Q.(a) Which of the following acids is more stronger? Why? (1 mark) (4-(trifluoromethyl)benzoic acid) Or (4-methylbenzoic acid)
You're viewing a preview — the full solution, concept, methods & PYQ mapping are locked.
Start your 14-day free trial to unlock the full solution →Electron-withdrawing –CF makes the trifluoromethyl acid stronger than the methyl (electron-donating) acid; Clemmensen reduction converts a carbonyl fully to –CH–; formic acid, uniquely among carboxylic acids, still has an aldehydic H and so reduces Tollens' reagent while acetic acid cannot; and aldehydes out-react ketones in nucleophilic addition for combined steric and electronic reasons.
- Which acid is stronger: 4-(trifluoromethyl)benzoic acid or 4-methylbenzoic acid? (4-(trifluoromethyl)benzoic acid) is the stronger acid. Acid strength depends on how well the carboxylate anion (conjugate base) is stabilised after loss of H. The –CF group is strongly electron-withdrawing by induction (–I effect); through the ring it pulls electron density away from the –COO formed, spreading out (stabilising) the negative charge, and so favours ionisation — increasing acid strength. The –CH group, in contrast, is electron-donating (+I effect); it pushes electron density towards –COO, intensifying (destabilising) the negative charge and making the compound a weaker acid than even unsubstituted benzoic acid.
- Clemmensen reaction The Clemmensen reaction reduces the carbonyl group of an aldehyde or ketone completely to a methylene () group, using zinc amalgam [Zn(Hg)] and concentrated hydrochloric acid: Example: acetophenone is reduced to ethylbenzene:
- Why formic acid reduces Tollens' reagent but acetic acid does not Formic acid, , is structurally unique among carboxylic acids: it can be written as , meaning it contains an aldehydic-type C–H bond directly on the carboxyl carbon — it is simultaneously a carboxylic acid and (formally) an aldehyde/reducing agent. This H is oxidisable (formic acid is readily oxidised further to carbonic acid/CO + HO), so it can reduce Tollens' reagent () to metallic silver (a silver mirror): Acetic acid, , has a methyl group (–CH) in place of that reactive hydrogen — there is no aldehydic C–H to oxidise — so it cannot reduce Tollens' reagent.
- Why aldehydes are more reactive than ketones towards nucleophilic addition Two factors, both favouring aldehydes:
- Steric factor: an aldehyde, , has only one bulky group (R) and one small H atom attached to the carbonyl carbon, leaving it relatively open to attack by an incoming nucleophile. A ketone, , has two bulky alkyl/aryl groups, which hinder the approach of the nucleophile to the carbonyl carbon and also crowd the tetrahedral product.
- Electronic factor: alkyl groups are electron-donating (+I effect). In a ketone, two alkyl groups donate electron density into the carbonyl carbon (from both sides), reducing its partial positive charge/electrophilicity more than the single alkyl group of an aldehyde does. A less electrophilic carbonyl carbon is less attractive to a nucleophile.
Together, less steric hindrance and a more electrophilic (less electron-rich) carbonyl carbon make aldehydes react faster and more completely with nucleophiles than ketones.
Alternative (Or):
Only aldehydes lacking an α-hydrogen can undergo the Cannizzaro disproportionation; carboxylic acids are more acidic than phenols because the carboxylate ion's negative charge is delocalised equally over two oxygens, a much more effective resonance stabilisation than phenoxide's ring delocalisation; and the two named reaction sequences give, respectively, propane (via Wolff–Kishner) and benzaldehyde (via Rosenmund reduction).
(e) Which aldehydes undergo the Cannizzaro reaction
Only aldehydes that have no -hydrogen atom (so they cannot undergo aldol condensation) undergo the Cannizzaro reaction — a base-induced self oxidation–reduction (disproportionation) in concentrated alkali, giving one molecule of the corresponding alcohol and one molecule of the carboxylate salt. Examples: formaldehyde (), benzaldehyde (), and trimethylacetaldehyde/pivaldehyde ().
(f) Why carboxylic acids are stronger acids than phenols
Both ionise to give an anion stabilised by resonance, but the quality of that resonance differs greatly:
- In the carboxylate ion, , the negative charge is delocalised equally over two identical, highly electronegative oxygen atoms (two exactly equivalent resonance structures), giving a symmetric, strongly stabilised anion (confirmed experimentally: both C–O bonds in the carboxylate are of equal, intermediate length). …
Unlock everything free for 14 days
- Full step-by-step solutions
- Concept-first explanations
- Methods, shortcuts & mistakes
- PYQ mapping + timed mock tests
Full access for 14 days. No credit card required.