Q.A spherical ball of salt is dissolving in water in such a manner that the rate of decrease of the volume at any instant is proportional to the surface. Prove that the radius is decreasing at a constant rate.
Concept understanding — Related Rates
Related Rates
The idea: quantities that change together
Many real situations involve two or more quantities that all vary with time, linked by a fixed relationship. Inflate a balloon and its radius and volume both grow; slide a ladder down a wall and the top's height and the foot's distance both change. A related-rates problem gives you the rate at which one quantity is changing and asks for the rate of another, at some instant.
The key insight: if the quantities are tied together by an equation, then their rates are tied together too. We uncover that link by differentiating the equation with respect to time t.
The core mechanism: differentiate with respect to time
Every variable is a function of t, so differentiating brings in the chain rule — each variable's derivative picks up a factor of its own rate. For example, if the volume of a sphere is V=34πr3, then differentiating both sides with respect to t gives
dtdV=4πr2dtdr.
This single equation connects the rate the volume grows, dtdV, to the rate the radius grows, dtdr. Knowing one (and the current r) gives the other.
The standard procedure
Solving a related-rates problem
- Identify the quantities that change with time and the rate you want.
- Write an equation relating those quantities (geometry, a formula, etc.).
- Differentiate both sides with respect to t, treating every variable as a function of t.
- Substitute the known values and the known rate at the given instant.
- Solve for the unknown rate.
Worked example
Air is pumped into a spherical balloon at dtdV=100 cm3/s. How fast is the radius increasing when r=5 cm?
From dtdV=4πr2dtdr, substitute dtdV=100 and r=5:
100=4π(5)2dtdr=100πdtdr⟹dtdr=π1 cm/s.
Substitute the numerical values after differentiating, never before. If you plug r=5 into the volume formula first, r becomes a constant and its rate dtdr vanishes from the equation.
The everyday cases are the sphere/circle (V,A vs. r), the sliding ladder (x2+y2=ℓ2), and the filling cone. In each you differentiate the relation in t and solve for the missing rate.
Related rates problems are a named application within the NCERT Class 12 Application of Derivatives chapter, and classic setups like the growing balloon or the sliding ladder are staples of CBSE board and JEE Main 'rate of change' questions. Students searching 'related rates problems class 12 examples' or 'rate of change of volume and radius' will find this differentiate-then-substitute method is exactly the five-step procedure boards expect to see written out.
Concept: Related Rates — connecting the rate of change of volume to the rate of change of radius via the geometry of a sphere.
Step 1: Let r be the radius, V=34πr3 the volume, and S=4πr2 the surface area. The given condition is:
dtdV=−kS,k>0
(the negative sign indicates decrease).
Step 2: Differentiate V with respect to t:
dtdV=4πr2dtdr
Step 3: Substitute into the condition:
4πr2dtdr=−k(4πr2)
Cancel 4πr2 (valid for r=0):
dtdr=−k
Since k is constant, dtdr is constant — the radius decreases at a constant rate.
The radius decreases at a constant rate: dtdr=−k.
The problem is a classic related rates application: we are told dV/dt∝S, and we need to show dr/dt is constant. Using the formulas V=34πr3 and S=4πr2, differentiating, and substituting the proportionality gives dr/dt=−k, a constant.
Why this works — the core idea
When a problem says "the rate of decrease of volume is proportional to the surface area," it gives you a direct link between dV/dt and S. But V and S are both functions of the radius r. So if you differentiate V with respect to time, you get an expression involving dr/dt. Plugging in the proportionality then lets you solve for dr/dt — and if that turns out to be independent of r, you've proven it's constant.
The key is that the surface area S itself depends on r2, and the volume depends on r3. When you differentiate, the r2 terms cancel beautifully, leaving only a constant.
Step-by-step solution
1. Write down the known formulas
For a sphere of radius r:
- Volume: V=34πr3
- Surface area: S=4πr2
2. Translate the given condition into an equation
"The rate of decrease of the volume at any instant is proportional to the surface."
"Rate of decrease" means dV/dt is negative. "Proportional to the surface" means dV/dt∝S. So we write:
dtdV=−kS
where k>0 is the constant of proportionality. The negative sign makes dV/dt negative (decreasing volume) while k is positive.
