Skip to content

Physics · Ch 11 — Thermodynamics

Carnot Engine and its Efficiency

11.12

Carnot Engine and its Efficiency

The Carnot engine is an idealised heat engine, conceived by the French engineer Sadi Carnot, built entirely out of reversible steps and operating between only two fixed temperatures: it absorbs heat only while at the higher temperature T1T_1, and rejects heat only while at the lower temperature T2T_2, with no heat exchanged at any other temperature in between. Its working substance is carried through a closed, repeating sequence of exactly four reversible steps, together called the Carnot cycle:

  1. Isothermal expansion at T1T_1 (the working substance is in contact with the hot reservoir throughout): the gas expands slowly, absorbing heat Q1Q_1 from the source, doing work on its surroundings, with its temperature held fixed at T1T_1 throughout (Section 11.7).
  2. Adiabatic expansion: the working substance is thermally isolated and allowed to expand further, doing more work at the expense of its own internal energy, with no heat exchanged, so its temperature falls smoothly from T1T_1 down to T2T_2 (Section 11.8).
  3. Isothermal compression at T2T_2 (now in contact with the cold reservoir): the gas is compressed slowly, rejecting heat Q2Q_2 to the sink, with work now being done on the gas, at the fixed lower temperature T2T_2.
  4. Adiabatic compression: the working substance is again thermally isolated and compressed further, with work done on it raising its temperature back up smoothly from T2T_2 to exactly T1T_1 -- returning it precisely to its original starting state, and closing the cycle.

On a PP-VV diagram, these four steps trace out a closed, curved, roughly leaf-shaped loop (Fig. 1); because the working substance returns to its original state after step 4, ΔU=0\Delta U = 0 over the complete cycle, so by the first law the net work done by the engine over one full cycle, W=Q1−Q2W = Q_1 - Q_2, is exactly equal to the area enclosed by this closed loop.

Efficiency of the Carnot engine. Working out the heat exchanged during the two isothermal steps (using the isothermal work/heat formula of Section 11.7) and the temperature relations for the two adiabatic steps (using the adiabatic equations of Section 11.8) together, the volume ratios in the two isothermal legs turn out to be related by the two adiabatic legs in such a way that everything but the temperatures cancels out, leaving the strikingly simple result

Q2Q1=T2T1\frac{Q_2}{Q_1} = \frac{T_2}{T_1}

so that the efficiency of a Carnot engine, from η=1−Q2/Q1\eta = 1 - Q_2/Q_1, works out to

ηCarnot=1−T2T1\eta_{\text{Carnot}} = 1 - \frac{T_2}{T_1}

where T1T_1 and T2T_2 must be expressed on an absolute (kelvin) temperature scale for this formula to be valid. Note that this efficiency depends only on the two operating temperatures T1T_1 and T2T_2, and not at all on the particular working substance used, nor on any detail of how the engine is built -- a remarkable and very general result. …

Figure 1P-V diagram of the Carnot cycle, showing all four steps

What this figure shows. A P-V diagram (pressure on the vertical axis, volume on the horizontal axis) showing a closed, roughly leaf-shaped loop made of four curves meeting at four labelled corner points A, B, C and D, traversed clockwise starting from the top-left point A. From A to B (upper curve, the shallower of the two upper curves, moving right and down): isothermal expansion at the higher temperature T1, labelled 'A to B: isothermal expansion at T1, absorbs Q1'. From B to C (continuing right and down, now the steeper curve): adiabatic expansion, labelled 'B to C: adiabatic expansion, Q = 0, cools from T1 to T2'. From C to D (lower curve, moving left and up, shallower curve at the lower temperature): isothermal compression at the lower temperature T2, labelled 'C to D: isothermal compression at T2, rejects Q2'. From D back to A (steeper curve, moving left and up, closing the loop): adiabatic compression, labelled 'D to A: adiabatic compression, Q = 0, heats back from T2 to T1'. The enclosed ar …