Skip to content
Exercises · 11.2

Q.How can you explain higher stability of BCl3 as compared to TlCl3?

Mahe DhseTextbookSubjectiveImportance★★★★★est
22% · 10/46 Questions
✓ Free question

Step 1 - Boron: no inert pair effect

Boron has configuration 2s22p12s^22p^1 with no intervening d or f electrons; it forms BCl3\text{BCl}_3 by using all three valence electrons in bonding (sp2sp^2 hybridisation), and this +3+3 state is fully stable - there is essentially no inert pair effect at boron's small size/low period.

Step 2 - Thallium: strong inert pair effect

Thallium, a much heavier group 13 element (6s26p16s^26p^1), shows a pronounced inert pair effect: poor shielding by the filled 4f4f and 5d5d subshells means the 6s26s^2 electron pair is held close to the nucleus and is reluctant to participate in bond formation.

Step 3 - Consequence for TlCl3

Consequently Tl+1\text{Tl}^{+1} (using only the single 6p6p electron) is the thermodynamically more stable oxidation state for thallium, while Tl3+\text{Tl}^{3+} compounds such as TlCl3\text{TlCl}_3 are strong oxidising agents that are comparatively unstable and decompose, releasing chlorine and going to the more stable TlCl\text{TlCl}:

TlCl3→TlCl+Cl2\text{TlCl}_3 \rightarrow \text{TlCl} + \text{Cl}_2

Step 4 - Comparison

Hence BCl3\text{BCl}_3 (boron fully using all 3 valence electrons, no inert pair effect) is markedly more stable than TlCl3\text{TlCl}_3 (thallium's 6s26s^2 pair resisting participation, +3 state disfavoured).

✓Final answer

BCl3 is fully stable because boron shows no inert pair effect and uses all 3 valence electrons in bonding. TlCl3 is comparatively unstable because Tl's 6s2 pair resists bonding (inert pair effect), favouring Tl+1; TlCl3 readily decomposes, TlCl3 -> TlCl + Cl2.

Unlock everything free for 14 days

  • Full step-by-step solutions
  • Concept-first explanations
  • Methods, shortcuts & mistakes
  • PYQ mapping + timed mock tests

Full access for 14 days. No credit card required.