A common mistake is to forget the negative sign. If you write dV/dt=kS, then dV/dt would be positive — meaning volume is increasing, which contradicts "dissolving". Always check the sign against the physical situation.
3. Differentiate the volume formula with respect to time
Since V=34πr3, differentiate both sides using the chain rule:
dtdV=dtd(34πr3)=34π⋅3r2⋅dtdr=4πr2dtdr
4. Substitute into the proportionality equation
We have two expressions for dV/dt:
4πr2dtdr=−kS
But S=4πr2, so:
4πr2dtdr=−k(4πr2)
5. Cancel the common factor
Provided r=0 (the ball hasn't fully dissolved yet), we can divide both sides by 4πr2:
dtdr=−k
Notice that r2 cancels completely — the radius disappears from the equation. This is the mathematical reason why dr/dt is constant: the dependence on r from both sides cancels out.
6. Interpret the result
dtdr=−k means the radius decreases at a constant rate k (the same k from the proportionality). The negative sign just tells us the radius is shrinking, not growing.
The radius is decreasing at a constant rate, specifically dtdr=−k, where k is the positive constant of proportionality from the given condition.
Method: Proving a Rate of Change Is Constant Using Related Rates
This method applies to "prove that [some rate] is constant" problems, where you're given a proportionality between two rates of change (often for volume, surface area, and radius of a solid) and must show algebraically that a third rate simplifies to a constant.
Steps
Step 1: Write the standard geometric formulas for the quantities involved
List the formulas connecting the shape's radius to the other quantities mentioned (e.g. for a sphere, volume V=34πr3 and surface area S=4πr2).
Step 2: Translate the given words into a calculus equation
Convert the proportionality statement (e.g. "rate of decrease of volume is proportional to the surface") into an equation with a constant of proportionality, being careful with the sign — "decrease" means the rate is negative, so introduce a negative sign with a positive constant k:
dtdV=−kS,k>0
Step 3: Differentiate the volume formula with respect to time
Apply the chain rule to the volume formula from Step 1:
dtdV=dtd(34πr3)=4πr2dtdr
Step 4: Equate the two expressions for dtdV and simplify
Set the differentiated expression equal to the one from Step 2, substitute the surface-area formula for S, and cancel the common factor that appears on both sides (here, 4πr2). Whatever remains is the rate you needed to analyze — if every r-dependent term has cancelled, you have proven that rate is constant (independent of r, and hence of time).
Common Mistakes
Mistake 1: Dropping or misplacing the negative sign in the proportionality
"Rate of decrease of volume is proportional to the surface" must be written as dtdV=−kS with k>0, so that dV/dt itself comes out negative (volume shrinking). Writing dV/dt=kS instead makes the volume increase, contradicting "dissolving," and flips the sign of the final answer for dr/dt.
Mistake 2: Not justifying why r2 can be cancelled
After substituting S=4πr2, both sides contain the factor 4πr2, which cancels to leave dr/dt=−k. Skipping the step of writing S in terms of r (or cancelling without noting r=0) makes the proof of "constant rate" look like an assumption rather than a derived conclusion — the whole point of the proof is showing the r-dependence disappears.
Showing the 12 most recent of 17 on this concept.
- AP EAPCET 2021Set eng-2021-08-23-AN1 markMCQQ.The volume of a spherical ball is increasing at a rate of 4π cm3.s−1. The rate at which its radius increases, when its volume is 288π cm3, is ______ cm.s−1. (A) 61 (B) 361 (C) 91 (D) 241
›Reveal solutionSolution
Related rates on V=34πr3 give dtdr=r21, and at the given volume r=6, so dtdr=361.
Concept and Intuition
This is a classic related-rates problem: differentiate the volume formula with respect to time using the chain rule, then substitute the known rate and the radius at the instant of interest (found from the given volume).
Step-by-Step Solution
- V=34πr3.
- Differentiate w.r.t. time: dtdV=4πr2dtdr.
- Given dtdV=4π: 4π=4πr2dtdr⇒dtdr=r21.
- Find r when V=288π: 34πr3=288π⇒r3=216⇒r=6.
- dtdr=621=361 cm/s.
Common Mistakes
- Forgetting to first solve for r from the given volume before substituting into dr/dt.
