Skip to content
Question

Q.Read the given passage and answer the questions that follow: The substitution reaction of alkyl halide mainly occurs by SN1 or SN2 mechanism. Whatever mechanism alkyl halides follow for the substitution reaction to occur, the polarity of the carbon halogen bond is responsible for these substitution reactions. The rate of SN1 reactions are governed by the stability of carbocation whereas for SN2 reactions steric factor is the deciding factor. If the starting material is a chiral compound, we may end up with an inverted product or racemic mixture depending upon the type of mechanism followed by alkyl halide. Cleavage of ethers with HI is also governed by steric factor and stability of carbocation, which indicates that in organic chemistry, these two major factors help us in deciding the kind of product formed. Predict the stereochemistry of the product formed if an optically active alkyl halide undergoes substitution reaction by SN1 mechanism.

CBSECBSE Class XII Board 2020Subjective· 1mImportance★★★★★
✓ Free question

An optically active alkyl halide undergoing SN1 substitution gives a racemic mixture as product because the planar carbocation intermediate allows nucleophilic attack from either face with equal probability.

The key to predicting stereochemistry in any substitution reaction lies in understanding the mechanism's intermediate. For SN1, the rate-determining step produces a carbocation — and that carbocation is planar (sp² hybridised). This flat geometry is the entire story behind the stereochemical outcome.

Let’s walk through why.

  1. The SN1 mechanism has two distinct steps. First, the leaving group departs, creating a carbocation. This step is slow and rate-determining. Second, the nucleophile attacks this carbocation in a fast step. Because the carbocation forms before the nucleophile arrives, the nucleophile has no "memory" of which side the leaving group was on.

  2. The carbocation intermediate is planar. A carbocation has three bonds arranged in a trigonal planar geometry (bond angles ~120°). The empty p orbital sticks out perpendicular to this plane. This means the carbocation is achiral at that carbon — it has no "handedness" left.

  3. Nucleophilic attack can occur from either face. The nucleophile can approach the planar carbocation from above the plane or below it with equal ease. There is no steric or electronic bias (assuming the nucleophile is not itself chiral or the solvent is not chiral). So roughly half the attacks happen from one side, half from the other.

  4. The result: a racemic mixture. If the starting alkyl halide was optically active (say, pure R enantiomer), the product will be a 50:50 mixture of R and S enantiomers. This mixture is racemic and therefore optically inactive.

Watch out

A common mistake is to think SN1 gives complete inversion or complete retention. It does not. The planar intermediate guarantees equal attack from both sides, so you always get racemisation — unless special circumstances (like a neighbouring group participating) block one face.

Tip

Compare with SN2: there, the nucleophile attacks as the leaving group departs (backside attack), forcing inversion of configuration. So SN2 gives complete inversion, while SN1 gives complete racemisation. This contrast is a favourite exam question.

✓Final answer

The product is a racemic mixture (50:50 mixture of enantiomers), so the optically active starting material loses its optical activity.

Unlock everything free for 14 days

  • Full step-by-step solutions
  • Concept-first explanations
  • Methods, shortcuts & mistakes
  • PYQ mapping + timed mock tests

Full access for 14 days. No credit card required.