Q.A water tank has the shape of an inverted right circular cone with its axis vertical and vertex lowermost. Its semi-vertical angle is tan−1(0.5). Water is poured into it at a constant rate of 5 cubic metre per hour. Find the rate at which the level of the water is rising at the instant when the depth of water in the tank is 4 m.
Concept understanding — Related Rates
Related Rates
The idea: quantities that change together
Many real situations involve two or more quantities that all vary with time, linked by a fixed relationship. Inflate a balloon and its radius and volume both grow; slide a ladder down a wall and the top's height and the foot's distance both change. A related-rates problem gives you the rate at which one quantity is changing and asks for the rate of another, at some instant.
The key insight: if the quantities are tied together by an equation, then their rates are tied together too. We uncover that link by differentiating the equation with respect to time t.
The core mechanism: differentiate with respect to time
Every variable is a function of t, so differentiating brings in the chain rule — each variable's derivative picks up a factor of its own rate. For example, if the volume of a sphere is V=34πr3, then differentiating both sides with respect to t gives
dtdV=4πr2dtdr.
This single equation connects the rate the volume grows, dtdV, to the rate the radius grows, dtdr. Knowing one (and the current r) gives the other.
The standard procedure
Solving a related-rates problem
- Identify the quantities that change with time and the rate you want.
- Write an equation relating those quantities (geometry, a formula, etc.).
- Differentiate both sides with respect to t, treating every variable as a function of t.
- Substitute the known values and the known rate at the given instant.
- Solve for the unknown rate.
Worked example
Air is pumped into a spherical balloon at dtdV=100 cm3/s. How fast is the radius increasing when r=5 cm?
From dtdV=4πr2dtdr, substitute dtdV=100 and r=5:
100=4π(5)2dtdr=100πdtdr⟹dtdr=π1 cm/s.
Substitute the numerical values after differentiating, never before. If you plug r=5 into the volume formula first, r becomes a constant and its rate dtdr vanishes from the equation.
The everyday cases are the sphere/circle (V,A vs. r), the sliding ladder (x2+y2=ℓ2), and the filling cone. In each you differentiate the relation in t and solve for the missing rate.
Related rates problems are a named application within the NCERT Class 12 Application of Derivatives chapter, and classic setups like the growing balloon or the sliding ladder are staples of CBSE board and JEE Main 'rate of change' questions. Students searching 'related rates problems class 12 examples' or 'rate of change of volume and radius' will find this differentiate-then-substitute method is exactly the five-step procedure boards expect to see written out.
The key idea is Related Rates: we connect dtdV (given) to dtdh (required) using the geometry of the cone.
Step 1: Relate radius and height.
Semi-vertical angle α satisfies tanα=0.5=hr, so r=2h.
Step 2: Express volume in terms of h alone.
Volume of a cone: V=31πr2h=31π(2h)2h=12πh3.
Step 3: Differentiate with respect to time t.
dtdV=12π⋅3h2dtdh=4πh2dtdh.
Step 4: Substitute known values.
Given dtdV=5 m³/h and h=4 m:
5=4π(4)2dtdh=4πdtdh.
Thus dtdh=4π5 m/h.
The water level is rising at 4π5 metres per hour.
The key idea is to relate the volume of water in the cone to its depth using the geometry of the cone, then differentiate with respect to time. The rate at which the water level rises when the depth is 4 m is 4π5 m/h.
This is a classic related rates problem. The core idea is simple: we know how fast the volume is changing (dV/dt=5 m³/h), and we want to find how fast the depth is changing (dh/dt) at a specific moment. The bridge between these two rates is the geometric relationship between volume and depth for a cone.
The trick is that as water fills the cone, both the depth h and the radius r of the water's surface change together. But they aren't independent — the cone's fixed shape ties them together through the semi-vertical angle.
- Set up the geometry. The cone has a semi-vertical angle α where tanα=0.5. From the figure, tanα=r/h, so:
hr=0.5⇒r=2h
This is the crucial relation — at any depth h, the radius of the water surface is exactly half of h.