- Cubing/uncubing errors when solving r3=216 (note 63=216).
✓Final answerThe correct option is (B) — 361.
ANSWER: B
- AP EAPCET 2021Set eng-2021-08-20-AN1 markMCQQ.The volume of a spherical balloon is increasing at the rate of 30 cc per minute. Find the rate of change of surface area of the balloon, when its radius is 6 cm. (A) 5 cm2.min−1 (B) 30 cm2.min−1 (C) 10 cm2.min−1 (D) 20 cm2.min−1
›Reveal solutionSolution
A standard related-rates chain: volume rate → radius rate → surface-area rate. The answer is 10 cm2/min.
Concept and Intuition
Both V and S of a sphere depend only on r, so their rates of change are linked through dr/dt via the chain rule. First use the given dV/dt to find dr/dt at the specified radius, then plug that into dS/dt.
Step-by-Step Solution
- V=34πr3⇒dtdV=4πr2dtdr.
- Given dtdV=30 cc/min and r=6 cm: 30=4π(6)2dtdr=144πdtdr.
- dtdr=144π30=24π5 cm/min.
- S=4πr2⇒dtdS=8πrdtdr.
- At r=6: dtdS=8π(6)(24π5)=24π48π⋅5=24π240π=10 cm²/min.
Common Mistakes
- Trying to relate S and V directly without going through r as the common variable.
- Arithmetic slip in simplifying 24π240π.
✓Final answerThe correct option is (C) — 10 cm2.min−1.
ANSWER: C
- AP EAPCET 2025Set eng-2025-05-23-FN1 markMCQQ.If the volume of a sphere is increasing at the rate of 12 c.c./sec, then the rate (in sq. cm/sec) at which its surface area is increasing, when the diameter of the sphere is 12 cm is (A) 2 (B) 3 (C) 4 (D) 6
›Reveal solutionSolution
This is a related-rates problem: given how fast volume grows, find how fast surface area grows at a specific radius; the answer is 4 cm2/s.
Concept and Intuition
Both V and S of a sphere depend only on r, so differentiating each with respect to time and eliminating dtdr (found from the volume-rate condition) gives the surface-area rate.
Step-by-Step Solution
- V=34πr3, so dtdV=4πr2dtdr.
- Given dtdV=12 and diameter =12⇒r=6: 12=4π(36)dtdr⇒dtdr=144π12=12π1.
- S=4πr2⇒dtdS=8πrdtdr.
- Substituting r=6, dtdr=12π1: dtdS=8π(6)⋅12π1=12π48π=4.
Common Mistakes
- Using the diameter (12) directly as the radius in the formulas instead of halving it first.
- Forgetting to substitute the specific radius before simplifying, leading to an expression instead of a number.
✓Final answerThe correct option is (C) — 4.
ANSWER: C
- AP EAPCET 2021Set eng-2021-08-20-AN1 markMCQQ.A spherical iron ball 10 cm in radius is coated with a layer of ice of uniform thickness, which melts at a rate of 50 cm3/min. When the thickness of the ice is 15 cm, the rate at which the thickness of ice decreases is ______ cm/min (A) 6π5 (B) 54π1 (C) 18π1 (D) 36π1
›Reveal solutionSolution
This is a related-rates problem: only the outer radius of the ice matters for relating the rate of volume loss to the rate of thickness loss. The answer is 18π1 cm/min.
Concept and Intuition
The iron ball's own radius (10 cm) is fixed and drops out of the derivative — only the total outer radius R=10+x, where x is the ice thickness, matters, since Vice=34πR3−34π(10)3 and the constant term vanishes on differentiating. This reduces the problem to the standard "rate of change of a sphere's volume vs. its radius" relation, dV/dt=4πR2dR/dt.
Step-by-Step Solution
- Let x(t) be the ice thickness at time t; outer radius R=10+x.
- Vice=34π(10+x)3−34π(10)3.
- dtdVice=4π(10+x)2dtdx (the constant term differentiates to zero).
- The ice melts (volume decreases) at 50 cm3/min, so dtdVice=−50.
- At the outer radius R=15 cm: 4π(15)2dtdx=−50⇒4π(225)dtdx=−50⇒900πdtdx=−50.
- dtdx=−900π50=−18π1; the thickness decreases at rate 18π1 cm/min.
