Q.Women should be allowed to join the combat units of the army and go up to the highest position.
The stronger, equality-grounded position is yes: if a woman meets the same standards of fitness and skill required of any soldier, gender itself gives no legitimate ground to exclude her, including from the highest positions.
Equality of opportunity holds that every person, as a human being, is entitled to the same rights and opportunities to develop their skills and pursue their goals and ambitions. This principle applies just as much to career and profession as it does to education — it is not limited to any one sphere of life.
If a woman meets the objective requirements that any soldier must meet — the same fitness standards, the same training, the same demonstrated skill — excluding her purely because she is a woman is exactly the kind of group-based, birth-determined exclusion the chapter treats as unacceptable, in the same family as excluding someone on the basis of caste or race. It is not a legitimate differentiation based on actual ability.
Those who argue against this sometimes raise concerns about physical-strength requirements or unit cohesion. But the chapter's own framework offers a clear way to handle exactly this kind of concern: it distinguishes between real, relevant differences (which can justify differential treatment — for instance, physical test standards that are genuinely tied to the actual demands of a role) and excluding an entire group from even being considered for an opportunity. The equality-consistent response is to test actual capability on relevant, objective standards, not to bar an entire gender-defined group from applying, serving in combat, or rising to the highest ranks.
Yes, on the principle of equality of opportunity — since career opportunity should not be foreclosed to a whole group on the basis of gender, women who meet the same objective standards required of any soldier should be free to serve in combat roles and rise to the highest ranks, just as men can.
Unlock everything free for 14 days
- Full step-by-step solutions
- Concept-first explanations
- Methods, shortcuts & mistakes
- PYQ mapping + timed mock tests
Full access for 14 days. No credit card required.