- Write the volume in terms of h only. The volume of a cone is V=31πr2h. Substitute r=h/2:
V=31π(2h)2h=31π⋅4h2⋅h=12πh3
V=12πh3
This expresses the volume of water entirely in terms of its depth — no separate r needed.
- Differentiate with respect to time. Both V and h are functions of time t. Differentiate both sides:
dtdV=12π⋅3h2⋅dtdh=4πh2⋅dtdh
- Plug in the known values. We are given dtdV=5 m³/h (constant), and we want dtdh when h=4 m:
5=4π(4)2⋅dtdh=4π⋅16⋅dtdh=4π⋅dtdh
- Solve for the rate.
dtdh=4π5 m/h
A common mistake is to treat r as constant when differentiating V=31πr2h. But r changes with h! Always eliminate r (or h) using the cone's geometry before differentiating — otherwise you'll need the product rule and an extra relation.
Notice that the answer doesn't depend on the cone's full size — only on its shape (the semi-vertical angle). The rate 4π5 is about 0.398 m/h, which makes sense: a wide, shallow cone (tan α = 0.5 means the radius grows slowly with depth) would have the water level rise relatively fast for a given inflow.
The rate at which the water level is rising when the depth is 4 m is 4π5 m/h.
Method: Related Rates for a Filling/Draining Container
The general five-step procedure for connecting a known rate to an unknown rate when two changing quantities are tied by a fixed geometric relationship.
Steps
Step 1: Identify the two rates and the fixed relationship
Here the given rate is dtdV and the required rate is dtdh. The container's shape (a cone with a fixed semi-vertical angle) links the radius r and height h of the water surface at every instant, since tan(semi-vertical angle)=hr.
Step 2: Eliminate the extra variable using the geometry, before differentiating
A volume formula for a cone naturally involves two variables, r and h. Use the fixed-angle relation to express r in terms of h (or vice versa) and substitute, so the volume becomes a function of a single variable:
V=31πr2h⟶V=V(h) only
Step 3: Differentiate both sides with respect to time
Apply the chain rule, since both V and h are functions of t:
dtdV=dhd[V(h)]⋅dtdh
Step 4: Substitute the given numerical values and solve
Plug in the known dtdV and the specific depth h at the instant asked about — only after differentiating, never before — then solve algebraically for the unknown rate.
Common Mistakes
Mistake 1: Differentiating V=31πr2h while treating r as constant
Why it's wrong: as water fills the cone, the radius of the water's surface changes together with the depth — it is not a fixed number, so it cannot be dropped from the differentiation. Differentiating with r held constant would produce an equation missing the crucial link between dtdh and the cone's geometry. Correct approach: use the semi-vertical angle to write r in terms of h (here r=h/2) and substitute into the volume formula before differentiating, so the volume is a function of h alone.
Mistake 2: Substituting the numerical depth before differentiating
Why it's wrong: plugging in h=4 into the volume formula first turns h into a constant, so the derivative with respect to time becomes dtdV=0 — losing the very relationship the problem needs. Correct approach: differentiate the general relation between V and h symbolically first, and only substitute the specific numbers (h=4, dtdV=5) into the resulting rate equation afterward.
Showing the 12 most recent of 17 on this concept.
- COMEDK 2025Set 2025-M1 markMCQQ.Oil from a conical funnel is dripping at the rate of 5 cm3/s. If the radius and height of the funnel are 10 cm and 20 cm respectively, then the rate at which the oil level drops when it is 5 cm from the top is (A) 45π8 cm/s (B) −452π cm/s (C) −454π cm/s (D) −45π4 cm/s
›Reveal solutionSolution
The rate at which the oil level drops is found by relating the volume of a cone to its height using similar triangles, then differentiating with respect to time. The answer is −45π4 cm/s, which corresponds to option (D).