Common Mistakes
- Using the iron ball's fixed radius (10 cm) instead of the full outer radius in 4πR2.
- Sign confusion between the volume decreasing and the thickness decreasing (both are negative rates, and the magnitude is what's asked).
✓Final answerThe correct option is (C) — 18π1.
ANSWER: C
- AP EAPCET 2025Set eng-2025-05-24-FN1 markMCQQ.If the surface area of a spherical bubble is increasing at the rate of 4 sq.cm/sec, then the rate of change in its volume (in cubic cm/sec) when its radius is 8 cms is (A) 8 (B) 12 (C) 15 (D) 16
›Reveal solutionSolution
A related-rates problem: given dtdS, find dtdV by eliminating dtdr through the common variable r. Answer: 16 cubic cm/sec.
Concept and Intuition
Both surface area S and volume V of a sphere depend on the single variable r (radius), which itself changes with time. The strategy in any related-rates problem is: express both quantities in terms of the shared variable, differentiate each with respect to time using the chain rule, and then eliminate the unknown rate (dtdr here) between the two equations.
Step-by-Step Solution
- Surface area: S=4πr2. Differentiating w.r.t. t: dtdS=8πrdtdr.
- We're given dtdS=4, so 8πrdtdr=4⇒dtdr=8πr4=2πr1.
- Volume: V=34πr3. Differentiating w.r.t. t: dtdV=4πr2dtdr.
- Substitute dtdr from step 2:
dtdV=4πr2⋅2πr1=2r.
- At r=8: dtdV=2(8)=16 cubic cm/sec.
Common Mistakes
- Forgetting the chain rule factor dtdr when differentiating S and V with respect to time (treating r as if it were the independent variable directly).
- Arithmetic slip in simplifying 4πr2⋅2πr1 (the π and one power of r cancel, leaving 2r).
✓Final answerThe correct option is (D) — 16.
ANSWER: D
- AP EAPCET 2021Set eng-2021-08-20-FN1 markMCQQ.The diameter and altitude of a right circular cone, at a certain instant, were found to be 10 cm and 20 cm respectively. If its diameter is increasing at a rate of 2 cm/s, then at what rate must its altitude change, in order to keep its volume constant? (A) 4 cm/s (B) 6 cm/s (C) −4 cm/s (D) −8 cm/s
›Reveal solutionSolution
This tests related rates: differentiating the volume of a cone with respect to time and setting the total rate of change to zero to keep volume constant. Answer: −8 cm/s.
Concept and Intuition
When a quantity built from several changing variables must stay constant, differentiate the formula with respect to time and set the total derivative to zero — this links the individual rates of change together.
Step-by-Step Solution
- Diameter =10 cm ⇒ radius r=5 cm; height h=20 cm.
- Diameter increasing at 2 cm/s ⇒dtd(2r)=2⇒dtdr=1 cm/s.
- Volume: V=31πr2h. Differentiate with respect to t: dtdV=31π(2rhdtdr+r2dtdh).
- For constant volume, dtdV=0⇒2rhdtdr+r2dtdh=0.
- Solve for dtdh: dtdh=−r2hdtdr=−52(20)(1)=−8 cm/s.
- The negative sign means the altitude must decrease at 8 cm/s to compensate for the increasing radius.
Common Mistakes
- Using the rate of change of the diameter directly as dtdr instead of halving it first.
✓Final answerThe correct option is (D) — −8 cm/s.
ANSWER: D
- AP EAPCET 2026Set eng-2026-05-18-AN1 markMCQQ.If the rate of increase in the surface area of a cube is 6 sq.cm./sec, then the rate of increase in its volume (in c.c./sec), when the length of its edge is 12 cm, is (A) 6 (B) 12 (C) 18 (D) 9
›Reveal solutionSolution
A related-rates problem: convert the given rate of change of surface area into the rate of change of the edge length, then into the rate of change of volume.
Concept and Intuition
Both surface area and volume of a cube are functions of the single variable a (the edge length), so differentiating each with respect to time and using the chain rule links their rates through da/dt — the one quantity actually changing independently.
Step-by-Step Solution
- Surface area: S=6a2⇒dtdS=12adtda.
- Given dtdS=6: 12adtda=6⇒dtda=2a1.
