What measures do you think the government has taken, or should take, to protect the rights of landless agricul

Questions · Q2

Q. What measures do you think the government has taken, or should take, to protect the rights of landless agricultural labourers and migrant workers?

CBSENCERTSubjective· 3mImportance★★★★★

15% · 2/13 Questions

✓ Free question

Concept understanding — Social Justice Policies

Social Justice Policies: A First Look

Think about a race where some runners start ten metres behind the starting line while others start ten metres ahead. Even if everyone runs their hardest, the result is already skewed before the race begins. Social justice policies are the attempt to fix that starting line — not to guarantee everyone finishes first, but to make the race fair from the beginning.

The Core Idea

Social justice policies are government measures designed to correct historical and structural disadvantages that certain groups face. These policies do not treat everyone identically; instead, they give extra support to those who have been systematically held back, so that eventually everyone can compete on a level field.

The key distinction is between formal equality (treating everyone the same) and substantive equality (ensuring everyone has a fair chance to succeed). A policy that gives everyone a free textbook sounds equal, but if one group of students cannot read because their school never taught them, the textbook alone does not help. Social justice policies go deeper — they address the root causes of inequality.

Why Do We Need Them?

Inequality is rarely accidental. In many societies, certain communities have faced centuries of discrimination based on caste, class, gender, tribe, or region. This discrimination created gaps in education, wealth, health, and social status that do not disappear just because a law says "everyone is equal now." The effects of past injustice linger for generations.

For example, if a community was historically barred from owning land or attending school, their children and grandchildren start life with far fewer resources — less money, less education, fewer connections. A policy that simply says "everyone can now go to school" does not help a child whose parents cannot afford school fees or whose family needs them to work. Social justice policies recognise that equal treatment of unequals only perpetuates inequality.

Common Types of Social Justice Policies

Reservation or affirmative action: Setting aside a percentage of seats in education, government jobs, or legislatures for historically disadvantaged groups. This is the most direct form — it guarantees representation and access.
Targeted scholarships and financial aid: Providing extra funding for students from disadvantaged backgrounds, covering fees, books, or living expenses that would otherwise block their education.
Land reforms: Redistributing land to landless families, breaking up large estates that were built on exploitation.
Anti-discrimination laws: Making it illegal to deny someone a job, housing, or service based on their identity. These laws create a legal backstop against prejudice.
Special development programmes: Building schools, hospitals, and roads in regions that have been neglected for decades, rather than spreading resources evenly across all areas.

Important

Social justice policies are not about punishing one group to benefit another. They are about removing unfair advantages that were never earned and compensating for unfair disadvantages that were never deserved. The goal is a society where your birth does not determine your future.

The Tension: Merit vs. Justice

A common objection is that social justice policies violate "merit" — the idea that rewards should go to the most talented or hardest-working. This sounds reasonable until you ask: what makes someone "meritorious"? A child who grows up with private tutors, good nutrition, and a quiet study room has a huge head start over a child who works after school and studies by candlelight. Their "merit" is partly a product of privilege.

Social justice policies do not reject merit; they reject the assumption that the current playing field is already fair. By levelling the ground, they allow genuine merit — talent and effort — to shine through, rather than letting inherited advantage masquerade as personal achievement.

A Real-World Example (Without Numbers)

Imagine two villages. One has had a school for fifty years, a hospital, and paved roads. The other has none of these — it was deliberately starved of resources by past governments. A "neutral" policy that gives the same budget to both villages keeps the second village behind forever. A social justice policy gives more resources to the second village — extra teachers, a mobile health clinic, road construction — until the gap closes. Once both villages have adequate facilities, the special treatment ends.

This is not "reverse discrimination." It is corrective justice — fixing a broken system so that it finally works for everyone.

Note

Social justice policies are always temporary in principle. They exist only as long as the inequality they address exists. Once the gap is closed, the special measures should fade away. In practice, this is difficult because inequalities are stubborn, but the ideal remains: a society that no longer needs such policies.

The government has implemented measures like minimum wage laws, employment guarantees, and social security schemes, but further steps are needed to ensure universal social security, better enforcement, and portable benefits for landless agricultural labourers and migrant workers.

Landless agricultural labourers and migrant workers represent some of the most vulnerable segments of India's workforce. They often face precarious employment, low wages, lack of social security, and exploitation, exacerbated by their mobility and lack of bargaining power. Protecting their rights is crucial for achieving social justice and inclusive development. The government has taken several steps, and further measures are necessary to address their unique challenges comprehensively.