Concept & Intuition
This is a classic related rates problem. Oil is draining from a conical funnel, so the volume is decreasing at a known rate (dV/dt=−5 cm³/s). We want the rate at which the height of the oil changes (dh/dt) when the oil is at a particular depth. The key twist: as the oil level drops, the radius of the oil's surface also shrinks, because the funnel is conical. The radius and height of the oil are not independent — they are linked by the geometry of the cone (similar triangles). So we first express volume purely in terms of height, then differentiate.
Step-by-step solution
- Set up the geometry. The funnel is a right circular cone with radius R=10 cm and height H=20 cm. At any moment, the oil forms a smaller cone of height h (measured from the tip) and radius r. By similar triangles:
hr=HR=2010=21
So r=2h.
- Write the volume of oil in terms of h. Volume of a cone: V=31πr2h. Substitute r=h/2:
V=31π(2h)2h=31π⋅4h2⋅h=12πh3
- Differentiate with respect to time t. Using the chain rule:
dtdV=12π⋅3h2⋅dtdh=4πh2dtdh
- Plug in known values. We are told the oil is dripping out at 5 cm³/s, so dV/dt=−5 (negative because volume is decreasing). The oil is 5 cm from the top of the funnel. Since the funnel is 20 cm tall, the oil height from the tip is h=20−5=15 cm. Substitute:
−5=4π(15)2dtdh
−5=4π⋅225⋅dtdh
−5=4225πdtdh
- Solve for dh/dt.
dtdh=−5⋅225π4=−225π20=−45π4
The negative sign confirms the oil level is dropping.
Watch outA common mistake is to use the full funnel's radius and height directly in the volume formula, forgetting that the oil's radius changes with height. Always use similar triangles to relate r and h for the current oil cone.
TipNotice that the rate dh/dt is not constant — it depends on h. That’s why we needed the specific height (15 cm) to get a numerical answer.
✓Final answerThe correct option is (D).
ANSWER: D
- COMEDK 2026Set 2026-A1 markMCQQ.An open hemispherical storage tank has radius 13 m . Oil flows into the tank such that the depth ' h ' of oil in the tank changes at the rate of 3 m/hr. When the depth h=1 m, the rate of change of the area of the top surface of the oil is (A) 72π m2/hr (B) 75π m2/hr (C) 24π m2/hr (D) 26π m2/hr
›Reveal solutionSolution
The oil surface is a circle of radius r with r2=2Rh−h2 for a bowl of radius R. So area A=π(2Rh−h2) and dtdA=π(2R−2h)dtdh. At R=13, h=1, dtdh=3 this is 72π m2/hr — option (A).
Concept & Intuition
In a hemispherical bowl of radius R, the free surface at oil depth h (measured from the lowest point) is a horizontal circle. Its radius r comes from the sphere geometry: the surface is a distance R−h from the centre, so r2=R2−(R−h)2=2Rh−h2. Differentiate the surface area with respect to time and use the given dtdh.
Step-by-step solution
- Radius of the top circle at depth h:
r2=R2−(R−h)2=2Rh−h2.
- Area of the top surface:
A=πr2=π(2Rh−h2).
- Differentiate with respect to time:
dtdA=π(2R−2h)dtdh.
- Substitute R=13, h=1, dtdh=3:
dtdA=π(2⋅13−2⋅1)(3)=π(26−2)(3)=π(24)(3)=72π.
✓Final answerdtdA=72π m2/hr — option (A).
ANSWER: A
- COMEDK 2023Set 2023-E1 markMCQQ.The altitude of a cone is 20 cm and its semi vertical angle is 30∘. If the semi vertical angle is increasing at the rate of 20 per second, then the radius of the base is increasing at the rate of (A) 160 cm/sec (B) 10 cm/sec (C) 3160 cm/sec (D) 30 cm/sec
›Reveal solutionSolution
(Note on units: the paper quotes the angular rate as '2 degrees per second' but the options are only consistent with treating that rate as 2 in the same angular unit used for the derivative - i.e. the option set is built on dr/dt = h sec^2 a * 2 = 160/3. Converting 2 degrees to radians would give 20*(4/3)*(pi/90) ~ 0.93 cm/s, which matches none of the four options. The intended and only available answer is 160/3 cm/sec.)
