Skip to content
Question 14 of 22

Q.Read the following extract carefully and answer the questions that follow : "There cannot be any divided loyalty" Govind Ballabh Pant argued that in order to become loyal citizens people had to stop focusing only on the community and the self : For the success of democracy one must train himself in the art of self-discipline. In democracies one should care less for himself and more for others. There cannot be any divided loyalty. All loyalties must exclusively be centred round the State. If in a democracy, you create rival loyalties, or you create a system in which any individual or group, instead of suppressing his extravagance, cares nought for larger or other interests, then democracy is doomed. (15.1) What are the major attributes of a loyal citizen ?

(2) (15.2) What should the citizens do for the success of democracy ?
(2) (15.3) What will happen to the State or democracy if the citizens have divided loyalties ? (3)
(OR)
Read the following extract carefully and answer the questions that follow : "I believe separate electorates will be suicidal to the minorities" During the debate on 27 August, 1947, Govind Ballabh Pant said : I believe separate electorates will be suicidal to the minorities and will do them tremendous harm. If they are isolated for ever, they can never convert themselves into a majority and the feeling of frustration will cripple them even from the very beginning. What is it that you desire and what is our ultimate objective ? Do the minorities always want to remain as minorities or do they ever expect to form an integral part of a great nation and as such to guide and control its destinies ? If they do, can they ever achieve that aspiration and that ideal if they are isolated from the rest of the community ? I think it would be extremely dangerous for them if they were segregated from the rest of the community and kept aloof in an air-tight compartment where they would have to rely on others even for the air they breathe ... The minorities if they are returned by separate electorates can never have any effective voice. (15.1) Why did some leaders think that there should be separate electorates for minorities ?
(2) (15.2) Why were some nationalists against the demand of separate electorates ?
(2) (15.3) Why did Govind Ballabh Pant consider separate electorates harmful for the minorities ? (3)
CBSECBSE Class XII Board 2019Subjective· 7mImportance★★★★★est
64% · 14/22 Questions
🔒 Locked · start free trial →

You're viewing a preview — the full solution, concept, methods & PYQ mapping are locked.

Start your 14-day free trial to unlock the full solution →

Part (a): a loyal citizen has self-discipline, cares for others and gives undivided loyalty to the State; democracy needs self-discipline and no rival loyalties; divided loyalties doom democracy.

Part (b): some wanted separate electorates to safeguard minorities; nationalists opposed them as a divisive colonial device; Pant held they would permanently isolate and cripple minorities.

Both passages come from Govind Ballabh Pant in the Constituent Assembly (the second dated 27 August 1947), during the debate on how the new nation should treat community identity and minority rights. Together they express the founders' central anxiety after Partition: how to build one nation without letting communal loyalties tear it apart.

(15.1) The attributes of a loyal citizen. Pant argues that citizenship in a democracy demands more than obedience. A loyal citizen must "train himself in the art of self-discipline", must "care less for himself and more for others", and above all must keep "all loyalties... exclusively centred round the State". The key attribute is undivided loyalty — the citizen does not place community, caste or self above the nation.

(15.2) What citizens must do for democracy to succeed. Democracy works only if citizens voluntarily restrain themselves. Pant asks each person to practise self-discipline, to suppress personal "extravagance" and selfishness, to consider the larger interest, and never to "create rival loyalties" that pull the nation in different directions. Trust and cooperation among citizens are what make democratic institutions function.

(15.3) The consequence of divided loyalties. Pant's warning is stark: if citizens create rival loyalties or care nothing for larger interests, "then democracy is doomed." Divided loyalties splinter the polity into competing groups, each pursuing only its own gain; the larger national interest is abandoned, and the State ceases to be the common centre of allegiance, losing its capacity to govern. His fear was rooted in the lived experience of Partition, caused partly by loyalties divided on religious lines.

Unlock everything free for 14 days

  • Full step-by-step solutions
  • Concept-first explanations
  • Methods, shortcuts & mistakes
  • PYQ mapping + timed mock tests

Full access for 14 days. No credit card required.