Measures Taken by the Government

The government has enacted various laws and introduced schemes aimed at improving the conditions of these workers:

Minimum Wages Act, 1948: This act mandates the payment of minimum wages to workers in scheduled employments, including agriculture. Its objective is to prevent exploitation by ensuring that workers receive a basic remuneration for their labour.
Mahatma Gandhi National Rural Employment Guarantee Act (MGNREGA), 2005: This landmark legislation guarantees 100 days of wage employment in a financial year to every rural household whose adult members volunteer to do unskilled manual work. It serves as a crucial safety net, particularly for landless agricultural labourers during lean seasons, providing income security and reducing distress migration.
Social Security Schemes: Various schemes have been launched to provide a safety net. These include:
- Pradhan Mantri Shram Yogi Maan-dhan Yojana (PMSYMY): A voluntary and contributory pension scheme for unorganised workers, including agricultural labourers, ensuring old age protection.
- Ayushman Bharat Pradhan Mantri Jan Arogya Yojana (PMJAY): Provides health insurance coverage, offering financial protection against catastrophic health expenditures.
- Building and Other Construction Workers (Regulation of Employment and Conditions of Service) Act, 1996: While primarily for construction workers, many migrant labourers fall under this category, and the welfare boards established under this act provide various benefits like accident insurance, education assistance, and maternity benefits.
One Nation One Ration Card (ONORC) Scheme: This initiative allows beneficiaries, especially migrant workers, to claim their entitlement to subsidised food grains from any Fair Price Shop (FPS) in the country, irrespective of their original ration card location. This addresses a significant challenge faced by migrants in accessing food security.
Labour Codes: The government has consolidated and rationalised various labour laws into four codes: the Code on Wages, the Code on Social Security, the Occupational Safety, Health and Working Conditions Code, and the Industrial Relations Code. These codes aim to provide universal minimum wages, expand social security coverage to all workers (including unorganised and gig workers), and improve working conditions, which are intended to benefit landless agricultural labourers and migrant workers significantly. The Occupational Safety, Health and Working Conditions Code, for instance, specifically addresses inter-state migrant workers, aiming to improve their working conditions and provide certain benefits.

Note

While the Inter-State Migrant Workmen (Regulation of Employment and Conditions of Service) Act, 1979, existed to protect migrant workers, it faced challenges in implementation and was eventually subsumed into the Occupational Safety, Health and Working Conditions Code, 2020, with the aim of providing broader and more effective protection.

Measures That Should Be Taken

Despite existing efforts, significant gaps remain. The following measures should be considered to further protect the rights of these vulnerable groups:

Strengthening Enforcement and Monitoring: The effective implementation of existing laws, particularly the Minimum Wages Act and the provisions for migrant workers under the new Labour Codes, is paramount. This requires robust labour inspection mechanisms, swift grievance redressal, and strict penalties for non-compliance by employers.
Universal and Portable Social Security:
- Expand Coverage: Ensure that all landless agricultural labourers and migrant workers are covered under comprehensive social security schemes, including health insurance, life insurance, and old-age pensions, without complex eligibility criteria or bureaucratic hurdles.
- Portability: Design schemes such that benefits are easily portable across states and different employment sectors, allowing workers to access entitlements regardless of their location or employment changes.
Registration and Data Collection: Establish a comprehensive national database of unorganised workers, including landless agricultural labourers and migrant workers. This would enable better policy formulation, targeted delivery of benefits, and real-time monitoring of their working and living conditions.
Access to Land and Credit:
- Land Reforms: Explore innovative approaches to land redistribution or cooperative farming models to provide landless families with access to productive assets.
- Institutional Credit: Facilitate easy access to institutional credit at reasonable interest rates, reducing their dependence on informal moneylenders and enabling them to invest in small-scale enterprises or improve agricultural practices.
Skill Development and Diversification: Provide vocational training and skill development programs tailored to the needs of landless labourers, enabling them to diversify into non-agricultural sectors or enhance their productivity in agriculture, thereby increasing their earning potential and reducing vulnerability.
Affordable Housing and Basic Amenities: At destination sites, governments should ensure access to affordable and dignified housing, sanitation facilities, clean drinking water, and healthcare services for migrant workers. This can be achieved through public housing projects or by mandating employers to provide such facilities.
Awareness and Legal Aid: Conduct extensive awareness campaigns to educate workers about their rights, available schemes, and legal recourse. Provide accessible and free legal aid services to help them address issues like wage theft, exploitation, and unsafe working conditions.
Inter-State Coordination: Enhance coordination between source and destination states to ensure seamless transfer of benefits, address grievances, and protect migrant workers from exploitation during recruitment and employment.