Concept: related rates on a cone. With altitude h fixed and semi-vertical angle alpha varying, r = h tan alpha, so dr/dt = h sec^2(alpha) * d(alpha)/dt.
Given h = 20 cm, alpha = 30 degrees, d(alpha)/dt = 2 per second.
sec^2(30) = 1/cos^2(30) = 1/(3/4) = 4/3.
dr/dt = 20 * (4/3) * 2 = 160/3 cm/sec.
(Note on units: the paper quotes the angular rate as '2 degrees per second' but the options are only consistent with treating that rate as 2 in the same angular unit used for the derivative - i.e. the option set is built on dr/dt = h sec^2 a * 2 = 160/3. Converting 2 degrees to radians would give 20*(4/3)*(pi/90) ~ 0.93 cm/s, which matches none of the four options. The intended and only available answer is 160/3 cm/sec.)
✓Final answerThe correct option is (C) — 3160 cm/sec
ANSWER: C
- COMEDK 2025Set 2025-E1 markMCQQ.A man is moving away from a tower 41.6 m high at a rate of 2 m/s. If the eyelevel of the man is 1.6 m above the ground, then the rate at which the angle of elevation of the top of the tower changes, when he is at a distance of 30 m from the foot of the tower is : (A) −1254rad/sec (B) 6254rad/sec (C) −1252rad/sec (D) 6251rad/sec
›Reveal solutionSolution
The angle of elevation decreases as the man moves away; using related rates and the tangent function, the rate is found to be −1254 rad/s, so the correct option is (A).
We have a tower of height 41.6 m, and the man’s eye level is 1.6 m above ground. So the effective height of the tower above the man’s eye level is 41.6−1.6=40 m. The man moves away from the tower at 2 m/s. We need the rate of change of the angle of elevation θ when his horizontal distance from the foot is 30 m.
Concept and intuition:
The angle of elevation θ satisfies tanθ=adjacentopposite=x40, where x is the horizontal distance from the man to the tower. As x increases, θ decreases, so we expect a negative rate. Differentiating with respect to time gives a relation between dtdθ and dtdx. This is a classic related-rates problem: we know dtdx=2 m/s, and we want dtdθ at x=30.
Step-by-step solution:
- Set up the relationship. Let x be the distance from the man to the foot of the tower. The effective height above eye level is H=40 m. Then
tanθ=x40.
- Differentiate implicitly with respect to time t. Using the chain rule:
sec2θ⋅dtdθ=−x240⋅dtdx.
Here dtdx=2 m/s (positive because distance increases).
- Find sec2θ at the given instant. When x=30 m,
tanθ=3040=34.
Recall sec2θ=1+tan2θ=1+(34)2=1+916=925.
- Substitute into the differentiated equation.
925⋅dtdθ=−(30)240⋅2.
Compute the right side:
−90040⋅2=−90080=−908=−454.
- Solve for dtdθ.
dtdθ=−454⋅259=−112536=−1254.
The negative sign confirms the angle is decreasing.
Watch outA common mistake is forgetting to subtract the man’s eye level from the tower height, or using the full 41.6 m directly. Always check the vertical difference from eye level to the top.
TipNotice that 1254=0.032 rad/s — a small rate, which makes sense because the angle changes slowly when the man is far away.
✓Final answerThe correct option is (A).
ANSWER: A
- COMEDK 2025Set 2025-M1 markMCQQ.A spherical snowball is melting such that its volume is decreasing at the rate of 1 cm3/min. The rate at which the diameter is decreasing when the diameter is 10 cm is (A) 75π11 cm/min (B) 50π1 cm/min (C) 75π2 cm/min (D) 25π1 cm/min
›Reveal solutionSolution
We relate the rate of change of volume to the rate of change of diameter using the formula for the volume of a sphere and implicit differentiation. The diameter decreases at 50π1 cm/min when the diameter is 10 cm, so the correct option is (B).
