramagnetic in nature.
›Reveal solutionSolution
[NiCl4]2− is the standard example of a tetrahedral, paramagnetic complex, arising from sp3 hybridisation of Ni2+ with the weak-field Cl− ligand.
Why [NiCl4]2− fits
Ni has configuration [Ar]3d84s2; in Ni2+, this becomes 3d8. Cl− is a weak-field ligand (low in the spectrochemical series), so it does not force pairing of the 3d electrons. With four ligands and no d-orbital freed by pairing, nickel uses one 4s and three 4p orbitals — sp3 hybridisation — giving a **tetrahedr …
- CBSE 2026Set ANNUAL1 markQ.According to VBT, which one has the highest paramagnetic character? [Cr(H2O)6]3+ or [Fe(H2O)6]2+
›Reveal solutionSolution
Counting unpaired d-electrons for each ion under VBT shows Fe2+ (d6, high-spin, 4 unpaired) is more paramagnetic than Cr3+ (d3, always 3 unpaired).
[Cr(H2O)6]3+
Cr (Z=24) is [Ar]3d54s1; Cr3+ removes 3 electrons to give 3d3. With only 3 electrons for the three t2g orbitals, Hund's rule places one electron in each — t2g3 — giving 3 unpaired electrons, regardless of whether the ligand is weak- or strong-field (there's no way to pair up 3 electrons across 3 orbitals to reduce this further).
[Fe(H2O)6]2+
…
- CBSE 2026Set ANNUAL1 markQ.Write True or False: Value of magnetic moment of a divalent ion in aqueous solution having atomic number 25, will be 5.92 B.M.
›Reveal solutionSolution
Mn2+ has 5 unpaired electrons, giving a spin-only moment of 5.92 B.M., so the statement is true.
Atomic number 25 = manganese, [Ar] 3d5 4s2. The divalent ion Mn2+ = [Ar] 3d5, which has 5 unpaired electrons.
…
- CBSE 2026Set ANNUAL1 markMCQQ.Which one of the following metal ions is likely to have a magnetic moment of 1.73 BM?(a) Fe²⁺(b) Mn²⁺(c) Cr²⁺(d) Cu²⁺
›Reveal solutionSolution
Using μ = √(n(n+2)) BM, 1.73 BM means n = 1 unpaired electron; Cu²⁺ (d⁹) is the only ion with one unpaired electron — option (D).
The spin-only magnetic moment is μ=n(n+2) BM, where n is the number of unpaired electrons. A value of 1.73 BM gives 1(1+2)=3=1.73, so n=1 unpaired electron.
Now count unpaired electrons for each ion:
- Fe2+: 3d6 → 4 unpaired (μ≈4.9 BM). …
- CBSE 2025Set JZ1 markMCQQ.Magnetic moment of a bivalent ion in aqueous solution will be, if its atomic number is 25(a) 1.73 BM(b) 2.83 BM(c) 4.96 BM(d) 5.92 BM
›Reveal solutionSolution
Mn2+ (3d5) has 5 unpaired electrons, so μ=5(5+2)=5.92 BM — option (d).
Concept. The magnetic moment of a transition-metal ion depends only on the number of unpaired d-electrons (n), through the spin-only formula μ=n(n+2) BM.
Step 1 — identify the ion. Atomic number 25 → manganese (Mn), configuration [Ar]3d54s2. A bivalent ion Mn2+ loses the two 4s electrons: Mn2+=[Ar]3d5.
…
- CBSE 2025Set ANNUAL1 markMCQQ.The spin magnetic moment of Co3+ ion is:(a) sqrt(3) BM(b) sqrt(8) BM(c) sqrt(15) BM(d) sqrt(24) BM
›Reveal solutionSolution
Co3+ has the configuration [Ar]3d6; in the high-spin (free-ion) state this places 4 electrons unpaired, giving a spin-only magnetic moment of √(n(n+2)) = √24 BM.
Cobalt (Z = 27) has ground state configuration [Ar]3d7 4s2. Removing 3 electrons to form Co3+ removes the two 4s electrons first and then one 3d electron, giving Co3+: [Ar]3d6.
Filling the five d orbitals with 6 electrons by Hund's rule (maximum multiplicity, i.e., high-spin, as would apply to the free gaseous ion or in a weak field):
↑↓ ↑ ↑ ↑ ↑ → one orbital doubly occupied, four orbitals singly occupied → 4 unpaired electrons (n = 4).
…
- CBSE 2025Set ANNUAL1 markMCQQ.Which of the following is a paramagnetic complex?(a) [Ni(H2O)6]2+(b) [Ni(CO)4](c) [Zn(NH3)4]2+(d) [Co(NH3)6]
›Reveal solutionSolution
Ni2+ (d8) with the weak-field ligand H2O keeps 2 electrons unpaired; the other three complexes all have a d10 or strong-field-paired d-count and are diamagnetic.