Important

The core challenge often lies not just in the absence of laws, but in their effective implementation and ensuring that the most vulnerable workers are aware of and can access their rights and benefits.

✓Final answer

In short, while the government has established a framework of laws and schemes like minimum wages, employment guarantees, and social security, future efforts must focus on strengthening enforcement, ensuring universal and portable social security, improving data collection, and providing better access to land, credit, and essential services for landless agricultural labourers and migrant workers.

Same / Similar Concept — real previous-year questions on the same or a closely similar concept, not this exact question.

CBSE 2024Set 62/RQPS/41 markMCQ
$Q. Which of the following features is incorrect for alienation ? (A) People do not enjoy their work. (B) Work is repetitive and exhausting. (C) People see the end result of their work. (D) Survival depends on whether technology has room for any human labour.$
›Reveal solutionSolution

Alienation, as described by Karl Marx, means workers are disconnected from the product, process, and purpose of their labour — so the incorrect feature is (C), because alienated workers do not see the end result of their work.

To understand why (C) is the odd one out, you need to step into the world of industrial capitalism as Marx saw it. Before factories, a cobbler made an entire shoe from start to finish. He chose the leather, cut it, stitched it, and handed the finished shoe to a customer he knew. He saw his work through from beginning to end, and that gave him a sense of pride and purpose.

Now picture a worker on a 19th-century assembly line. Her job is to tighten bolt number seven on a car door, eight hours a day, every day. She never sees the finished car. She never meets the buyer. She does not decide how fast the line moves or what the car looks like. That is alienation in a nutshell.

Marx identified four dimensions of alienation. First, the worker is alienated from the product of her labour — the thing she makes belongs to the capitalist, not to her. Second, she is alienated from the process of work itself — the work is not her own creative activity but a forced, monotonous routine. Third, she is alienated from her species-being — her human capacity for free, conscious creation is crushed by repetitive drudgery. Fourth, she is alienated from other human beings — competition replaces cooperation, and the capitalist stands as an enemy.

Note

Marx did not just mean that work feels boring. He meant that under capitalism, labour becomes a commodity like any other, bought and sold on a market. The worker sells her time and energy, and in doing so loses control over what she produces and how she produces it.

Now look at the four options through this lens.

Option (A) — "People do not enjoy their work" — is spot on. Alienated labour is forced labour, not a free expression of human creativity. The worker works only to survive, not because the work itself is fulfilling.

Option (B) — "Work is repetitive and exhausting" — is equally correct. The division of labour in a factory reduces complex tasks to simple, mind-numbing motions repeated thousands of times a day. This is the very engine of alienation.

Option (D) — "Survival depends on whether technology has room for any human labour" — captures a later, more anxious dimension of alienation. As machines replace human hands, the worker becomes disposable. Her survival hinges on whether the capitalist still needs her to operate the machines. This is the fear of technological unemployment, which Marx saw as an intensification of alienation.

Option (C) — "People see the end result of their work" — is the one that breaks the pattern. In an alienated system, the worker does not see the end result. The product is whisked away, sold in a distant market, and consumed by strangers. The worker is a tiny, interchangeable cog in a vast machine; she never holds the finished thing in her hands and says, "I made this."

Important

The core of alienation is disconnection — from the product, from the process, from oneself, and from others. Seeing the end result would mean reconnection, which is the opposite of alienation.

So the incorrect feature is (C). It describes a pre-industrial or craft-based relationship to work, not the alienated labour of industrial capitalism.

✓Final answer
$In short, the incorrect feature for alienation is (C) — "People see the end result of their work" — because alienation precisely means workers are cut off from the finished product of their labour.$

←Previous questionQ1 — Read the passage given and answer the questions: i. Why do you think t…→Next questionQ3 — There are direct linkages between the situation of agricultural worker…

Q.What measures do you think the government has taken, or should take, to protect the rights of landless agricultural labourers and migrant workers?

Measures Taken by the Government

Measures That Should Be Taken

🎓Unlock everything free for 14 days

Unlock everything free for 14 days