Concept and intuition:
This is a classic related rates problem. The snowball’s volume shrinks at a known constant rate, and we want how fast its diameter shrinks at a particular instant. The key is to connect volume V and diameter D through the sphere’s volume formula, then differentiate both sides with respect to time t. Because we know dtdV and want dtdD, we just substitute the given diameter and solve.
Step-by-step solution:
- Write the volume in terms of diameter. The volume of a sphere of radius r is V=34πr3. Since the diameter D=2r, we have r=D/2. Substituting:
V=34π(2D)3=34π⋅8D3=6πD3.
This expresses V directly as a function of D, which is convenient because we want dtdD.
- Differentiate with respect to time t. Both V and D depend on t, so we use implicit differentiation:
dtdV=6π⋅3D2⋅dtdD=2πD2dtdD.
- Plug in known values. We are told dtdV=−1 cm³/min (negative because volume is decreasing). At the instant of interest, D=10 cm. Substitute:
−1=2π(10)2⋅dtdD=2π⋅100⋅dtdD=50π⋅dtdD.
- Solve for dtdD.
dtdD=50π−1 cm/min.
The negative sign confirms the diameter is decreasing. The question asks for the rate at which it is decreasing, so we report the magnitude: 50π1 cm/min.
TipA common mistake is to use the radius instead of the diameter in the formula, or to forget the factor of 2 when converting between dr/dt and dD/dt. Writing V directly in terms of D avoids that pitfall entirely.
Watch outDo not forget the negative sign when interpreting the rate. The problem asks for “the rate at which the diameter is decreasing” — that is the absolute value of dtdD, so it is positive.
✓Final answerThe correct option is (B).
ANSWER: B
- COMEDK 2023Set 2023-E1 markMCQQ.If the volume of a sphere is increasing at a constant rate, then the rate at which its radius is increasing is (A) inversely proportional to its surface area (B) proportional to the radius (C) a constant (D) inversely proportional to the radius
›Reveal solutionSolution
i.e. the rate of increase of the radius is inversely proportional to the surface area (equivalently, inversely proportional to r^2 - NOT simply inversely proportional to r, so (D) is wrong).
Concept: related rates for a sphere.
V = (4/3) pi r^3
dV/dt = 4 pi r^2 * dr/dt
Given dV/dt = k (a constant), so
dr/dt = k / (4 pi r^2).
But 4 pi r^2 is exactly the surface area S of the sphere. Therefore
dr/dt = k / S,
i.e. the rate of increase of the radius is inversely proportional to the surface area (equivalently, inversely proportional to r^2 - NOT simply inversely proportional to r, so (D) is wrong).
✓Final answerThe correct option is (A) — inversely proportional to its surface area
ANSWER: A
- COMEDK 2025Set 2025-E1 markMCQQ.If the length of the diagonal of a square is increasing at the rate of 0.1 cm/sec. What is the rate of increase of its area when the side is 215 cm ? (A) 3 cm2/sec (B) 0.15 cm2/sec (C) 1.5 cm2/sec (D) 32 cm2/sec
›Reveal solutionSolution
The key idea is to relate the side length and diagonal of a square, then use the chain rule to connect the rates of change of the diagonal and the area. The area increases at 1.5cm2/sec when the side is 215 cm, so the correct option is (C).
We are told the diagonal of a square is increasing at a constant rate of 0.1cm/s. We need the rate of increase of the area when the side length is 215cm. The natural approach is to express the area in terms of the diagonal, then differentiate with respect to time.
Concept and intuition:
For a square, the diagonal d and side s are related by d=s2. The area A=s2. If we know how fast d changes, we can find how fast s changes, and then how fast A changes. Alternatively, we can directly relate A to d: since s=d/2, then A=(d/2)2=d2/2. Differentiating this gives dA/dt=d⋅(dd/dt). This is simpler because we don't need to find ds/dt separately.
Let's work through step by step.
- Relate area to diagonal. For a square with side s, diagonal d=s2 and area A=s2. Substituting s=d/2 gives:
A=(2d)2=2d2.