- Volume: V=a3⇒dtdV=3a2dtda.
- Substitute: dtdV=3a2⋅2a1=23a.
- At a=12: dtdV=23×12=18.
Common Mistakes
- Forgetting the factor of 6 faces when writing S=6a2 (or using S=a2).
- Plugging a=12 into da/dt before simplifying dV/dt=3a/2 algebraically, risking an arithmetic slip.
✓Final answerThe correct option is (C) — 18.
ANSWER: C
- AP EAPCET 2026Set eng-2026-05-15-FN1 markMCQQ.If a cylindrical tank of radius 3 m is filled with water at the rate of 23 m3/sec, then the rate of change of its water level in (m/sec) is (A) 3π1 (B) 2π1 (C) π1 (D) 6π1
›Reveal solutionSolution
This tests related rates for a cylinder of fixed radius; the water level rises at 6π1 m/s.
Concept and Intuition
Since the radius doesn't change as the tank fills, the volume V=πr2h is a function of h alone (with r a constant), so differentiating with respect to time directly links dV/dt to dh/dt through the constant cross-sectional area πr2.
Step-by-Step Solution
- V=πr2h, with r=3 constant, so V=9πh.
- Differentiate w.r.t. time: dtdV=9πdtdh.
- Given dtdV=23 m3/s: 23=9πdtdh⇒dtdh=18π3=6π1.
Common Mistakes
- Forgetting that r is constant and mistakenly differentiating it too (product rule on r2 as if it varied).
- Arithmetic slip simplifying 9π3/2.
✓Final answerThe correct option is (D) — 6π1.
ANSWER: D
- AP EAPCET 2025Set eng-2025-05-21-AN1 markMCQQ.If the velocity of a particle moving on a straight line is proportional to the cube root of its displacement, then its acceleration is (A) constant (B) inversely proportional to its velocity (C) proportional to its velocity (D) proportional to its displacement
›Reveal solutionSolution
Express acceleration as vdv/dx, substitute the given proportionality, and eliminate x in favour of v. Answer: acceleration is inversely proportional to velocity.
Concept and Intuition
For motion along a straight line, acceleration can be written as a=dtdv=vdxdv (chain rule through position). Given a relation between v and x, this lets us compute a purely as a function of x, and then re-express it in terms of v using the same original relation.
Step-by-Step Solution
- Given v∝x1/3, write v=kx1/3 for some constant k.
- dxdv=3kx−2/3.
- a=vdxdv=kx1/3⋅3kx−2/3=3k2x−1/3.
- From v=kx1/3, cube both sides: v3=k3x⇒x=k3v3, so x−1/3=vk.
- Substitute: a=3k2⋅vk=3vk3.
- Hence a∝v1 — acceleration is inversely proportional to velocity.
Common Mistakes
- Trying to differentiate v with respect to t directly without the vdv/dx trick, which gets stuck because x(t) isn't known explicitly.
- Forgetting to eliminate x in favour of v at the end — the question asks for the dependence on velocity, not on displacement.
✓Final answerThe correct option is (B) — inversely proportional to its velocity.
ANSWER: B
- AP EAPCET 2026Set eng-2026-05-14-FN1 markMCQQ.If the vertical angle of a cone is 60∘ and the rate of change of its total surface area is 23 cm2/sec, then the rate of change of its volume (in cm3/sec) when its radius is 5 cm, is (A) 15 (B) 10 (C) 5 (D) 9
›Reveal solutionSolution
A related-rates problem: using the 60° vertical angle to fix h and slant height l in terms of r, then chaining dtdS→dtdr→dtdV gives 5 cm3/sec.
Concept and Intuition
When a cone's vertical (apex) angle is fixed, its shape stays similar as it grows — radius and height stay in a fixed ratio determined by the semi-vertical angle. This lets us express both surface area and volume purely in terms of r, so a single related-rates chain (through dr/dt) connects the given rate of surface-area change to the unknown rate of volume change.
Step-by-Step Solution
- Vertical angle =60°, so semi-vertical angle α=30°. In the cone's cross-section, tanα=r/h, so r=htan30°=h/3, i.e. h=r3.
- Slant height: l=r2+h2=r2+3r2=4r2=2r.
