Q.Assertion (A): The function defined by is not one-one function in its domain.
Reason (R): The line meets the graph of the function at more than one point.
The key idea is that a function is one-one (injective) only if every horizontal line cuts its graph at most once. Since is periodic and symmetric, the horizontal line meets the graph at infinitely many points, proving the function is not one-one. Assertion (A) is true, Reason (R) is true, and (R) correctly explains (A).
Concept first: What does "one-one" really mean?
A function is one-one (injective) if different inputs always give different outputs. Graphically, this is the horizontal line test: no horizontal line should intersect the graph more than once. If even one horizontal line hits the graph at two or more distinct -values, the function fails to be one-one.
Now, . Its domain excludes points where , i.e., . The range given is , which matches the actual range of secant. The function is periodic with period , and within each period it is symmetric about vertical asymptotes.
Why does matter?
The line is a horizontal line inside the range (since ). If we can show it meets the graph at more than one , the function is not one-one. Let's check.
- Solve . . The general solution for is:
-
Check if these values lie in the domain.
The domain excludes . Are any of our solutions equal to an odd multiple of ?
is not an odd multiple of , and never equals for integer (since is not a rational multiple of in that sense). So all these values are in the domain.
-
Count distinct values for .
For : and (two points).
For : and (two more).
In fact, there are infinitely many such because can be any integer. So the horizontal line cuts the graph at infinitely many points.
A common mistake is to think that because is not one-one on its whole domain, the Reason must be false. But the Reason gives a specific horizontal line () that works. It doesn't need to mention all lines — one counterexample is enough to prove non-injectivity.
- Connect Assertion and Reason. Assertion (A) says is not one-one. Reason (R) says the line meets the graph at more than one point. Since this violates the horizontal line test, (R) is a correct explanation of (A). Both are true.
For periodic trigonometric functions like , any horizontal line with will intersect the graph infinitely many times (except possibly at asymptotes). So the function is never one-one on its full domain. The given domain excludes asymptotes but still leaves infinitely many periods.
Both Assertion (A) and Reason (R) are true, and (R) is the correct explanation of (A).
Unlock everything free for 14 days
- Full step-by-step solutions
- Concept-first explanations
- Methods, shortcuts & mistakes
- PYQ mapping + timed mock tests
Full access for 14 days. No credit card required.