- Differentiate with respect to time. Using the chain rule:
dtdA=dtd(2d2)=21⋅2d⋅dtdd=d⋅dtdd.
We are given dtdd=0.1cm/s.
- Find the diagonal when the side is 215 cm. Since d=s2,
d=215⋅2=15cm.
- Plug into the rate equation.
dtdA=15×0.1=1.5cm2/sec.
TipNotice we never needed to compute ds/dt explicitly. By expressing area directly in terms of the diagonal, we saved a step and reduced the chance of algebraic error.
Watch outA common mistake is to forget that the diagonal and side are not independent — students sometimes try to differentiate A=s2 without first relating s to d, leading to confusion about which rate is given.
Thus, the rate of increase of the area is 1.5cm2/sec.
✓Final answerThe correct option is (C).
ANSWER: C
- COMEDK 2026Set 2026-M1 markMCQQ.If 3 cm/s is the rate at which the side of an equilateral triangle increases, then the rate of change of area, when the side is 12 cm is: (A) 93 cm2/s (B) 18 cm2/s (C) 63 cm2/s (D) 183 cm2/s
›Reveal solutionSolution
The area of an equilateral triangle depends on its side length; by differentiating the area formula with respect to time, we find the rate of change of area when the side is 12 cm is 183cm2/s, which corresponds to option (D).
We are told the side length s of an equilateral triangle increases at a constant rate: dtds=3 cm/s. We need the rate of change of the area A when s=12 cm. The key idea is to relate A to s using geometry, then differentiate with respect to time t using the chain rule — this turns a static formula into a dynamic relationship.
- Area of an equilateral triangle in terms of its side For an equilateral triangle of side s, the height is 23s (by splitting it into two 30-60-90 right triangles). The area is
A=21⋅base⋅height=21⋅s⋅23s=43s2.
- Differentiate with respect to time Both A and s are functions of time t. Using the chain rule:
dtdA=dtd(43s2)=43⋅2s⋅dtds=23s⋅dtds.
- Substitute the given values We have dtds=3 cm/s and s=12 cm at the moment of interest.
dtdA=23⋅12⋅3=23⋅36=183cm2/s.
TipNotice that the factor 23s is exactly the height of the triangle. So the rate of change of area is simply (height) × (rate of change of side). This geometric shortcut can save time in similar problems.
Watch outA common mistake is forgetting the factor 43 or misapplying the chain rule — for example, writing dtdA=23s without multiplying by dtds. Always check that you’ve differentiated with respect to t, not s.
✓Final answerThe correct option is (D).
ANSWER: D
- COMEDK 2025Set 2025-A1 markMCQQ.x=a(θ+sinθ) and y=a(1−cosθ) represents the equation of a curve. If θ changes at a constant rate k then the rate of change of the slope of the tangent to the curve at θ=3π is (A) 2k (B) 3k (C) 32k (D) 32k
›Reveal solutionSolution
The problem asks for the rate of change of the slope of the tangent, not the slope itself. We find dxdy in terms of θ, then differentiate with respect to time using the chain rule, using dtdθ=k. At θ=3π, the result simplifies to 32k, so the correct option is (D).
We are given a cycloid-like parametric curve:
x=a(θ+sinθ), y=a(1−cosθ), with θ increasing at constant rate k, i.e. dtdθ=k.
The slope of the tangent is dxdy. But the question asks for the rate of change of that slope with respect to time — that is dtd(dxdy). This is a classic related-rates problem in parametric form.
1. Find the slope in terms of θ
First compute derivatives with respect to θ:
dθdx=a(1+cosθ),dθdy=asinθ
Then the slope is:
dxdy=dx/dθdy/dθ=a(1+cosθ)asinθ=1+cosθsinθ
Using the identity sinθ=2sin(θ/2)cos(θ/2) and 1+cosθ=2cos2(θ/2), this simplifies to:
dxdy=2cos2(θ/2)2sin(θ/2)cos(θ/2)=tan2θ
So the slope at any θ is simply tan(θ/2).
2. Differentiate the slope with respect to time
We want dtd(dxdy)=dtd(tan2θ).