- Total surface area: S=πr2+πrl=πr2+πr(2r)=3πr2.
- Differentiate: dtdS=6πrdtdr.
- Given dtdS=23 and r=5: 23=6π(5)dtdr=30πdtdr, so dtdr=30π23=15π3.
- Volume: V=31πr2h=31πr2(r3)=3πr3.
- Differentiate: dtdV=33πr2dtdr=3πr2dtdr.
- Substitute r=5, dtdr=15π3: dtdV=3π(25)⋅15π3=153×25=1575=5.
Common Mistakes
- Using the wrong trig ratio for the semi-vertical angle (mixing up r/h with h/r).
- Forgetting that total surface area includes both the base (πr2) and the lateral surface (πrl), not just the lateral part.
✓Final answerThe correct option is (C) — 5.
ANSWER: C
- AP EAPCET 2026Set eng-2026-05-14-FN1 markMCQQ.The surface area of a sphere is 49π sq.cm. If it is increased by 0.016 sq.cm, then the approximate increase in its volume (in c.c.) is (A) 0.07 (B) 0.04 (C) 0.032 (D) 0.028
›Reveal solutionSolution
Using differentials to connect a small change in surface area to the corresponding small change in volume, via the shared variable r, gives an approximate volume increase of 0.028 c.c.
Concept and Intuition
When a small change in one geometric quantity (surface area) causes a small change in another (volume), and both depend on a common variable (r), we can relate their differentials directly: dS=8πrdr and dV=4πr2dr share the same dr, so we solve for dr from the given dS and substitute into the dV formula — this is the standard "approximate change" technique using derivatives.
Step-by-Step Solution
- Surface area of sphere: S=4πr2=49π⇒r2=449⇒r=27=3.5 cm.
- Differentiate S=4πr2: dS=8πrdr.
- Given dS=0.016, and r=3.5: dr=8π(3.5)0.016=28π0.016.
- Volume: V=34πr3. Differentiate: dV=4πr2dr.
- r2=12.25, so dV=4π(12.25)dr=49πdr.
- Substitute dr: dV=49π×28π0.016=2849×0.016.
- 2849=1.75, so dV=1.75×0.016=0.028.
Common Mistakes
- Computing r incorrectly from 4πr2=49π (forgetting to divide by 4π correctly, or taking the wrong square root).
- Forgetting that both dS and dV formulas share the same dr — trying to compute them independently instead of chaining through dr.
✓Final answerThe correct option is (D) — 0.028.
ANSWER: D
- AP EAPCET 2024Set eng-2024-05-22-AN1 markMCQQ.If a man of height 1.8 mt. is walking away from the foot of a light pole of height 6 mt. with a speed of 7 km per hour on a straight horizontal road opposite to the pole, then the rate of change of the length of his shadow is (in kmph) (A) 7 (B) 5 (C) 3 (D) 2
›Reveal solutionSolution
Similar triangles link shadow length to distance walked; the shadow grows at 3 kmph.
Concept and Intuition
The tip of the shadow, the top of the pole, and the top of the man's head are collinear (that's what casts the shadow). This gives a similar-triangles relationship between the man's distance from the pole and his shadow's length, which can be differentiated with respect to time (related rates).
Step-by-Step Solution
- Let x = distance of the man from the pole, s = length of his shadow. The tip of the shadow is at distance x+s from the pole.
- Similar triangles (pole-to-shadow-tip vs man-to-shadow-tip): x+spole height=sman height⇒x+s6=s1.8.
- Cross-multiply: 6s=1.8(x+s)=1.8x+1.8s⇒4.2s=1.8x⇒s=4.21.8x=73x.
- Differentiate w.r.t. time: dtds=73dtdx.
- Given dtdx=7 kmph: dtds=73(7)=3 kmph.
Common Mistakes
- Confusing the shadow's length s with the distance from the pole to the tip of the shadow (x+s) and differentiating the wrong quantity.
- Setting up the similar triangles with man-height and pole-height swapped.
✓Final answerThe correct option is (C) — 3.
ANSWER: C
🎓Unlock everything free for 14 days
- ✓Full step-by-step solutions
- ✓Concept-first explanations
- ✓Methods, shortcuts & mistakes
- ✓PYQ mapping + timed mock tests
Full access for 14 days. No credit card required.