Q.Let r be the distance of a point on the axis of a bar magnet from its centre. The magnetic field at r is always proportional to (A) 1/r2 (B) 1/r3 (C) 1/r (D) not necessarily 1/r3 at all points
Concept understanding — Magnetic Field of a Bar Magnet
For a point far from a bar magnet (r≫l), the field can be found by analogy with the electric dipole. On the AXIS, at distance r from the centre, Baxis=4πμ0r32m, directed along m; on the perpendicular bisector (the EQUATOR), Beq=4πμ0r3m, directed opposite to m. At the same distance r from the centre, the axial field is always exactly twice the equatorial field, Baxis=2Beq. Nearer the magnet, the exact axial expression is B=4πμ0(r2−l2)22mr, which reduces to the simple 1/r3 dipole law only once r≫l.
At a general point P, neither on the axis nor the equator, the moment m is resolved (about the centre) into a component mcosθ along the position vector r (treated as an "axial" contribution) and a component msinθ perpendicular to r (treated as an "equatorial" contribution), where θ is the angle between r and m. These give Ba=4πμ0r32mcosθ (along r) and Beq=4πμ0r3msinθ (perpendicular to r); since these two contributions are mutually perpendicular, the resultant magnitude is B=4πμ0r3m1+3cos2θ, making an angle α with r given by tanα=21tanθ. This general formula correctly reduces to the pure axial result at θ=0 and the pure equatorial result at θ=90∘.
All of this comes from a single "electrostatic analogue" trick: every magnetic formula here has a matching electric-dipole formula, with the pole strength qm playing the role of charge q and the constant μ0/4π playing the role of 1/4πε0; because the underlying 1/r2 (Coulomb-like force between poles) and 1/r3 (resulting dipole field) mathematics is identical in both cases, every electric-dipole result carries straight over to magnetism.
[!TLDR] The exact axial-field formula for a bar magnet is B=4πμ0(r2−l2)22mr, which reduces to B∝1/r3 only in the far-field limit r≫l -- not at every point on the axis. [!ANSWER] (D) not necessarily 1/r3 at all points
The familiar formula Ba=4πμ0r32m (Eq. 12.3) is derived using the electrostatic dipole ANALOGY, which is valid only in the far-field limit r≫l, where l is the half-length of the magnet. The exact axial field, obtained without that approximation, is B=4πμ0(r2−l2)22mr. Only when r is very much larger than l does (r2−l2)2≈r4, so that this exact expression reduces to r42mr=r32m, giving the familiar inverse-cube law. For a point close to the magnet (comparable to l), the exact denominator (r2−l2)2 departs noticeably from r4, so B is NOT simply proportional to 1/r3 there. Since the question asks what holds true for r in general (not just r≫l), the only fully correct option is that B is not necessarily proportional to 1/r3 at every point on the axis. [!ANSWER] (D) not necessarily 1/r3 at all points
Recall the exact (non-approximated) axial field expression for a finite bar magnet, and compare it with the far-field (r≫l) dipole approximation to see where the 1/r3 law breaks down.
Assuming the familiar B∝1/r3 dipole law holds at every point on the axis, when it is really only the far-field (r≫l) approximation of the exact axial-field formula.