[Ni(H₂O)₆]²⁺: Ni²⁺ is d⁸; H₂O is a weak-field ligand and cannot force pairing, so 2 electrons remain unpaired — paramagnetic (octahedral, sp³d² outer-orbital complex).
[Ni(CO)₄]: here nickel is in the zero oxidation state, Ni(0), configuration 3d¹⁰4s⁰ — a completely filled d-subshell regardless of ligand field, so it is diamagnetic (sp³, tetrahedral).
[Zn(NH₃)₄]²⁺: Zn²⁺ is always 3d¹⁰ (fully filled) in its only common oxidation state, so it is diamagnetic (sp³, tetrahedral) irrespective of the ligand.
…
- CBSE 2024Set ANNUAL1 markMCQQ.The magnetic moment of Mn+2 in aqueous solution is –(a) 2.84 B.M(b) 3.87 B.M(c) 4.90 B.M(d) 5.92 B.M
›Reveal solutionSolution
Mn²⁺ has a half-filled d⁵ configuration with 5 unpaired electrons, and the spin-only formula gives a magnetic moment of 5.92 B.M.
Mn2+ has the configuration [Ar]3d5 — a half-filled d-subshell, with all 5 electrons unpaired (by Hund's rule, each of the 5 d-orbitals holds one electron).
Using the spin-only formula:
μ=n(n+2) B.M.,n=5
…
- CBSE 2023Set ANNUAL1 markQ.Calculate the spin only magnetic moment of M2+(aq) ion (Z=27).
›Reveal solutionSolution
Z=27 corresponds to cobalt; Co2+(aq) has the configuration 3d7 with 3 unpaired electrons, giving a spin-only magnetic moment of 15≈3.87 BM.
Identify the ion: Z=27 is cobalt (Co), with ground-state configuration [Ar]3d74s2. Removing 2 electrons (always from 4s first) to form Co2+ gives:
Co2+:[Ar]3d7
Count unpaired electrons: Distributing 7 electrons among the five 3d orbitals following Hund's rule (each orbital singly filled first, before pairing) for the aqua ion (a weak-field, high-spin case):
↑↓ ↑↓ ↑ ↑ ↑
…
- CBSE 2020Set 56/2/11 markMCQQ.Total number of unpaired electrons present in Co3+ (Atomic number = 27) is (A) 2 (B) 7 (C) 3 (D) 5
›Reveal solutionSolution
Cobalt loses three electrons to form Co3+, leaving an electronic configuration of [Ar]3d6. In the d6 configuration, pairing depends on ligand field strength, but the question asks for the ground-state free ion, which follows Hund's rule and has 4 unpaired electrons.
The number of unpaired electrons in a transition metal ion determines its magnetic properties. To find this, we need the electronic configuration of the ion and then apply Hund's rule of maximum multiplicity.
Understanding the Configuration
Cobalt has atomic number 27. The neutral atom's electronic configuration is:
[Ar]3d74s2
When cobalt forms Co3+, it loses three electrons. Electrons are always removed from the outermost shell first—both 4s electrons go first, then one 3d electron:
Co3+:[Ar]3d6
Applying Hund's Rule
The five 3d orbitals can hold up to 10 electrons. With 6 electrons to place, Hund's rule tells us to:
- Maximize unpaired electrons first by placing one electron in each orbital with parallel spin.
- Then pair up any remaining electrons.
Let me show the filling pattern for 3d6:
dxy dyz dzx dx2−y2 dz2 ↑↓ ↑ ↑ ↑ ↑ The first five electrons occupy all five orbitals singly (all spin-up). The sixth electron must pair with one of them.
Result: 4 unpaired electrons and 1 paired set. …
- CBSE 2019Set ANNUAL1 markQ.Calculate the magnetic moment of a divalent ion in aqueous solution if its atomic number is 25.
›Reveal solutionSolution
The divalent ion of element 25 is Mn2+, a 3d5 ion with all five d-orbitals singly occupied; the spin-only formula then gives μ≈5.92 BM.
Element with atomic number 25 is manganese (Mn): [Ar]3d54s2.
Forming the divalent ion Mn2+ removes the two 4s electrons first:
Mn2+: [Ar]3d5
By Hund's rule, all five 3d electrons occupy the five d-orbitals singly (maximum multiplicity), giving n=5 unpaired electrons.
…
🎓Unlock everything free for 14 days
- ✓Full step-by-step solutions
- ✓Concept-first explanations
- ✓Methods, shortcuts & mistakes
- ✓PYQ mapping + timed mock tests
Full access for 14 days. No credit card required.