By the chain rule:
dtd(tan2θ)=sec2(2θ)⋅21⋅dtdθ
Given dtdθ=k, we have:
dtd(dxdy)=2ksec2(2θ)
3. Evaluate at θ=3π
Here 2θ=6π. We know sec(π/6)=32, so sec2(π/6)=34.
Thus:
dtd(dxdy)θ=π/3=2k⋅34=32k
Watch outA common mistake is to compute the slope itself at θ=π/3 (which is tan(π/6)=1/3) and then multiply by k, forgetting the extra factor from the chain rule on tan(θ/2). Always differentiate the slope expression fully.
TipThe simplification 1+cosθsinθ=tan2θ is a neat trigonometric shortcut that makes differentiation much cleaner.
✓Final answerThe correct option is (D).
ANSWER: D
- COMEDK 2026Set 2026-M1 markMCQQ.A square plate is contracting at a uniform rate of 2 cm2/min. The rate at which the perimeter is decreasing when the side of the square is 16 cm is: (A) 81 cm/min (B) 41 cm/min (C) 16 cm/min (D) 32 cm/min
›Reveal solutionSolution
The area decreases at a constant rate; we relate the side length to area, differentiate with respect to time, and then find the perimeter’s rate of change. The perimeter decreases at 41 cm/min when the side is 16 cm.
We have a square plate whose area is shrinking at a steady rate of 2 cm2/min. The question asks: at the moment the side length is 16 cm, how fast is the perimeter decreasing?
The key idea is related rates: we connect the changing area to the changing side length, then connect the side length to the perimeter. Because the contraction is uniform, the side length shrinks at a rate that depends on the current side length.
- Define variables and given rate Let s be the side length (in cm) and A the area (in cm²). For a square:
A=s2
We are told:
dtdA=−2(negative because area is decreasing)
- Relate the rates of area and side Differentiate A=s2 with respect to time t:
dtdA=2s⋅dtds
Substitute the known rate:
−2=2s⋅dtds
Solve for dtds:
dtds=−s1
At the instant s=16 cm:
dtds=−161 cm/min
The negative sign confirms the side length is decreasing.
- Find the perimeter’s rate of change Perimeter P=4s. Differentiate:
dtdP=4⋅dtds
Plug in dtds=−161:
dtdP=4×(−161)=−41 cm/min
The negative sign means the perimeter is decreasing. The question asks for the rate at which it is decreasing, so we take the magnitude: 41 cm/min.
Watch outA common mistake is to forget that dtds depends on s — it is not constant. If you incorrectly assume dtds is constant, you might get a wrong answer like 16 or 32 cm/min.
TipNotice that dtds=−s1 means the side shrinks faster when the square is smaller — intuitive, because a fixed area loss is a larger fraction of a small square.
✓Final answerThe correct option is (B).
ANSWER: B
- COMEDK 2024Set 2024-M1 markMCQQ.The side of an equilateral triangle expands at the rate of 3 cm/sec. When the side is 12 cm, the rate of increase of its area is (A) 18 cm2/sec (B) 12 cm2/sec (C) 10 cm2/sec (D) 33 cm2/sec
›Reveal solutionSolution
The area of an equilateral triangle is A=43s2. Differentiating with respect to time gives dtdA=23sdtds. Substituting s=12 cm and dtds=3 cm/s yields dtdA=18 cm²/s, so the correct option is (A).
Concept & Intuition
This is a classic related rates problem. The key idea: when a geometric shape changes size, its area changes at a rate that depends on both its current dimensions and how fast those dimensions are changing. Here, the side length grows at a constant speed, but the area grows faster as the side gets longer because area depends on the square of the side. We connect the rates using calculus — specifically, implicit differentiation with respect to time.
Step-by-step solution
- Write the formula for the area of an equilateral triangle. For an equilateral triangle of side s, the area is
A=43s2.
(Derivation: height =23s, so area =21⋅base⋅height=21⋅s⋅23s=43s2.)
