The kinetic energy change of the rocket–gas system comes entirely from the work done by the ejection mechanism. That work equals 21Δmu2, independent of the rocket’s speed.
The key insight is that the ejection device does work only on the gas, not on the rocket directly. The rocket gains kinetic energy because it recoils, but that recoil energy comes from the same work done on the gas — the total system’s KE change is exactly the work input. Gravity is neglected, so no external forces act on the system.
Let’s set it up cleanly.
- System definition and initial state
At time t, the rocket of mass M moves upward with speed v. Its kinetic energy is
KErocket(t)=21Mv2.
No gas has been ejected yet, so the system’s total KE at t is just that:
KEtotal(t)=21Mv2.
- What happens in Δt
The rocket ejects a small mass Δm of gas downward. Relative to the rocket, the gas leaves with speed u downward. So relative to the ground, the gas has velocity
vgas=v−u(downward positive? careful — let’s define upward as positive).
Taking upward as positive: the rocket’s velocity is +v, the gas is ejected downward relative to the rocket, so its ground velocity is
vgas=v−u.
Since u>0, this is less than v; it could even be negative if u>v.
- Rocket’s new speed
By momentum conservation (no external forces), the rocket’s mass becomes M−Δm and its new speed v+Δv. The system’s total momentum is unchanged:
Mv=(M−Δm)(v+Δv)+Δm(v−u).
Expand:
Mv=(M−Δm)v+(M−Δm)Δv+Δmv−Δmu.
The Mv cancels with (M−Δm)v+Δmv, leaving
0=(M−Δm)Δv−Δmu.
So
Δv=M−ΔmΔmu.
For small Δm, this is approximately MΔmu, but we keep the exact form.
- Kinetic energy at t+Δt
The system now has two parts:
- Rocket: mass M−Δm, speed v+Δv
- Gas: mass Δm, speed v−u
So
KEtotal(t+Δt)=21(M−Δm)(v+Δv)2+21Δm(v−u)2.
- Change in kinetic energy
Subtract the initial KE:
ΔKE=21(M−Δm)(v+Δv)2+21Δm(v−u)2−21Mv2.
Expand the first term:
21(M−Δm)(v2+2vΔv+(Δv)2)=21(M−Δm)v2+(M−Δm)vΔv+21(M−Δm)(Δv)2.
The second term:
21Δm(v2−2vu+u2)=21Δmv2−Δmvu+21Δmu2.
Now combine with −21Mv2. Notice 21(M−Δm)v2+21Δmv2=21Mv2, so those cancel. We’re left with:
ΔKE=(M−Δm)vΔv−Δmvu+21(M−Δm)(Δv)2+21Δmu2.
- Substitute Δv
From step 3, Δv=M−ΔmΔmu. Then
(M−Δm)vΔv=(M−Δm)v⋅M−ΔmΔmu=Δmvu.
This exactly cancels the −Δmvu term. Good — the v-dependent terms vanish, as they must because the work done by the ejection device shouldn’t depend on the rocket’s speed.
- Remaining terms
Now
ΔKE=21(M−Δm)(Δv)2+21Δmu2.
Substitute (Δv)2=(M−ΔmΔm)2u2:
21(M−Δm)⋅(M−Δm)2(Δm)2u2=21M−Δm(Δm)2u2.
So …