- Differentiate both sides with respect to time t. Since s changes with time, A also changes. Using the chain rule:
dtdA=43⋅2s⋅dtds=23sdtds.
This equation tells us the rate of change of area at any instant, given the side length s and its rate of change dtds.
- Plug in the known values.
We are given:
- dtds=3 cm/s (the side expands at this rate),
- s=12 cm (the side length at the moment we care about). Substituting:
dtdA=23⋅12⋅3=23⋅12⋅3=212⋅3=236=18.
- State the units. Since s is in cm and dtds in cm/s, dtdA comes out in cm²/s. So the rate is 18 cm²/s.
Watch outA common mistake is to forget the factor 43 or to accidentally use the formula for a square (s2) instead of the equilateral triangle. Always double-check the shape’s area formula.
TipNotice that dtdA is proportional to s — so as the triangle grows, the area accelerates even if the side grows at a constant rate. That’s why the answer is larger than you might guess from just multiplying dtds by something simple.
✓Final answerThe correct option is (A).
ANSWER: A
- KCET 2023Set A-21 markMCQQ.A particle moves along the curve 16x2+4y2=1. When the rate of change of abscissa is 4 times that of its ordinate, then the quadrant in which the particle lies is (A) II or IV (B) III or IV (C) II or III (D) I or III
›Reveal solutionSolution
The problem uses implicit differentiation on an ellipse to relate dtdx and dtdy. Setting dtdx=4dtdy leads to a relation between x and y, which together with the ellipse equation gives the possible quadrants. The particle lies in quadrants II or IV.
The curve is an ellipse centered at the origin. The abscissa is x, the ordinate is y. We are told that the rate of change of x is 4 times the rate of change of y — that is, dtdx=4dtdy. The question asks: in which quadrants can the particle be when this condition holds?
The key is to connect the rates through the geometry of the ellipse. Differentiating the ellipse equation with respect to time gives a relation between x, y, dtdx, and dtdy. Substituting the given rate condition then yields a simple linear relation between x and y. The quadrants are determined by the signs of x and y that satisfy both this relation and the ellipse equation.
- Differentiate the ellipse equation implicitly. The curve is 16x2+4y2=1. Differentiating both sides with respect to t:
162xdtdx+42ydtdy=0
Simplify:
8xdtdx+2ydtdy=0
- Substitute the given rate condition. We have dtdx=4dtdy. Replace dtdx:
8x(4dtdy)+2ydtdy=0
2xdtdy+2ydtdy=0
Factor 21dtdy:
21dtdy(x+y)=0
- Interpret the equation. Since the particle is moving, dtdy is not zero (otherwise the condition dtdx=4dtdy would force both rates to zero, meaning the particle is stationary — a trivial case not intended). Therefore:
x+y=0⇒y=−x
So the particle lies on the line y=−x at the moment the condition holds.
- Find the intersection points of the line and the ellipse. Substitute y=−x into 16x2+4y2=1:
16x2+4(−x)2=1
16x2+4x2=1
Common denominator 16:
16x2+4x2=1⇒165x2=1
x2=516⇒x=±54
Then y=−x gives:
- If x=54, then y=−54 → point in quadrant IV (x>0, y<0).
- If x=−54, then y=54 → point in quadrant II (x<0, y>0).
- Check the quadrants. Quadrant I: x>0,y>0 — not possible because y=−x forces opposite signs. Quadrant III: x<0,y<0 — also not possible for the same reason. So only quadrants II and IV occur.
Watch outA common mistake is to forget that dtdy could be zero and then conclude x+y=0 is forced. But if dtdy=0, then dtdx=0 as well, meaning the particle is at rest — which is not the intended dynamic situation. The problem implies motion, so we safely divide by dtdy.
✓Final answerThe particle lies in quadrants II or IV, so the correct option is (A).
🎓Unlock everything free for 14 days
- ✓Full step-by-step solutions
- ✓Concept-first explanations
- ✓Methods, shortcuts & mistakes
- ✓PYQ mapping + timed mock tests
Full access for 14 days. No credit card required.